April 21, 2017

OR utilization improves with data gleaned from software program

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN
Share

One of the biggest challenges for OR managers is efficient use of OR blocks. OR managers struggle to balance revenue and utilization targets with surgeon and staff preferences. The result is underutilized OR time, unnecessary costs, and dissatisfied staff.

“Let’s face it, our block allocation process isn’t very efficient,” says Ashley Walsh, MHA, senior financial analyst and former perioperative business manager at UCHealth’s metro Denver campus, an academic medical facility in Aurora, Colorado.

Ashley Walsh, MHA

“In many ways, it’s similar to how Congress passes bills—surgeons lobby for more time, we spend hours pulling data and proposing changes, and blocks get debated and resolved in the OR committee,” she says. “In a world where data can drive block allocation decisions, block management should be easier.

In January 2016, UCHealth partnered with LeanTaas (Santa Clara, California) to help develop and implement a surgical scheduling optimization system called “iQueue.”

Designed by LeanTaaS mathematicians, software designers, and Lean experts, the system:

• shows key causes of underutilization and usage patterns over time

• applies predictive analytics and machine learning to increase the transparency of key performance metrics

• corrects for unforeseen situations such as last-minute block cancellations

• systematically reallocates OR block time.

Sanjeev Agrawal

“Hospitals using iQueue can improve block utilization while lowering unit labor costs to increase operating margins,” says Sanjeev Agrawal, president, healthcare, chief marketing officer, LeanTaaS.

“With iQueue, we have seen significant improvement in OR utilization, 12% to 15% improved utilization of blocks that were swapped or released at late notice, lower staffing costs, and an increased ability to give new surgeons block time,” he says. “In addition, overall utilization can go up as much as 5 to 10 percentage points, each of which is worth a lot of revenue and patient access. Labor costs can also go down as much as 18% to 20%. Plus, surgeons, administrators, nurses, and staff are much happier due to the transparency and fairness of the system.”

 

Partnering with UCHealth

“The way we build our products is with input from our customers,” says Agrawal. LeanTaaS partnered with UCHealth to help build iQueue’s four modules.

These include:

• Mobile Block Exchange

• Smart Block Scheduling

• Smart Performance Tracker

• Smart Staffing

UCHealth encompasses five hospitals, 16,200 employees, and 108 ORs that perform about 66,000 surgical procedures each year. More than a third of the surgical procedures are performed at the metro Denver campus. The ORs had approximately 70% to 80% room utilization on a consistent basis, and they were growing at 6% to 12% each year.

“As a business manager, I spent a lot of time putting together reports, analyzing data, and building dashboards,” says Walsh. “We had two homegrown databases on top of our electronic medical record [EMR], which gave me tons of data, but it took a lot of my time to pull all of the data from the different areas, and, at the end of the day, I was looking backward.”

Walsh says she needed something that was less time consuming and more forward looking, and iQueue provided that.

UCHealth was looking for a predictive tool that provided transparency into all the data they already had captured in their EMR, says Agrawal. He noted that UCHealth and many hospitals have made significant investments in their EMRs, business intelligence, and other tools in the past few years, which provided them with a lot of untapped data they could use in the iQueue system.

Agrawal also noted that the system is cloud-based, and data are retrieved through a secure file transfer protocol push rather than requiring information technology integration, which makes it much simpler to retrieve data.

 

Mobile Block Exchange

Surgeons and schedulers can quickly release blocks securely from their phones,
and other surgeons and schedulers can request them from the same app.
Source: LeanTaaS, Santa Clara, California.
Used with permission.

The Mobile Block Exchange module makes it easy for surgeons to release and request blocks (sidebar right):

• Surgeons and schedulers can release blocks securely through a Web browser on their mobile phones.

• Other surgeons and schedulers can immediately discover those blocks and request them from the same app.

• The module also monitors booking patterns to identify blocks that are likely to be underutilized, and it reminds surgeons and schedulers to proactively release them.

All requests must be approved by administrators because other aspects of a block also have to be evaluated when scheduling cases, such as equipment needs or availability of specific teams, notes Walsh.

“The problem this is solving is the 10% to 15% of block time that might be going underutilized or abandoned because of several possible reasons,” says Agrawal. “It could be a surgeon going to a conference who forgets to cancel his block, or it could be a surgeon who hoards block time. Being able to remind them proactively about releasing those blocks through their mobile device makes it very easy for them.”

UCHealth had been using Epic’s block management tools since 2011, says Walsh, but being transparent about released blocks has always been a struggle. “Often surgeons would tell their colleagues in the same service line they weren’t going to use their block time in case their colleagues wanted it, but they didn’t tell the schedulers or OR managers,” she says.

Because of this, block time was going unused at a time when some service lines were growing at a more rapid rate than others and needed more block time.

“The Mobile Block Exchange has made this process more transparent and has been a big win for new surgeons,” says Walsh. “Block time was not easy for them to get, and they would have to put their cases on the add-list for a long time. This program gives them an easy way to find unused blocks for their cases,” she says. UCHealth added 11 new surgeons last fall.

