Perioperative nurse leaders play a critical role in ensuring that patients receive the best surgical care. In rural communities, however, access to such care can be limited. As L D Britt, MD, MPH, noted in a statement to the American College of Surgeons’ Committee on Optimal Care: “There is no quality without access.”
According to the US Department of Agriculture, nearly 46 million Americans—14% of the population—live in rural communities. These residents often struggle to get needed health and surgical services because access to care is limited in rural areas throughout the country. Geographic isolation and low patient volumes are persistent challenges for rural hospitals.
Many small, outlying facilities are now coming to grips with the financial impact of COVID-19, increased regulations, and an opioid crisis. To protect access to healthcare, many have opted to consolidate with larger health systems, enter other partnerships, or restructure service offerings. At least one analysis showed that 147 rural hospitals have eliminated services or closed altogether from 2010 to 2019.
Rural hospital acquisitions have accelerated in the past 2 decades, and their impact on access to surgical care has been a recent topic of debate. Mergers can provide rural hospitals with needed financial resources, specialty care expertise, and access to innovative technologies. A 2021 JAMA Network Open article by Jiang et al suggests that rural hospital acquisitions bring about improved patient outcomes.
Some acquisitions, however, fail. The Private Equity Stakeholder Project published a January 2023 report, titled “Private Equity Descends on Rural Healthcare,” warning that private equity firms are exploiting rural health centers. It includes six case studies of failed rural hospital acquisitions. After the buyouts, quality of care and access to services deteriorated in those communities.
After a successful buyout, improvement has been seen in care quality, expanded services, physician coverage, and perioperative support.
Barbara Nosek, director of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC) supply chain management implementation team, played a key role in UPMC’s acquisition of several rural facilities. She explains that postpandemic conditions are dire everywhere. “The past couple of years have been very hard,” Nosek says. “Numbers, volumes, they’re starting to pick back up for surgeries, but in some facilities they have not.” Nosek adds that when the rural hospital where she worked was acquired by UPMC, she and colleagues saw many positive effects that improved care quality.
Dana Kopera, MBA, BSN, RN, CNOR, director of surgical and perioperative services, wound care, and medical outpatient services at UPMC Altoona/Bedford, agrees with Nosek that the UPMC acquisition was positive. “It was a win in our community,” Kopera says. The acquisition of UPMC Altoona led to better care quality through service expansion, added physician coverage, and support for perioperative teams.
After merging with a larger health system, UPMC Altoona was able to offer more specialized programs. “I can say as a community member and hospital employee, we expanded our services,” Nosek recalls. “Now we have posttransplant clinics, telemedicine for specialized care, and other services that we never had before.”
Access to care also increased by way of affiliations with larger programs. “Our cancer center became affiliated with the renowned UPMC Hillman Cancer Center,” explains Nosek. “We now follow all Hillman protocols. The women’s and birth centers became Magee Women’s, which is also renowned in our state. We now have access to telemedicine for our high-risk OB patients.”
In addition to broadening specialized programs and services, rural hospital acquisitions help to fill gaps in hard-felt physician shortages. “In our small town, we have one neurosurgeon,” says Nosek. “When he’s out, the department sends someone to cover. Same thing with our vascular group. So if the surgeon goes on vacation or has an emergency, we need a backup. Now, we have much better support, especially for specialties with few providers.”
Kopera agrees with Nosek. “We have physicians from Pittsburgh coming here to do surgery on certain days; that is a really positive benefit, to not only those of us here in the hospital, but to our community as well.”
Perioperative nurse teams were also bolstered by the rural hospital acquisition. “I felt like we had a lot of support [in the merger],” Kopera tells OR Manager. “With a bigger system came a lot of standardization, from policies and service lines to supply chain. I think that kind of streamlines things—having standardized procedures and resources.”
Merging with a larger health network can be particularly beneficial for perioperative leaders in rural facilities. “From a leadership perspective, OR directors to periop anesthesia leaders, each has their own group that you can reach out to for support,” Kopera says. “You know if you have a question, that there is a group of peers doing the same thing you are available to help.”
