April 1, 2010

Editorial

By: Pat Patterson
Share

It took a Texas jury less than an hour on February 11 to return a not guilty verdict for Anne Mitchell, RN. An administrator at 15-bed Winkler County Memorial Hospital in the small town of Kermit, Texas, Mitchell was charged by the local sheriff with a felony after she reported concerns about a physician to the state medical board.

Conviction would have carried a jail sentence of up to 10 years and a $10,000 fine.

Another nurse, Vickilyn Galle, RN, who assisted in writing the letter, was also charged, but the charges were dropped.

A heavy price

Though not guilty, Mitchell paid a heavy price. She and Galle were both fired by the hospital and amassed legal fees. The nurses had worked at Winkler for over 20 years.

They raised concerns with the medical board about Rolando G. Arafiles, Jr, MD. Mitchell was charged with “misuse of official information” for reporting the physician for what she alleged was a pattern of improper prescribing and performing minor surgery without surgical privileges. The nurses said they had taken their concerns to the hospital administration but said the concerns were not sufficiently ad-dressed.

After the physician complained to the local sheriff that he was being harassed, the sheriff launched an investigation and filed criminal charges. Though the complaint was anonymous, the sheriff got information from the medical board that enabled him to identify the nurses. He obtained a search warrant for their work computers and found the letter.

The information they allegedly misused was patient case numbers, although the medical board said such information can be used for reporting and is exempt from patient privacy regulations.

Texas law provides protection for whistleblowers but that doesn’t extend to local prosecutors filing criminal charges, according to the Texas Nurses Association (TNA).

A duty to patients

The news reached far beyond west Texas. American Nurses Association President Rebecca M. Pat-ton, RN, MSN, CNOR, called the action “outrageous,” saying it undermined a basic tenet of the nurse’s Code of Ethics—that nurses have a duty to the health and safety of their patients. TNA raised money for their defense.

The case is a reminder of what it can take to stand up for patients and the Code of Ethics.

The nurses have filed a federal suit against the hospital, its admin-istrator, the county, and the physician.

“We’re just in disbelief that you could be arrested for doing something you had been told your whole career was an obligation,” said Mitchell.

—Pat Patterson

Read more about the case at www.texasnurses.org/displaycommon.cfm?an=1&subarticlenbr=509#2

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat