October 21, 2019

Editorial

By: Elizabeth Wood
Share

Our series on Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS), which began last month with an overview of its history and perioperative pathway, continues in this issue with examples of improved outcomes and the roles played by perioperative team members (see p 18).

ERAS, known to speed recovery and increase patient satisfaction, has been adopted for many types of procedures. Yet Henrik Kehlet, MD, PhD, who came up with the concept of “fast-track surgery” from which ERAS evolved, sounded a cautionary note early in 2019. In a JAMA Viewpoint, Dr Kehlet and his colleagues stressed the importance of conducting scientifically rigorous studies to support the adoption of ERAS protocols, noting that “ERAS recommendations for one surgery may not be directly translatable to another.”

They lament the shift in focus from reducing complications and improving recovery to reducing length of stay (LOS). “Although it is likely that most patients would prefer a shorter hospital stay, a focus on inpatient LOS ignores the full process of rehabilitation since much of recovery is shifting from hospitals to other acute care settings such as skilled nursing facilities,” they say. Another caveat: Be wary of adding new or inadequately studied drugs and interventions. For example, intravenous acetaminophen or liposomal bupivacaine may work well in one procedure but may be unsafe in another.

Dr Kehlet and his colleagues want to ensure that ERAS, which began as a patient-centered science, is not replaced by “uncertain scientific approaches that seek to replace true measures of recovery such as complications, readmissions, or quality of life with LOS.”

 

Cardiac surgery protocols

The authors of recent ERAS recommendations for cardiac surgery appear to have used the kind of rigor advocated by Dr Kehlet et al. Their multidisciplinary group of cardiac surgeons, anesthesiologists, and intensivists experienced in ERAS researched the literature and ultimately agreed on 22 interventions across preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative phases of recovery. Each recommendation required a minimum of 75% agreement on class and level for consensus.

The strongest recommendations have benefits that greatly outweigh risks and are based on evidence ranging from randomized clinical trials to non-randomized or observational studies. Examples include:

• delirium screening at least once per nursing shift

• using forced-air warming blankets, raising the ambient room temperature, and warming irrigation and intravenous fluids to avoid hypothermia in the early postoperative period

• the use of tranexamic acid or epsilon aminocaproic acid during on-pump cardiac surgical procedures

• the use of acetaminophen, Tramadol, dexmedetomidine, and pregabalin or gabapentin for multimodal opioid-sparing pain management

• the use of biomarkers for early identification of patients at risk for acute kidney injury complications.

“Cardiac surgery involves a large clinician group working in concert throughout all phases of care,” the authors say. “Patient and caregiver education and systemwide engagement (facilitated by specialty champions and nurse coordinators) are necessary to implement best practices. A successful introduction of ERAS protocols is possible, but a broad-based, multidisciplinary approach is imperative for success,” they conclude.

 

Putting ERAS into practice

Similar conclusions were drawn in a review of studies on health professionals’ experiences of ERAS. The authors narrowed down a qualitative literature review to eight studies in the US, UK, Canada, Denmark, Norway, and Australia focusing on ERAS applied to colorectal surgery, gastrointestinal surgery, abdominal hysterectomy, and orthopedics.

Like other standardized care initiatives, successful implementation of ERAS depends on a multidisciplinary team that communicates effectively, is willing to collaborate, overcomes resistance to change, understands each team member’s role, and understands ERAS protocols. Some of the studies found that giving new staff a “thorough introduction” about ERAS principles and using a “bottom-up” rather than a “top-down” approach were helpful in engaging staff.

Three of the eight studies found that staff generally favored use of ERAS, but all of the studies cited challenges such as worry about other team members’ perceptions and possible second-guessing of decisions. In one study, for example, researchers noted: “Where nurses anticipated that some surgeons might resist ERAS recommendations, surgeons thought that the nursing culture and lack of nursing time would present a problem. Anesthetists, meanwhile, were concerned that patients would not understand ERAS guidelines and procedures.”

The authors conclude that even when staff are on board with ERAS, it can be a complex and challenging process to implement. “We suggest that the provision of comprehensive, coherent, and locally relevant information to health professionals would help to improve the implementation and delivery of ERAS pathways,” they say.

This is the intent of our ERAS series: to provide a comprehensive picture of the people, processes, and improved outcomes that are possible with this model of patient care. We hope you find these articles illuminating. ✥

 

References

Cohen R, Gooberman-Hill R. Staff experiences of enhanced recovery after surgery: Systematic review of qualitative studies. BMJ Open. 2019;9:e022259.

 

Engleman D T, Ali W B, Williams J B, et al. Guidelines for perioperative care in cardiac surgery: Enhanced Recovery After Surgery Society recommendations. JAMA Surg. 2019;154(8):755-766.

 

Memtsoudis S G, Poeran J, Kehlet H. Enhanced Recovery After Surgery in the United States: From evidence-based practice to uncertain science? JAMA. Published online February 28, 2019.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat