There are few things more disheartening for patients than having to board in the emergency department (ED) for long periods while waiting for a bed. ED boarding can also delay treatment and adds to overcrowding and backups.
Erlanger Health System, based in Chattanooga, Tennessee, decided to tackle this problem head on by developing an innovative surgical transfer unit for Baroness Hospital, its Level 1 trauma center, also in Chattanooga. Launched June 12, 2017, the unit was dubbed the Erlanger Surgical Transfer and Receiving Unit (eSTAR). So far, the eSTAR has helped prevent unnecessary ED presentations and decreased the amount of time surgical patients spend boarding in the ED.
Baroness Hospital is a busy trauma center and regional referral center. Its high-acuity, trauma OR performed more than 1,500 surgeries in fiscal year 2017. Its acute-care surgery program includes an in-house trauma surgeon and surgical team who provide surgical subspecialist care for high-acuity transfers from Alabama, Georgia, Tennessee, and North Carolina. The hospital has more than 600 beds and is often operating at capacity.
In the past, this made it difficult to find beds for transfers and direct admissions. “Patients were taken care of, but we felt we could be more efficient around access and treatment,” says Adam Royer, MS, BSN, RN, CNOR, FACHE, assistant vice president of surgical services, Erlanger Health System.
Surgical transfers and direct admissions often had to access Baroness Hospital via the ED, resulting in lengthy ED boarding and overcrowding. Residents and surgeons often had to make rounds on their surgical patients in the ED. These situations led some referral sources to seek alternate care locations.
“The lion’s share of our surgical patients transfer from another facility or a physician’s office,” says Royer. “They don’t need emergency care, but they have had to go to the ED in the past because there was nowhere else to put them. We wanted to do better for our patients and referring facilities and practices.”
Baroness Hospital’s eSTAR unit was developed to help surgical patients bypass the ED and obtain rapid evaluation, disposition, and treatment. “Our goal was to provide faster access to care for surgical transfers and direct admissions,” says Royer.
The concept for eSTAR was modeled after the University of Maryland Medical Center’s Critical Care Resuscitation Unit (CCRU). This innovative unit provides quick admission and time-sensitive specialty services for critically ill transfer patients.
Similar to the CCRU, eSTAR provides direct-admission beds for appropriately selected patients. The unit accepts admissions from medical offices, the ED, and other hospitals and facilities—including patients with stable, isolated trauma injuries, such as a fractured femur or ankle needing surgery.
“It’s a surgical unit with the capability and skills to take care of any acuity-level transfer patient,” says Royer.
In June 2017, eSTAR opened with four beds and now has 12 beds that are open 7 days a week, 24 hours a day. “We have beds and a team ready to provide high-quality care for surgical patients, whether they are transferred from the ED, walk in from a physician’s office, or are flown in by helicopter,” says Royer.
eSTAR has three private rooms and nine rooms divided by half-walls. This creates private bays that are quickly accessible by the nurses. The unit is staffed by nurses with ED or critical-care backgrounds who are focused on caring for the specialized needs of surgical patients.
“We always maintain the capability of accepting critical-care patients, and we have a dedicated staff that loves to take care of surgical patients,” says Royer.In addition, residents and the surgical staff can evaluate their patients in a dedicated, specialized surgical unit outside the busy ED.
eSTAR has reduced ED overcrowding and boarding hours and the burden on ED staff who must also care for emergent patients. The total number of patients who have bypassed the ED has more than tripled since June 2017. Since opening its doors, 35% of the unit’s patients are direct admits or transfers, 41% come from the ER, and 24% from the postanesthesia care unit (PACU), says Royer.
Ongoing quality improvement projects include decreasing the number of surgical patients admitted through the ED and increasing the number of direct admissions and transfers to 60% or more. The unit is also looking to offer conscious sedation services, which would boost the number of patients who could bypass the ED.
A 2013 study by the National Institutes of Health found that the median charge for common outpatient ED conditions, such as sprains and strains, headaches, and kidney stones, was $1,233. “That’s a redundant and unnecessary cost for stable patients transferring from a doctor’s office or another hospital,” says Royer.
He notes that multiplying that amount by multiple patients adds up to significant costs. eSTAR is helping to reduce healthcare costs by keeping surgical patients out of the ED when unnecessary.