The metro Denver campus has about 155 blocks a week, and on average there were about 21 blocks unused per week before implementing Mobile Block Exchange. This translates to $1 million to $2 million a year per OR, says Walsh. “Even if you only capture 25% of that, through Mobile Block Exchange, the ROI [return on investment] is large,” she says. “You’re looking at roughly $500,000 per OR, per year.”

 

Smart Block Scheduling

Smart Block Scheduling ensures that the right surgeon gets the right block on the right day of the week. It uses machine learning to continuously forecast surgeon needs for block time and recommends block schedule changes.

Unlike traditional block scheduling methods, this program considers more than just surgical volume. It weighs factors such as seasonality, growth, and case length mix and variability to determine who needs more time and who has more time than they need.

“We refer to this as ‘Swiss cheese,’” says Agrawal. “When you lay out utilization patterns by surgeon, there are big holes in them. If there are big enough holes, there should be enough that you can take time away from them and still allow them to do all of their procedures.”

To accomplish this, the program creates supply tables and then mathematically forecasts how much time surgeons will use in a demand table:

• For supply, the program looks at how block owners are using their time in order to uncover “collectable block time.” This includes how block time is currently being used and whether there are chunks of time that, if “collected,” can be put to other or better use.

• For demand, the program looks at how block users are using time in order to uncover the need for more (or less) block time. Based on surgeon usage patterns, the program considers whether a more accurate forecast for demand by surgeon or service line can be done.

“Mirroring supply with demand through predictive analytics, we can now predict demand ahead of time,” says Walsh. “For example, we know how many surgeries we can expect on Friday night and how many nurses and anesthesiologists we need to support the demand.”

 

Smart Performance Tracker

The Smart Performance Tracker improves measurement and transparency. It monitors OR performance and provides forward-looking actionable guidance for surgeons and OR managers.

“Think of this as a backward-looking dashboard, which I call ‘admiring the problem,’” says Agrawal. “This is really saying two different things—what is going to happen and what you can do about it, and why what’s happening is happening,” he explains.

Walsh notes that the Smart Performance Tracker is different from other dashboards in that it is forward looking and “helps us ‘stay on our toes.’ It sends a mobile text each week that lets us know what is going on in real time and what happened last week,” she says.

The tool sends surgeons mobile alerts telling them:

• how they are contributing to OR volume

• how their performance measures are trending

• ways to improve their utilization.

Surgeons can track core metrics, such as how they:

• contributed overall to the OR

• utilized their time

• compared with their peers

• contributed to delays.

Surgeons also receive alerts on ways to improve performance, for example:

• their utilization on Monday mornings is going down

• their first case delays are nearing threshold

• 15 blocks are available in October.

“Surgeons, who are competitive by nature, love this because it shows them where they rank with other surgeons,” says Walsh.

OR managers, business managers, and administrators also benefit from this tool. It gives them objective data, including utilization patterns and what’s causing first case delays, long turnovers, or last-minute cancellations.

They can track key OR metrics from their phones, including overall utilization, block utilization, and first case starts.

They also receive actionable insights, such as who isn’t utilizing their block time well, who is causing the most delays, and where they can accommodate new surgeons.

“This kind of forward-looking information helps us plan better and ensures that we meet our revenue and performance targets while balancing surgeon needs,” says Walsh.

 

Smart Staffing

Balancing staffing against the blocks is a big challenge for OR managers, says Walsh.

“How often do we scramble to find nurses because of unexpected demand? How often do we wish we knew in advance how many cases to expect on Thursday at 5 pm? How often do we wonder what impact it will make on the schedule if an anesthesiologist takes Friday off?”

Having answers to these types of questions can save a lot of time, money, and stress, she says.

“When you are making staffing decisions, such as how many nurses and techs are needed to staff each OR by day of the week, by skill type, or 3 months in advance, you are creating what is called ‘constraint optimization problems’ in mathematics,” says Agrawal.

These problems can be solved mathematically with algorithms in the Smart Staffing module.

The module predicts OR utilization by time of day and day of week, and uses optimization algorithms to recommend staffing plans that minimize the risk of over- and understaffing.

“Smart Staffing looks at actual utilization patterns and then predicts what they are likely to be over the next 90 days. This allows managers to staff more optimally, which can decrease labor costs by 10% to 15%,” says Agrawal.

In addition to optimized monthly/quarterly staffing plans, the module includes “What-if” tools to minimize overall cost by balancing time and overtime. (sidebar right).

“The What-if Simulator takes all of your historical data and allows you to play around with it,” says Agrawal. For example, OR managers can ask: “How many shifts should I have, and when should they start and end, or how many nurses and techs do I need per shift?” Then they can optimize for reducing furloughs, overtime, callbacks, and total cost, he says.

OR managers also can run various scenarios, such as: What would happen if starting times for some nurses and technologists were shifted from 7 am to 9 am?

The module gives OR managers complete power based on historical data, plus the program keeps learning, and the algorithms shift with the new data, says Agrawal. ✥

—Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN

 

References

Agrawal S, Walsh A. Improving OR utilization using Lean & predictive analytics. OR Business Management Conference, 2017.

Walsh A. What’s next after EHR? An OR manager’s perspective. Unpublished paper.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat