Communication breakdowns in the perioperative environment are a factor in 70% of events that adversely affect patients. Sometimes those breakdowns occur because OR staff are reluctant to voice their concerns in an environment that is hierarchical and intimidating. However, when an organization adopts patient safety first (PSF) initiatives, adverse outcomes can dramatically diminish—or even disappear, as was the case at The Medical Center of Aurora (TMCA) in Aurora, Colorado, which eliminated never events.
The four fundamental characteristics of PSF initiatives are problem identification, strength of organizational competencies, vulnerability to culture, and commitment to change. Understanding these characteristics can help OR nurse leaders establish and sustain PSF programs designed to improve culture and outcomes.
Part 1 of this two-part series will explain the importance of evidence-based communication tools in allowing every team member’s voice to be heard. Part 2 will explore managing the characteristics of vulnerability to culture and the commitment to change that is associated with PSF initiatives.
TMCA is a Level 2 trauma hospital with 346 licensed beds and 11 ORs specializing in cardiovascular services, neurosciences, surgery, orthopedic, and women’s services. A Magnet®-designated facility, TMCA has been named Top General Hospital and US News Best General Hospital.
From June 2013 to August 2014, TMCA experienced six never events in the OR—three wrong-site surgeries and three retained surgical items—that resulted in direct patient harm and prompted a call to action.
According to Kathy Bilys, MBA, CPHQ, vice president of quality and performance improvement at TMCA, the perioperative and executive leadership teams were concerned that something bigger than any single never event was going on and that the hospital needed to get in front of it. Bilys, whose background is in patient safety and process improvement, joined TMCA in 2014 and helped initiate taking a new look at the root cause analyses (RCAs) associated with the never events.
“Once we stepped back and looked at past RCAs all together, we saw the deeper recurring issue,” says Bilys. “Communication is a common theme in never events, but when we did some digging to determine what about communication was problematic at our facility, we identified that staff had a feeling that something was not right during the case but did not feel comfortable speaking up.”
Robin Chard, PhD, RN, CNOR, the PhD program coordinator at the Passan School of Nursing at Wilkes University in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, says every member of the perioperative team must feel valued equally to establish an enabling culture where all team members can provide safe patient care and speak up when warranted.
In a research study of the meaning of intraoperative errors, Chard found that for the perioperative RNs who participated in the study, the conditions in their hospitals were not conducive for them to speak up, resulting in a prevailing culture of intimidation in which nurses do not have a voice and do not feel they are equal or respected members of the perioperative team.
The RCA review at TMCA also identified critical thinking and compliance as problems. In particular, counting polices were not well understood or not followed carefully, and there was a lack of compliance with the Universal Protocol (preprocedure briefing, time out, postprocedure briefing). In an effort to build solutions and identify actions to prevent recurrence, TMCA perioperative and executive leadership team members came together with staff to establish an “all hands on deck” dynamic that initially sought to answer several questions.
Says Bilys: “First we asked, ‘What are our organizational competencies and policies that support, or do not support, a particular process?’ We knew this was our call to action to change the culture, but what did that action look like? At that point, we acknowledged that we had a burning platform and needed to bring the entire OR team together at one point in time, require their attendance, and involve them in being part of a culture change.”
In late August 2014, the entire OR team, perioperative leaders, medical staff leaders, and the executive team (roughly 100 team members) attended the inaugural PSF meeting to review patient safety issues and define TMCA’s call to action. Members of the perioperative and executive leadership teams encouraged an open discussion of what had been learned from the RCAs and ways to improve organizational competencies and policies to ensure better outcomes.
“In our presentation materials, we used pictures of patients, the dates of the never event, and what the event was to recognize that there are individuals who have had a significant, avoidable experience with us,” says Bilys. “There were several heartfelt moments in the meeting that really engaged the team and identified that every one of us at TMCA has a role to play in patient safety.”
During this first PSF meeting, a new perioperative services PSF framework was presented to augment the OR staff’s clinical skill set with patient safety and human factors skill sets (listed below), to elevate their practice around a culture of safety during critical but routine tasks, and to cultivate a culture of “always” relative to adherence to evidence-based safety interventions (sidebar at right).
