September 20, 2018

Don’t let burnout get the best of you

By: Elizabeth Wood
Share

Burnout and resiliency are addressed at nearly every major healthcare conference these days, and research on burnout ties it to adverse effects on healthcare providers as well as their patients.

Bernadette Melnyk, PhD, RN, APRN-CNP, FNAAP, FNAP, FAAN

According to Bernadette Melnyk, PhD, RN, APRN-CNP, FNAAP, FNAP, FAAN, vice president for health promotion and university chief wellness officer, Ohio State University (OSU), more than half of practicing nurses and physicians across the US exhibit at least one symptom of burnout.

“Nearly one out of five nurses leave their profession in their first year of employment, and one in three leave for good by the end of year 2,” Melnyk says. “In 2016, almost half of physicians in America said they planned to reduce their work hours, leave clinical positions, or retire within the next 3 years. Both evidence-based practice and clinicians’ well-being are necessary if our healthcare systems are going to reach the Quadruple Aim.” (The Quadruple Aim adds improving the clinician experience to the Triple Aim goals of improving the patient experience of care and the health of populations while lowering costs.)

Results of a survey published in NEJM Catalyst likewise raise concerns about burnout. The survey went to members of the NEJM Catalyst Insights Council—healthcare executives, clinical leaders, and clinicians. A total of 83% of the 703 respondents said they consider physician burnout a “serious” or “moderate” problem in their organizations. A total of 78% of respondents said burnout is a serious problem for registered nurses, and 64% believe that’s also true of advanced practice nurses.

“We have found the drivers of physician burnout to be workload, work/life balance, cognitive dissonance, and clerical work, while nurses more often suffer burnout due to compassion fatigue, moral distress, and work environment issues such as psychological safety and hostility,” the authors say.

Burnout—the state of emotional exhaustion and depersonalization—is associated with lower patient satisfaction, higher infection rates, more medication errors, shorter lifespan, more personal injury, and more illness, according to J. Bryan Sexton, MD, director, patient safety center, Duke University Health System, Durham, North Carolina.

Dr Sexton, who has done extensive research on burnout, cites these signs of burnout:

  • You try to be everything to everyone.
  • You feel you are not making a meaningful difference.
  • You feel the work you are doing is not recognized.
  • You lack work-life balance.
  • Your job varies between monotony and chaos.
  • You feel you have little or no control over your work.
  • You work in healthcare.

 

Numbers don’t lie

“We all know cardiovascular disease is the number one killer of Americans, but considering all causes of death and disease, behaviors are truly number one,” Melnyk says. One out of two people have a chronic condition, she notes, but 80% of chronic conditions are preventable with healthy lifestyle behaviors such as eating well, being physically active, and not smoking.

A 2012 Gallup poll found that, compared with physicians, nurses had higher smoking rates, ate less well, and had higher rates of obesity, cholesterol, diabetes, and depression. Data based on 1,984 physicians and 7,166 nurses were collected between January 2, 2011 and August 31, 2012.

Results of research by Melnyk and colleagues published in February 2018 shows that, among 1,790 practicing nurses, back pain and musculoskeletal disorders affected 30% of respondents, followed by high cholesterol, high blood pressure, and arthritis. “Depression was reported in about 23% of this sample. That’s 9% higher than what the Gallup poll study found in 2012,” Melnyk says.

In fact, she notes, this research is the first study to show that depression is the leading predictor of medical errors. Nurses in poor physical or mental health had a 26% to 71% higher likelihood of medical errors. “We also found that the longer the shift work, the more errors were made, and the poorer their health,” she says.

“We also looked at nurses’ lifestyle behaviors. Only 17% were meeting the recommended five servings of fruits and vegetables daily, and only half were getting 7 hours of sleep a night. Only 27% were getting the recommended minutes of physical activity per week, and 13% were drinking alcohol four or more times per week.”

Nurses who had higher levels of education and were married met the targeted physical activity recommendations. Those who worked longer shifts did not.

“We have so much evidence to support that 12-hour shifts are not good for our clinicians or the health and safety of our patients,” Melnyk says.

Not surprisingly, the researchers found that nurses working in places that supported wellness had less stress and better health outcomes, she adds.

 

National initiatives promote clinician well-being

Interventions

Systems and infrastructure enhancements, such as improvements in electronic medical records and other information technology systems, were among the interventions suggested by NEJM Catalyst survey respondents. Just over half (51%) of respondents said that practicing self-care could effectively guard against burnout.

Researchers at the Duke University Patient Safety Center have conducted studies of the “Three Good Things” intervention, developed by clinical psychologist Martin Seligman, PhD, which involves keeping a daily record of three positive experiences. A 2005 study by Seligman et al. found that over time, people who do this become happier.

