Interest in data analytics, artificial intelligence, technology, and innovation has skyrocketed with rapid advances in systems and devices designed to improve patient care. When it comes to data analytics, asking the right questions is key to finding answers that will enhance efficiency and patient safety, according to David Wyatt, PhD, RN, NEA-BC, CNOR, the opening keynote speaker at the 2019 OR Business Management Conference.
“The science of analytics is not about the ability to run reports,” says Wyatt, vice president, perioperative enterprise, at Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee. “It’s the science of understanding what you’re doing with the information in order to manipulate or change your current situation.”
He likens operating rooms to a prism; if you have a prism exactly right, you see clearly—but only from your angle. And others are seeing it clearly from theirs. “You both can be describing something from a totally different perspective through a different part of that prism. And the more priorities you have, the more complexity you have.”
One common metric is cost per case. At Vanderbilt, Wyatt says, cases that generate a lot of revenue also are often costly. “If you separate revenue optimization from cost containment and you prioritize cost containment, you’ll lose money. I’m not suggesting that you don’t pay attention to cost containment, but you need to ask different questions,” he says. “At Vanderbilt we’ve created an O to E cost ratio. We establish an observed cost against an expected one. That helps us not over-prioritize cost containment in those areas where we’re really focused on revenue optimization.”
Wyatt asked attendees to recognize that, as OR leaders, they are not data experts, they are operations experts. He urged them to evaluate questions and get help to find the answers.
“We should measure things that matter,” Ari Robicsek, MD, told the audience during a recent NEJM Catalyst webinar. Robicsek, chief medical analytics officer at Providence St Joseph Health, Renton, Washington, noted that many hospitals use length of stay (LOS) as a measure of quality. However, LOS doesn’t confer benefits unless other costs are reduced and outcomes are better.
“If we assign resources to working on the wrong problem, we’re not working on the right problem,” he says. For example, if there’s too much emphasis on reducing LOS, patients may be discharged prematurely, which could lead to higher 30-day readmissions.
Dr Robicsek makes a case for using measurement as a tool for learning rather than punishment or reward. “This would allow us to learn what specific elements of care improve outcomes,” he says, adding that it’s important to focus on the performance of the team rather than the individual.
Organizations trying to measure what matters need to show they’re achieving results such as high patient satisfaction scores, low provider burnout, and low turnover, according to Dr Robicsek. “If we succeed in finding measures that matter, there will be strong incentive for others to follow,” he says. He believes that creating an environment in which physicians feel they can do their best work will ultimately improve outcomes and diminish the importance placed on some of the quality measures imposed by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Judith F. Baumhauer, MD, MPh, associate chair of academic affairs and professor of orthopedics at the University of Rochester Medical Center (URMC), Rochester, New York, explained how use of the PROMIS tool (Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System) has helped change clinical practice at her institution. PROMIS is a statistically validated, computer-driven survey that uses computer adaptive technology and item-response theory for highly detailed, accurate results.
During outpatient visits, patients use iPADs to answer questions about pain, function, and mood among other symptoms that are important to them. Whether they are in orthopedics, cancer, or urology, these PROMIS symptom assessments can be referenced to a normative population and discussed with patients, allowing them to share in decision making about their care. In some cases, patients opt not to have surgery because the data show that they are functioning too well or do not have enough pain that surgery will benefit them.
PROMIS, originally adopted in the orthopedic department at URMC, has spread to about 40 different departments with some 900 providers collecting data, Dr Baumhauer says.
She notes that although it takes just a couple of minutes to collect patient information, providers don’t always share the data with their patients or incorporate this step into their workflow. “They’re burdened with other quality indicators they need to address to get paid,” she says. “We need to get rid of some of those and put the patient’s voice back into the program.”
Although not everyone has a custom platform that can implement patient-reported outcomes like PROMIS, Dr Baumhauer says providers can collect meaningful data through other PROMIS apps and tools. “The other problem is providers not understanding how to use the data,” she says. “We need to empower them to ask the important clinical questions and ask leadership to provide the resources for them to get the answers.”
Two articles in this issue demonstrate how the right questions and tools can improve patient safety. A rural facility that added screening for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) to its presurgical patient assessment found that nearly 29% of patients either had OSA or were at risk for it (cover story). And adopting a protocol to encourage nursing staff to question practices has eliminated never events at a Level 2 trauma center (p 17).
Upcoming issues will feature technological innovations that have exciting implications for surgical practice. Regardless of facility investment in technology, however, the playing field remains pretty level when it comes to asking the right questions to improve patient care. ✥
NEJM Catalyst. Provider-driven data analytics to improve outcomes. Webinar. January 31, 2019.
Wyatt, D. Business intelligence—The intersection of analytics and operations. Keynote address. OR Business Management Conference. January 28, 2019.