Acquisitions can enable funding for new technology. Rural hospitals often struggle to invest in new equipment and systems because of limited resources. When a rural facility merges with a large health system, it can receive capital to upgrade current, often outdated, systems. Investments resulting in greater efficiency and fewer complications lead to better outcomes for surgical patients.
As a result of the UPMC acquisition, Kopera’s hospital was able to add service lines and providers. “We started robotics,” Kopera recalls. “We got the DaVinci system and were able to start bringing in doctors and patients for those surgeries.”
In addition to new equipment, the facility was able to upgrade its health records system. “When you’re acquired, you’re usually given a pot of capital money,” Nosek explains. “For instance, they say, ‘We’re giving you $20 million because we know you need to have a new EHR [electronic health record] for us to have the same EHR.’ They’re giving you money toward investments that you must make for interoperability.”
According to Nosek, financial assistance for many rural hospital acquisitions is exciting. “For the hospitals we’ve integrated—and we’ve acquired some critical access hospitals—it is a big deal,” she says. “We had one that couldn’t buy furniture for their waiting rooms. They were excited about the new furniture, as well as building maintenance. For what I consider ‘very rural’ communities, with different reimbursement models, it is a game changer and keeps them open in their communities.”
When rural hospitals are backed by resources and funding from a buyout, they may be better positioned for staffing, recruiting, and retention. “I think that the name may attract people to the interviews,” explains Nosek. “But we are still a small town. So, some vacancies are still hard to fill.”
The greater the distance between a rural facility and a city, the more difficult it can be to attract and retain healthcare professionals. Smaller rural communities frequently offer lower pay and fewer opportunities for advancement. When a rural hospital is purchased, it may be able to offer more competitive salaries and benefits to employees, making it more appealing to potential recruits. A surgical unit that is well-staffed is better equipped to provide high-quality care.
“Recruitment is always a challenge,” says Nosek. “It can be hard to recruit because you’re not just recruiting the doctor; you’re recruiting the spouse and the children. There’s the impact on the family to consider when you’re coming to a small town.” Looking back on the UPMC merger, the benefits post-buyout are easy to see. But there were still challenges. “We went through a huge record transition. Every EHR in the hospital changed. Our local policies, everything had to be integrated,” Kopera recalls.
Getting acquainted with new names, faces, policies, and systems was also difficult, Nosek adds. Some employees were dissatisfied with the changes and resigned as a result. “Some people said, even in the OR: ‘I’m not learning a new EHR,’” she says. “It’s not that they saw and hated it. It was, ‘I don’t even want to go down that road.’ They decided to retire or leave, and that’s ok.
“Everything changes—from the coffee served in the cafeteria, to the software applications, to the email address. Everything you can imagine is likely to change in some way,” explains Nosek of hospital acquisitions. “Those who struggle with change do struggle.”
“It took time,” Kopera recalls. “Nothing happened overnight obviously, but now everything is more streamlined.”
Rural hospital acquisitions can improve patient access to surgical care. Furthermore, a recent study showed that rural hospitals offering more surgical services seemed to have more predictable profits. Integration with large health systems can result in service expansion, funding for new technologies, and staff recruitment and retention opportunities. With an uptick in rural healthcare acquisitions and mergers, it is critical for perioperative nurse leaders to stay informed about challenges in rural healthcare and efforts to ensure that all patients, regardless of where they live, have access to the best surgical care possible.
According to a January report, 631 rural hospitals, more than 29% of all hospitals in the US, are on the verge of closing this year. Nosek mentions that other facilities have contacted UPMC about joining the system. “It will be interesting to see” future rural hospital acquisitions, she says.
—Sarah Falcone, BSN, RN, educates readers as nurse manager and health content writer in Fort Worth, Texas.
Hoskins N N, Cunicelli M A, Hopper W, et al. The value surgical services bring to critical access hospitals. Cureus. 2021;13(4):e14367.
Rural hospital closures. The Sheps Center for Health Services Research (UNC). Updated in real time.
Rural hospitals at risk of closing. Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform. January 2023.