“We are hard-wired to remember the negative. It’s easier to remember the heartbreaking moments at work each day than it is to remember the heartwarming moments,” Dr Sexton says. Studies have shown that people have enhanced recall of material during their last 2 wakeful hours each day, he notes, and regular practice of Three Good Things increases the tendency to notice more positive things.

According to Dr Sexton, an internal medicine resident study at Duke found dramatically improved results and a much greater level of resilience among those who participated in the Three Good Things exercise:

  • lower burnout
  • less depression
  • fewer delays
  • less conflict
  • better work-life balance.

Dr Sexton was a co-author of a 2017 study of 32 healthcare professionals who work in a neonatal intensive care unit. Their responses to the Three Good Things exercise identified three main themes that offer a pillar on which to build additional resilience interventions for healthcare workers:

  • having a good day at work
  • having supportive relationships
  • making meaningful use of self-determined time.

The authors note that the last item relates to focusing on self-care and self-reflection, which is something many healthcare workers find difficult to do. “While self-care bolsters healthcare professionals’ ability to rebound from adversity and overcome difficult circumstances, many downplay its importance,” they say. “If healthcare workers are not given the opportunity to attend to their own needs, while cultivating positive emotions, we might miss an important opportunity to build resilience in a vital group at risk for burnout.”

A number of organizations have launched initiatives at the national level, which attests to the growing recognition of burnout as a serious issue (sidebar above right).

 

Cultivating resiliency

There is a relationship between burnout and moral distress, and a program called MEPRA (the Mindful Ethical Practice and Resilience Academy), developed at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland, has helped clinicians build moral resiliency. MEPRA was created by Cynda Hylton Rushton, PhD, RN, FAAN, to help nurses learn mindful practices and give them the tools to cope with ethical issues in clinical practice. Rushton is the Anne and George L. Bunting Professor of Clinical Ethics at Johns Hopkins.

MEPRA, which launched in spring 2016, is also designed to cultivate mindfulness, ethical competence, and resilience in response to ethical challenges and moral suffering.

Through a series of six 4-hour workshops, MEPRA participants practice techniques such as meditation to increase their mindfulness and develop confidence in discussing ethical issues with physicians or patients. They also work with trained actors who simulate clinical encounters to allow participants to practice their communication skills in a realistic environment.

More than 150 staff nurses from several different departments, including medical/surgical, critical care, psychiatry, and pediatrics, have participated in the MEPRA training. Their mean age was 32 years, and they spent an average of 6 years in nursing. After completion of the course, preliminary trends indicate improved work engagement, moral competence, and perceived confidence, according to Rushton. The MEPRA team is currently analyzing the pre- and post-program evaluation data.

“There is no quick fix to burnout, but there are ways that nurses can support their well-being by building greater mindfulness skills,” Rushton told OR Manager. She also suggests creating new patterns for starting and ending each work day. For example, she says, pausing before entering a patient’s room, and using your time and energy more intentionally can make daily practice more meaningful. Similarly, thinking at the end of the day about the good that has been done, rather than what is left undone or what went wrong, helps to bring more positive energy into the moment.

When it comes to ethical challenges, she says, nurse leaders can acknowledge that moral distress is a common response to moral adversity. “They can be proactive in detecting the signals that indicate nurses at the frontline are struggling with ethical concerns,” she says. When people ask, “why are we doing this?” she says that’s a signal that ethical values are threatened and need to be discussed.

 

University of Utah experience

Staff at the University of Utah Health in Salt Lake City have developed a Resiliency Center to “support the Quadruple Aim of healthcare by promoting faculty and staff wellness through advocacy, collaboration, and innovative programming focused on individual and system resilience,” say the authors of a recent Joint Commission journal article.

The center ties together wellness initiatives in different areas of the system and is based on four pillars:

  • wellness initiatives, which include a mindfulness-based stress reduction class and designated champions across the system who advocate for wellness
  • communication skills, which currently consists of a day-long course with interactive didactic sessions and practice sessions with actors in the role of patients
  • peer support, which includes a program that provides support during adverse clinical events or other stressful situations
  • an on-site Employee Assistance Program to offer brief counseling services and referrals along with flexible hours to make it readily available to staff.

“We believe the emotional effects of working in the healthcare environment are far-reaching among staff, but little has been studied for non-physician employees,” say the authors. “Traumatic and stressful events will always be a part of healthcare; how we address these events on a personal and team level is essential to the success of our healthcare system.”

The Resiliency Center is in its infancy and development is ongoing, the authors note. They anticipate adding evidence-based interventions at the organizational level and measuring the impact of each initiative.

 

Ohio State University experience

“Our hospitals and healthcare systems must create a wellness culture where healthy lifestyle behaviors are the norm,” Melnyk says. “You can have great coaches, but if the leaders aren’t supporting this, those behaviors will not be sustained. Leader and middle manager role modeling is critical as well as grass roots initiatives.”

