Access to quality care in rural areas has been making headlines since the pandemic began. The issue of ensuring appropriate access to services in rural and community hospitals is not a new concern. But with the unprecedented number of shutdowns—not only of certain departments and service lines but also total closure of hospitals—that has been occurring recently, access to quality care in rural areas has gained renewed attention.
In this issue, this topic is explored in the feature article, “How rural hospital acquisitions are impacting surgical care access” (cover). Cited in the article are the two following statistics:
This is indicative of a larger trend. In February 2018, OR Manager reported that over 750 hospitals had been acquired or merged between 2008 and 2014. According to the American Hospital Association (AHA), 1,887 hospital mergers were announced between 1998 and 2021, which has reduced the number of hospitals in the US from about 8,000 to just over 6,000.
Again, this is not new, but mergers and acquisitions (M&A) and other consolidation efforts in healthcare are undoubtedly becoming more common as hospitals and health systems continue to struggle to remain profitable.
AHA maintains that M&A “can help hospitals improve access to care by broadening the types of specialists or services…available to patients,” citing a Kaufman Hall analysis that showed “nearly 40% of affiliated hospitals added one or more services postacquisition.” Other experts disagree and believe this trend is not great for access to quality care in more remote areas.
“There are…indications that consolidation will reduce access to healthcare for the most vulnerable populations through hospital closures and higher prices in highly consolidated markets,” said David Grande, MD, MPA, director of policy at the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, when he moderated a panel, titled “Unpacking consolidation in healthcare,” earlier this year.
“The unfortunate reality is that more than 25 years of market-driven health facility consolidation has really left too many communities across the US without timely access to needed care,” said Lois Uttley, MPP, in the same panel. Uttley is former senior advisor of the Hospital Equity and Accountability Project and has experience analyzing healthcare public policies. “Acquiring systems often move to close services like intensive care, labor and delivery, psychiatric care, and cardiac surgery. It forces people to travel out of their communities and poses serious…issues for patients, especially those who are disabled, elderly, non-English speaking, and without their own cars,” she continued.
Another panelist, Leemore Dafny, PhD, professor of Business Administration at the Harvard Business School, Boston, and former deputy director for healthcare and antitrust of the Federal Trade Commission’s Bureau of Economics, added: “When [hospital] rivals merge, prices increase, and there’s scant evidence of improvements in the quality of care that patients receive. There’s…a fair amount of evidence that quality of care decreases.”
Beyond the obvious financial incentive behind most M&A activity in healthcare, the implications for access to surgical care may be more positive. As the 2018 OR Manager article, titled “Planning can relieve ‘growing pains’ of hospital mergers,” and the follow-up rural hospital acquisitions article in this issue explore, there are key benefits that follow M&A, including:
• More technological innovation: merging with a larger health system can increase access to robotics, electronic health record systems, and other advanced software.
• More specialization: it can also increase expertise in some areas and even introduce new specialized service lines to a hospital’s services, though nonsurgical departments might not experience the same.
• More efficiency: day-to-day operations within policies and procedures, metrics, performance evaluations, and inventory counts can be streamlined and better supported.
It is not ‘one-size fits all’; what may be the answer to better quality care for one department might be a detriment to another department or specialty. Rashid Syed, MBA, ACHE, managing partner of North Houston Surgical Hospitals, Texas, opined in an interview earlier this year with Becker’s Hospital Review that “the best approach towards improving rural healthcare is to segregate…services from one large hospital system to nimbler healthcare facilities, making it more approachable and personable…by creating urgent care centers, surgery centers, specialty microhospitals for mild to moderate complexity elective and nonelective treatments, and keeping larger hospitals for higher complexity, longer complicated treatments.”
Not surprisingly, access to ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) in rural areas is also challenging. A 2021 ASC accessibility report explored the geographical distribution of ASCs throughout the US and ranked states by the average number of residents that an ASC can serve in each state. While rural access was not the sole factor in the ranking, Maryland ranked number 1 as the state with the biggest concentration of ASCs (some 16,000 potential patients per ASC), and other states with major urban cities also topped the list.
The two states ranked last were West Virginia at 49 (some 140,000 potential patients per ASC) and Vermont at 50 (more than 300,000 potential patients per ASC). Of Vermont, “a mostly rural state,” the report noted that given its population, “ASCs in Vermont have to serve nearly 20 times more potential patients than ASCs in Maryland.”
The report further noted many rural regions in the US have no ASCs within easy reach. ASCs do same-day surgical procedures, so “living too far away makes driving to and from the facility in a single day burdensome, if not impossible.” In another ranking, this time looking at states with the longest drives to the nearest ASC (average miles per resident), it found that “residents in primarily rural states…have to drive, on average, more than 25 miles to reach the nearest ASC.” Alaska topped the list with an average distance of 55 miles.
Rural access to quality care is bound to remain a much debated topic. Whether in the publication, the website, or conferences, OR Manager will continue to monitor this critical issue for data updates and new expert commentary.
—Tarsilla Moura
Ambulatory Surgery Center accessibility in the USA. AcuityMD. April 12, 2021.
Muhammad M, Dyrda L. What will save rural healthcare? Becker’s Hospital Review. January 25, 2023.
Saver C. Planning can relieve ‘growing pains’ of hospital mergers. OR Manager. 2018;34(2):1,7-12.