• Increase compliance with standardized processes and protocols.
• Create a system of comprehensive checklists and double-check systems.
• Enforce and improve awareness related to protocols and policies.
• Improve continuing education and enhanced information sharing.
• Cultivate teamwork (eg, collaboration, trust, camaraderie).
• Empower staff to speak up and “Stop the Line” when warranted.
To eliminate never events in the OR, team members agreed to adopt the following PSF initiatives:
• Enhanced communication and empowerment with the CUSS (concern, uncomfortable, safety, stop) speak-up tool.
• Improved briefing, time out, and debriefing processes (sidebar below).
• Development of an ongoing, comprehensive staff education program.
• Hosting of biannual, mandatory PSF meetings to engage staff and maintain awareness of preventing never events.
“Buy-in for the PSF initiative came automatically from the hospital leadership because of the patient safety component and priding ourselves in leading from the front and having complete transparency with our team,” says Michelle Stierstorfer, MSN, RN, director of surgical services: SDS, PACU, Pre-Admit Testing, Endoscopy at TMCA. “The key stakeholders who were slow to the table were the surgeons, but after education on the ‘why’ of it, full support and attendance at PSF meetings were achieved.”
Critical to the rollout of the PSF initiative was implementation of the TeamSTEPPS® CUS speak-up model. Members of the TMCA OR and quality and improvement team are TeamSTEPPS-certified and utilized their training by introducing the validated, evidence-based CUS tool.
“Because the CUS acronym has only one ‘S’ and ends with ‘safety,’ our team elevated the tool to include an extra S that means ‘stop,’” says Stierstorfer. “We wanted to empower team members using the CUSS speak-up tool to take control of the situation when warranted by stopping the whole process of what’s happening if they feel uncomfortable.”

CUSS posters are in every procedure room at TMCA as a reminder that the communication practice is supported and accepted (sidebar at right). “CUSS is more than a speak-up tool,” says Nancy Wolfmeier, MSN, RN, AVP of perioperative services. “Culturally, it signals to staff that leadership is behind them, and not only is it okay to CUSS, it is expected. To really change culture, it is important for staff to hear that if they are getting a little pushback from the surgeon or anyone, then the CEO, the whole C-suite, and our perioperative leadership will back them 100%.”
Evidence-based tools like CUS promote a shared team model for safety, explains Lisa Spruce, DNP, RN, CNS-CP, CNOR, ACNS, ACNP, FAAN, director of evidence-based perioperative practice at AORN.
“Implementing CUS and customizing the tool to a particular setting empower perioperative teams to provide an opportunity for any team member to indeed have a voice and understand that any situation that could be unsafe should be addressed,” says Spruce. “Trust is built with these formal communication tools that facilitate timely communication and responses by each team member and that help the quality of communication by making sure critical patient factors are not overlooked.”
As TMCA’s error reduction strategies and use of the CUSS speak-up tool illustrate, PSF initiatives that strengthen organizational competencies enable perioperative teams to focus on what a process should be rather than on what it was. This approach can foster new behaviors that improve culture and prevent recurrence of never events. ✥
—Iris Llewellyn is a freelance healthcare writer based in Denver.
Read part 2 here!
AORN. Guideline for team communication. Guidelines for Perioperative Practice. Denver, CO: AORN, 2019. www.aorn.org.
Chard R, Tovin M. The meaning of intraoperative errors: Perioperative nurse perspectives. AORN J. 2018;107(2):225-235.
Ortiz L, Wolfmeier N, Stierstorfer M. Patient Safety First. Poster. OR Manager Conference 2018.
Pocket Guide: TeamSTEPPS: Team Strategies & Tools to Enhance Performance and Patient Safety. Agency for Healthcare and Research Quality. https://www.ahrq.gov/teamstepps/instructor/essentials/pocketguide.html#cus.
Universal Protocol Poster. The Joint Commission. https://www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/18/UP_Poster1.PDF.