OSU is a big university with more than 65,000 students, 46,000 faculty and staff, seven hospitals, and 14 primary care practices, according to Melnyk. Under her leadership, the “One University Health and Wellness Council” was created to bring together leaders from the different health and wellness units, form a strategic plan, and implement that plan as one OSU wellness team.

“We have evidence-based interventions that focus on the individual, family, and social network, the workplace culture and environment, and policy,” Melnyk says. “We track outcomes because if we find we’re slipping back on an important outcome, we have to go back to the drawing board and figure out what is not working.” She says there has been a 7% improvement in population cardiovascular health and a decrease in employees with pre-diabetes.

Some 30% to 40% of medical, nursing, and other health sciences students have elevated rates of depressive symptoms when they start their programs at OSU, according to Melnyk. A wellness onboarding program for all of the health sciences students was started about 4 years ago that included an evidence-based cognitive behavioral skills building program, she says. Since then, improvements in depressive symptoms and healthy lifestyle behaviors have been seen in these students.

The kinds of improvements experienced at OSU have also yielded a savings of more than $15 million in the past year, she adds, noting that OSU’s healthcare spend is -1.4% compared with 4.3% in other organizations nationwide.

Her criteria for a successful wellness program include:

  • having senior leaders who invest in a wellness structure and resources, and who role model healthy lifestyle behaviors
  • having a comprehensive strategy aimed at building a culture of well-being
  • focusing on employee stress
  • tracking metrics
  • communicating frequently.

“A wellness program really does have a great return on investment,” she says. “If you are willing to invest in these types of programs, you’ll get savings. You’ll have clinicians and employees who will be happy, healthy, and engaged, and they’ll provide more high-quality, safe care,” she says.

 

Upcoming events

OSU will host the inaugural National Summit on Promoting Well Being and Resilience in Healthcare Providers on September 26-28 (www.clinicanwellbeing.osu.edu), and the 4th National Summit on Building Healthy Academic Communities on April 30 – May 1, 2019 (www.healthyacademics.org).

And at the OR Manager Conference (September 17-19 in Nashville, Tennessee), Jane McLeod, MSN, RN, cofounder of Capstone Leadership Solutions, Inc, in Sault Ste Marie, Michigan, will relate her journey from burnout to resiliency during a breakfast session: “Grace Under Fire: The Resilient Nurse Leader.” To learn more, visit www.ormanagerconference.com.

 

References

Castellucci, M. IHI forms nationwide patient safety committee. Modern Healthcare. Published online May 22, 2018.

http://www.modernhealthcare.com/article/20180522/TRANSFORMATION02/180529996?utm_source=modernhealthcare&utm_medium=email&utm_content=20180522-TRANSFORMATION02-180529996&utm_campaign=am

http://www.healthleadersmedia.com/quality/new-collaborative-tackles-clinician-burnout?utm_source=edit&utm_medium=ENL&utm_campaign=HLM-Spotlight-POP-SilverPop_05022018&spMailingID=13422238&spUserID=MTY3ODg4NjQ2MjI0S0&spJobID=1400094415&spReportId=MTQwMDA5NDQxNQS2

https://nam.edu/initiatives/clinician-resilience-and-well-being/

https://psnet.ahrq.gov/perspectives/perspective/190/burnout-among-health-professionals-and-its-effect-on-patient-safety

https://psnet.ahrq.gov/perspectives/perspective/143/in-conversation-with–j-bryan-sexton-phd-ma

https://www.medpagetoday.com/publichealthpolicy/generalprofessionalissues/72551

https://rising.jhu.edu/moral-resilience-nursing-cynda-rushton

Gazelle G, Liebschutz J M, Reiss H. Physician burnout: Coaching a way out. J Gen Intern Med. 2015;30(4), 50-513. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4371007/

Melnyk B. Optimizing the health & well-being of clinicians: Evidence-based strategies for success. American Hospital Association webinar. May 10, 2018.

Melnyk B, Orsolini L, Alai T, et al. A national study links nurses’ physical and mental health to medical errors and perceived worksite wellness. J Occupat Environ Med. 2018;60(2), 126-131.

Seligman M E P, Steen T A, Park N, et al. Positive psychology in progress. Empirical validation of interventions. Am Psychol. 2005;60:410-421. https://howtobehappy.guru/Positive-Psychology-Progress.pdf

Morrow E, Call M, Marcus R, et al. Focus on the Quadruple Aim: Development of a Resiliency Center to promote faculty and staff wellness initiatives. J Qual Pat Safety. 2018;44:293-298.

Sexton B. Perioperative research, preventing burnout, and improving resilience. AORN Global Surgical Conference & Expo. 2018.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat