Recent developments such as the Trump administration’s failure to pass its healthcare reform bill and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid’s (CMS) decision to delay expanding its bundled payments program leave the healthcare industry in a position of uncertainty.
It’s difficult to plan, and signs of any real progress are somewhat elusive at present. Yet recent reports suggest that value-based care (VBC) is taking hold, and bundled payments appear to still be the wave of the future.
The 2017 HealthLeaders Media Annual Industry Outlook Survey polled C-suite leaders as well as clinical, operations, financial, marketing, and information leaders. Among the survey’s 310 respondents, 66% said their organizations are committed to VBC, and only 2% said they don’t plan to pursue this model.
The remaining respondents were either planning to shift to VBC or were still considering whether to do so.
But it’s still early days, with just 35% of respondents fully committed and currently underway with implementing VBC.
What’s in the way? Revenue stream uncertainty, inadequate payer incentives, and inadequate information technology tools are the top three barriers preventing adoption, respondents said.
The survey also asked which areas of change are considered threats or opportunities. Payer consolidation, retail healthcare, and industry movement toward full capitation were cited as the leading threats, whereas clinical integration, care continuum relationships (clinical), health information exchange, and patient as consumer took the top spots as perceived opportunities.
The fact that 91% and 87%, respectively, of respondents viewed clinical integration and care continuum relationships (clinical) as opportunities shows that “they fully understand the key role these strategies play in delivering quality outcomes at lower costs,” the survey report said.
Indeed, there are case studies supporting the cost savings of bundled payment programs. For example, an observational study of 3,942 lower extremity joint replacement patients at Baptist Health System found that, between July 2008 and June 2015, average Medicare episode expenditures declined 20.8% for 3,738 episodes without complications and 13.8% for 204 episodes with complications.
CMS had planned to expand its Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement (CJR) bundled payment program this year. The program was going to include hip and femur fractures and three cardiac episodes of care (acute myocardial infarction, coronary artery bypass graft, and cardiac rehabilitation) starting July 1. Recently, however, CMS said it would delay that until October 1—and may even push the start date as late as January 1, 2018.
Under CJR, which was rolled out to 800 hospitals in April 2016, providers receive a single Medicare payment for all costs associated with a hip or knee replacement over a 90-day period. Health and Human Services Secretary Tom Price has criticized such mandatory initiatives, and opinions among industry leaders are mixed as to whether mandatory or voluntary participation is the way to go.
Ashish Jha, MD, professor of health policy at the Harvard School of Public Health, told Modern Healthcare he believes that optional participation in alternative payment models will drive up costs, whereas Carolyn Magill, CEO of Remedy Partners, said, “We have found that voluntary models provide a forum for more engaged participation.” Remedy Partners provides software that functions as an operating system for value-based payment programs and has designed episodes of care for many participants in Medicare’s voluntary Bundled Payment for Care Improvement initiative.
Dave Terry, CEO of Archway, echoed Magill’s enthusiasm for voluntary participation. According to Terry, only about 10% of providers who were supposed to be included in the mandatory cardiac bundles had expressed interest in actively preparing for them. Archway provides a platform that includes online software tools to access bundled payment program analytics and track patients and program performance.
Whatever happens—be it further implementation delays or a shift from mandatory to voluntary participation for bundled payments—the overarching goal is to lower healthcare costs while still providing high-quality care.
OR Manager has been reporting on developments as they occur, and we are also offering a day-long workshop on bundled payments. Our “Bundled Payments Bootcamp,” to be held June 20 in Nashville, Tennessee, will provide expert advice on topics such as changes under the Trump administration, reimbursement, collaborating with stakeholders, and implementing a successful bundled payment model of care.
For more information or to register, visit www.ormanager.com/events. ✥
—Elizabeth Wood
Cheney C. Medicare delays expansion of bundled payments program. HealthLeaders Media. Published online March 22, 2017.
HealthLeaders Media. Annual industry outlook: The road to value-based care. January/February 2017. www.healthleadersmedia.com/intelligence.
Navathe A S, Troxel A B, Liao J M, et al. Cost of joint replacement using bundled payment models. JAMA Intern Med. 2017; 177(2):214-222.
Whitman E. CMS delays expansion of bundled payment programs. Modern Healthcare. Published online March 20, 2017.