In the first 11 months of operation, eSTAR prevented 615 unnecessary ED presentations, resulting in a savings of $758,295 and 369 boarder days. The unit also decreased the amount of time surgical patients spent in the ED boarding by accepting 711 patients, thus accounting for 426 ED boarder days.
As of November 2018, eSTAR had prevented more than 1,000 unnecessary ED presentations, resulting in a savings of more than $1,233,000, says Royer.
eSTAR offers nurses a unique setting that is a hybrid of ER, critical-care, and medical/surgical nursing. “eSTAR was a new concept, a bit of an unknown for the nurses, but we took an unknown and developed it,” says Jennifer Ohle, BS, RN, CPAN, director of perioperative services, Erlanger Health Center. “The atmosphere in the unit is very positive, and the nurses feel that they are making a difference.”
Patient flow on a typical day can be unpredictable, and eSTAR nurses do not always know the kind of cases they will get. Patient acuity varies widely, and there is generally a quick turnover. However, there are also days when patients stay longer than expected because the hospital is full. Patients have even shown up at the door unannounced.
“It’s somewhat like an ER. There may be three nurses and three patients to start, and shortly after, there are three nurses and nine patients,” says Royer.
Another challenge is in anticipating the condition of direct admits and patients transferring from other hospitals.
“Patients don’t always present as reported,” says Ohle. “We once had a transfer who was admitted for a laparoscopic cholecystectomy. After assessing him, the nurses discovered he was actually having a myocardial infarction. He ended up in the catheterization lab and had coronary artery bypass graft surgery.”
Crucial skills for eSTAR nurses include sharp assessment and critical-thinking skills. “eSTAR nurses must have that ER and critical-care mindset to pick up on cases like that,” says Royer. “They also have to be able to professionally articulate their assessments to the residents.”
Launching eSTAR did not occur without growing pains. Initially it served as a PACU overflow unit, and soon it began absorbing ED overflow as well.
“It has been a challenge to find balance and have a unit with good utilization that still maintains the goal of quick access for surgical transfers and direct admits,” says Royer. “Our overarching goal is to always be capable of taking care of these patients. We now have put limits on ED and PACU overflow to save four beds at all times, so we can always say yes to surgical transfers and direct admits.”
Having administrative buy-in is essential. “When the ED or the PACU start backing up and want to send patients, you need administrative support to keep your beds open for direct admits and transfers,” says Ohle. “Otherwise, you will fill up with other patients.”
Opening the innovative unit also required a culture change among the staff. It took time for them to understand the purpose and proper utilization of eSTAR and to overcome the practice of sending everyone through the ED first.
Staff were initially concerned that eSTAR patients had not been admitted by a surgeon. They have since learned that it’s sufficient for a patient to be admitted by a hospitalist and accepted by a surgeon, says Royer.
One key to success is ongoing communication with the ED, transferring physicians and hospitals, and the regional operations center. This includes helping the ED staff define appropriate patients for the eSTAR unit and reviewing cases in which a patient who should have gone directly to eSTAR ended up in the ED.
“Defining appropriate patients must be approached from a team perspective, not done in a silo,” says Royer. “Feedback is very positive from the ED. It has been a partnership.”
It was also important to partner with the regional operations center, which manages transfers and direct admissions, Royer notes. The staff take calls from physicians and other hospitals transferring patients and find beds for those patients. eSTAR is giving them options and helping streamline their process.
“The hardest part is ensuring everyone has a clear understanding of appropriate patients,” says Royer. “It was a new concept for everybody, but I’m spending a lot less time on the phone now than I did 6 months ago.”
The eSTAR staff nurses have also been vital to the success of the unit. “One of my nurse leaders is always right on it, bulldogging the ER board and assessing pending transfers into the unit,” says Ohle. “We want those patients with us and not in the ER. That has been a big part of our success—ensuring we get our patients.” ✥
Catherine Spader, RN is a medical writer, editor, and award-winning fiction author based in Littleton, Colorado
Caldwell N, Srebotnjak T, Wang T, et al. How much will I get charged for this? Patient charges for top ten diagnoses in the emergency department. PLoS One. 2013;8(2):e55491.
Royer A. Implementation of a surgical transfer unit: An innovative approach to increase timely access to surgical subspecialists. Poster presented at OR Manager Conference. 2018.