Financial difficulties are challenging more managers of ambulatory surgery centers (ASC) this year, according to results of the 20th annual OR Manager Salary/ Career Survey.
Much of the change can be attributed to reduced case volume and changes in Medicare reimbursement for ASCs.
More than a third (34%) of respondents reported lower volume, compared with 15% 2 years ago, and elective surgery is down, too. In all, 43% reported financial difficulties because of the current economic condition. More than two-thirds attributed those difficulties to changes in Medicare reimbursement.
“We’ve seen the end of the 4-year transition phase for Medicare changes, which sheltered some of the higher volume procedures from drastic cuts in years past,” said Marie Edler, director of reimbursement policy for the ASC Association.
As a result, the survey found many managers are reconsidering or postponing capital expenditures, particularly for OR technology.
The OR Manager Salary/Career Survey was mailed in March to 1,000 OR Manager subscribers and an external list of nurse managers of ASCs, with 182 usable responses for an 18% response rate. The margin of error is ±6.7% at the 95% confidence level. Results from the staffing portion of the survey appeared in the September issue.
The 43% of ASCs that have experienced financial difficulties from the economic downturn is significantly higher than last year’s 31%. The most common source of those difficulties is a decline in surgical volume, reported by 81% of respondents, compared with 90% last year. Edler attributes the decline to the weak economy, which is causing people to postpone elective surgery, and the increase in high-deductible plans being chosen by employers, causing many patients to put off or decide not to have procedures.

ASCs experiencing problems with changes in Medicare reimbursement jumped dramatically from 39% last year to 68% in 2010, and 8% reported a lack of available credit.
More than one-third (36%) reported a decrease in overall surgical volume in the past 6 months, with those reporting an increase or a steady volume both at 32%.
Respondents note they are fighting back on volume. “Adding on new doctors,” said one. “We must be the ‘partner of choice.'” Some report success, as the manager who noted, “maintaining patient volume with decreasing revenue.” Another said, “increased net income despite decreased case volume.” Other respondents have even expanded services.
For respondents (40%) who are reconsidering or postponing capital expenditures, areas hardest hit are OR technology and equipment (78%) and information technology (50%, significantly more than the 34% in 2009).
Despite economic constraints, many ASCs are moving forward with new projects, with some reporting expansion. “Opened 3 new centers [in] 3 new markets,” said one respondent.
ASC managers are also working to boost productivity to meet economic challenges. Asked to name their greatest improvement in the past year, a number wrote in “decrease in overtime,” “efficiencies with on-time starts and turnover of rooms,” and “converting from a paper charting system to an EHR [electronic health record].”
| 2010 | 2008 | 2006 | |
| Increased | 21% | 35% | 57% |
| Decreased | 34% | 15% | 14% |
| Remained about the same | 45% | 50% | 29% |
On average, ASC managers earn less than their hospital OR counterparts.
| ASC | Hospital | |
| Salary | $86,700 | $109,000 |
| Total compensation | $105,000 | $132,000 |
ASC managers in corporate-owned facilities earn the most, followed by those in joint-venture and physician-owned centers.
Benefits. Across the board, ASC managers consistently have fewer benefits than hospital OR managers and directors.
| ASC | Hospital | |
| Paid time-off | 99% | 100% |
| Health ins | 92% | 97% |
| 401(k) plan | 87% | 86% |
| Life insurance | 77% | 89% |
| Dental ins | 70% | 91% |
| Disability ins | 60% | 78% |
| Eye care | 53% | 68% |
| Dependent health ins | 49% | 69% |
| Education benefits | 45% | 55% |
| Tuition reimb | 35% | 78% |
| Pension | 16% | 48% |
About 8 in 10 (79%) reported having a bonus/profit sharing program compared with less than half (46%) of hospital OR managers and directors. In all, 10% reported losing benefits in the past 6 months, lower than the 19% for hospital OR managers and directors.
The average raise for ASC managers was 3.7%, comparable with 3.5% for hospital OR managers and directors. But the 2 groups saw a marked difference in the number who received bonuses or profit sharing during the past 12 months—70% for ASC respondents versus 33% for hospital OR respondents. ASC managers’ bonus amounts were lower, however, averaging $6,530, less than the $8,060 for hospital OR directors and managers.
ASC managers have an average of 26.1 days of paid time off a year.
| Annual salary | Total compensation | |
| By number of ORs | ||
| <5 ORs | $82,700 | $98,000 |
| 5+ ORs | $101,500 | $130,000 |
| By ownership | ||
| Physician owned | $80,700 | $99,000 |
| Corporate owned | $94,700 | $116,000 |
| Joint venture | $91,100 | $109,000 |
| By title | ||
| Administrator/admin director | $99,000 | $119,000 |
| Nurse manager | $79,500 | $98,000 |
More than half (52%) of respondents’ ASCs are in suburban areas, followed by urban (31%) and rural (15%) locales. The average annual case volume is 4,410.
As in previous years, most respondents (45%) work in physician-owned ASCs. A quarter work in joint-venture ASCs, a fifth in corporate-owned facilities, and only 8% in hospital-owned centers. Nearly two-thirds (63%) of respondents work in multispecialty centers. Most single specialty ASCs were physician-owned (75%), while multispecialty ASCs were fairly evenly split between joint-venture (34%), hospital-owned (27%), and physician-owned (26%) facilities.
The top specialties for single-specialty ASCs were ophthalmology (37%), orthopedics (19%), gastroenterology (16%), and cosmetic/plastic surgery (10%).
Facility size. ASC managers oversee an average of 3.7 ORs, basically the same as last year’s 3.8, with variations according to type of ownership. Those in single-specialty centers oversee an average of 2.5 ORs, compared with 4.5 for those in multispecialty ASCs, and respondents in physician-owned centers oversee 2.7 ORs, compared with 4.5 for other types of ownership.
Scope of responsibility. ASC managers supervise an average of 23.7 FTEs, including an average of 19.5 clinical FTEs and 4.2 nonclinical FTEs. That’s much less than the average of 111 FTEs for hospital OR directors and managers.
One-third of respondents report their title to be administrator or administrative director, with the remainder split fairly evenly among director of nursing (22%), nurse manager (19%), and clinical director (16%).
More than a third (36%) report to administration, 20% to physician owners, and only 14% to a board of directors.
Budget. The average ASC annual operating budget is $4.7 million. More than half of respondents, primarily those with the title of nurse manager, didn’t know.

| ASC budgets by ownership | |
| Joint venture | $6.2 million |
| Corporate | $5.1 million |
| Physician | $2.5 million |
Although more than half (54%) of respondents said their budgets stayed the same in the past 6 months, 14% experienced a decrease, and 13% reported an increase.
Budgets remain a primary focal point for managers. “We made budget in a tight economy,” said one respondent. Another reported “cost and payroll savings of 6.5% of net revenue.”
Purchasing influence. About 9 out of 10 managers influence the selection and purchase of OR supplies and equipment (85%) and OR capital equipment (73%). Nearly half (48%) are members of the decision committee or team, 37% are the primary decision maker, and 28% serve in an advisory capacity.
Work hours/satisfaction. Respondents work an average of 49.1 hours a week, with 35% working between 50 and 54 hours. On a scale of 1 to 5, with 1 being “not at all satisfied” and 5 being “very satisfied,” respondents report a mean of 4 for satisfaction with their current position, and more than a third said they were very satisfied.
Like their hospital counterparts, ASC managers are a seasoned group. More than half (56%) have been employed in nursing for 30 years or more. They have been in their current positions an average of 10.1 years.
The average age has steadily increased over the years, from 47 years in 1997 to 53 in 2010, the same trend as for hospital OR directors and managers.
Nearly half of ASC managers (48%) have a bachelor’s as their highest degree, followed by 21% with an associate degree, and 14% with a master’s. That pattern differs from hospital OR leaders, half of whom have a master’s degree.
Nearly half (47%) of respondents’ employers require a specific degree, compared with 76% for hospital OR respondents. The bachelor’s is the most common degree required for ASC managers, followed by associate and master’s degrees.
“Medicare reimbursement will remain a challenge for many ASCs if CMS [Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services] doesn’t alter its policies that continue to cause a divergence of hospital outpatient departments and ASC rates, such as the inflation update differences,” says Edler. CMS uses different inflation indexes for hospitals and ASCs. ASC inflation updates are based on the consumer price index for urban consumers, while hospital updates use a market basket representing goods and services purchased by hospitals. ASCs contend their updates should also use the hospital market basket because they face the same inflationary pressures as hospitals in retaining nurses and purchasing supplies.
Edler adds that the productivity adjustment made as part of health care reform negated the inflation ASC payment update for 2011. “Other facets of health care reform may impact ASCs in the long term, but this is the most significant for 2011 reimbursement.”
The good news for ASCs, she says, is that under health care reform, more people will have insurance (though many will be on Medicaid). Another possible upside for patient volume is the coverage, with no copays or deductibles, of some screening services such as colonoscopies.
–Cynthia Saver, RN, MS
Cynthia Saver is a freelance writer and president of CLS Development, Inc, in Columbia, Maryland