A surprising 70% of respondents to the 2019 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey report overall satisfaction with their jobs—surprising in light of their significant workload, relatively flat salaries, number of staff vacancies, and industry-wide prevalence of clinician burnout.
Burnout is defined as a state of physical or emotional exhaustion that also involves a sense of reduced accomplishment and loss of personal identity. The National Nursing Engagement Report from PRC published earlier this year, based on survey findings from more than 2,000 healthcare partners, found that 15.6% of all nurses felt burned out, and 41% described themselves as “unengaged.”
A more recent study that assessed 672 nurse leaders at 29 hospitals found levels of burnout were similar across frontline, midlevel, and director-level leadership positions, although work-life balance scored lower among directors.
Much of the literature on burnout tends to focus on physicians, so it’s nice to see attention turning to nurses. The OR environment makes nurse leaders and their staffs especially vulnerable to burnout, which may compel them to leave their jobs at any stage of their careers. Some newly minted nurses have been known to abandon nursing within a short time, and many younger nurses, regardless of whether they hold staff or management positions, don’t hesitate to change jobs if they can’t improve their current situations.
Millennials in particular have a reputation for this kind of job hopping, and managers who have invested a lot of time and effort in orientation and onboarding are understandably frustrated by staff turnover. Yet who can argue with the notion that everyone deserves a better work-life balance?
A nationwide nursing shortage has been projected for the past several years, but in fact the numbers vary by geographic area: Shortages by 2030 are predicted for California, Texas, New Jersey, South Carolina, and Alaska, whereas Florida, Ohio, Virginia, New York, and Missouri are expected to have a surplus of RNs, according to a 2017 National Center for Health Workforce Analysis.
Staffing issues—notably having enough staff and highly competent and engaged staff—are a chief concern of OR Manager survey respondents. Half of them say they anticipate retiring by 2028, and more than a third say the percentage of open positions at their facilities has increased for both RNs and surgical technologists compared with a year ago.
An increasing number of OR Manager articles and conference sessions over the past few years have focused on future OR leaders and staff in an effort to help manage workforce changes. A three-part series on recruitment strategies that began in the September issue continues in this issue with an in-depth look at interviewing, job shadowing, and testing to identify candidates most likely to fit well in the OR environment (p 11). To paint the full picture, we’ll also explore ways to retain employees in a two-part article starting in November.
One common thread in our articles and elsewhere in the literature is the huge role played by work environment in building and sustaining a successful team. We’ve previously discussed studies linking work environment with nurses’ satisfaction and the effect on patient safety, and we’ve published several “Success Stories” that illustrate this concept. In this issue, for example, you’ll learn how cross-departmental collaboration at a community hospital has broken down silos and dramatically reduced pressure injuries in surgical patients (p 24).
Improvements like these don’t happen merely from process change. What’s critical for success is getting all stakeholders to take ownership in new initiatives, which can only be accomplished by nurturing and sustaining good teamwork.
Efforts to improve the team member experience have paid off for leaders at Vidant Medical Center in Greenville, North Carolina. A few simple employee engagement strategies have boosted morale and created greater synergy among staff:
• Nursing salons: Periodic gatherings of small groups who discuss a specific topic with a facilitator have allowed people to share experiences and learn from one another through storytelling.
• Games: The winning team in a competition to promote engagement has received a small monetary award along with a celebration.
• Breaks: The discovery that most emergency department nurses weren’t taking breaks has led to creating a break area that includes a “serenity room” painted with calming colors and inspirational quotes.
Each year at the OR Manager Conference, we cover a lot of ground with sessions on the latest regulatory and legal requirements, best clinical practices, and solutions to common problems. But I think many attendees would say what they value most is being away from the daily grind and immersed in a supportive, stimulating environment that reminds them of the important work they do and the difference they make in people’s lives.
These are the messages that get lost when stressors take over and a downward spiral begins. Are you and/or anyone on your staff experiencing burnout? Do you have a poor work environment that may contribute to the departure of valuable staff? Are there changes you could make to prevent that from happening?
Perhaps now is a good time to take a step back and assess. Recognizing a problem is the first step toward recovery. ✥
Cohen J K. How bad is the nursing shortage? Modern Healthcare. August 17, 2019. https://www.modernhealthcare.com/labor/how-bad-nursing-shortage.
Kelly L A, Lefton C, Fischer S A, et al. Nurse leader burnout, satisfaction, and work-life balance. J Nurs Admin. 2019;49(9):404-410.
Thew J. 3 Ways nurse leaders can change workplace culture. HealthLeaders Media. Published online June 10, 2019. https://www.healthleadersmedia.com/nursing/3-ways-nurse-leaders-can-change-workplace-culture.