Creating a more harmonious work environment is a struggle for some OR leaders. Tips on how to achieve this were offered during the 2017 OR Manager Conference and the 2018 OR Business Management Conference (ORBMC), and we share some of these in the March issue.
A dysfunctional atmosphere in the OR can take a toll, and many healthcare providers are burned out. In fact, burnout has prompted the National Academy of Medicine (formerly the Institute of Medicine) to launch a national Action Collaborative on Clinician Well-Being and Resilience, with participation from the Association of American Medical Colleges and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education.
They have identified four major goals:
• increase the visibility of clinician stress and burnout
• improve healthcare organizations’ understanding of the challenges to clinician well-being
• identify evidence-based solutions
• monitor the effectiveness of implementation of these solutions.
Burnout is characterized by emotional exhaustion and depersonalization. A workplace fraught with inefficiency, long hours, and managers who neglect input from staff increases the likelihood of burnout.
Sound familiar?
According to Rebecca McKenzie, DNP, MBA, MSN, RN, assistant vice president at Duke University Hospital, Durham, North Carolina, one in three nurses are burned out, and that rate is actually approaching two in three.
At Duke’s academic center, a Level 1 trauma center where 42,000 procedures are performed annually in 65 ORs, McKenzie conducted a pilot study involving a resilience intervention program. She shared results at ORBMC.
A total of 228 nurses and surgical technologists volunteered to participate in use of the WISER (web-based implementation for the science of enhanced resilience) tool. Each activity was introduced in a 1-hour in-service over a 6-month period, and participants earned continuing education credit. Activities included:
• keeping a daily journal in which they recorded three good things that happened that day
• writing a gratitude letter to someone who had been a positive influence on them
• engaging in deliberate acts of kindness, such as buying a stranger a cup of coffee.
Outcomes were measured by four validated instruments—the Maslach Burnout Inventory, the Subjective Happiness Scale, Work Life Balance Scale (CABQ), and the Center for Epidemiological Depression Scale 10-item version (CES-D10).
Pre- and post-surveys, conducted electronically, showed a statistically significant increase in happiness and lower depression. Work-life balance shifted to be more favorable but did not reach a statistically significant change, and burnout was unchanged.
McKenzie noted that although burnout remained unchanged, burnout may be influenced by other factors. For example, during the study, there were three colleague deaths, transition to newly opened ORs, and other changes, including the departure of a manager. Further exploration is necessary to better understand burnout among OR teams, she said. However, overall feedback was positive, and she believes other organizations could perhaps adopt a program like this.
In another presentation at ORBMC, Christina Dempsey, MSN, MBA, RN, CNOR, CENP, FAAN, connected the dots between a safe work environment for nurses and patient outcomes. Dempsey, chief nursing officer and senior vice president at Press Ganey Associates, Inc, in South Bend, Indiana, shared poignant personal stories and data to illustrate that when nurses are engaged and compassionate, patient care improves and satisfaction rates are higher.
According to Press Ganey studies, she said, key drivers of loyalty and likelihood to recommend include teamwork, nurse courtesy, and room cleanliness. “What do these have in common?” Dempsey asked. “If you work better as a team, I feel safe. If you involve me in my care and you’re courteous, I feel safe. If my room is clean, I think I won’t get an infection, so I feel safe. There is simply no light between clinical quality, patient safety, and the patient experience. They are all the same thing.”
Other Press Ganey data, Dempsey said, analyzed the impact of work environment on safety, comparing most favorable versus least favorable environments. Even in places with below-median staffing levels, there were fewer falls and fewer pressure ulcer injuries in the most favorable work environments.
Compared to organizations in the bottom quartile of workplace safety, organizations in the top quartile had 52% less RN-perceived missed care, and 27% rated job enjoyment higher. “It’s not only important for patients to feel safe, it’s important for staff to feel safe,” she said.
What can be done to improve work environments? Dempsey offered these strategies:
• Staffing and assignments should account for patient volume, nurse skill mix, and the nature and intensity of the care each patient requires.
• Provide and enforce uninterrupted, adequate meal and rest breaks.
• Utilize patient data to drive scheduling and avoid extended work shifts.
• Educate nurse leaders and unit managers to train and empower nursing staff.
• Develop a stable core of nurse leaders and nurses with leadership potential.
She urged attendees to return to their ORs and remind their staffs of how important they are. “They need to feel safe, and you do that by giving them the tools are resources they need, by giving them autonomy, and by giving them the ability to grow in their careers. Those are the things that matter, and the data prove that. And when you do that for your staff, the patient experience also improves.” ✥
Dempsey C. How staff safety and surveillance can improve patient outcomes. Presented at the 2018 OR Business Management Conference.
Dzau V J, Kirch D G, Nasca T J. To care is human—Collectively confronting the clinician-burnout crisis. Perspective. N Engl J Med. 2018;378(4),312-314.
McKenzie R. Resilience: A skill that can be learned. Presented at the 2018 OR Business Management Conference.