April 20, 2016

Emotional intelligence: A mark of superior OR leadership

By: OR Manager
Share

Emotional intelligence is a phrase bandied about in the literature and lay press, but what exactly is it and why should OR leaders care about it? Emotional intelligence (EI) is linked to higher levels of patient, staff, and physician satisfaction as well as patient safety. As such, it’s an important skill that’s a mark of superior OR leadership.

Emotions are difficult to manage because what we absorb from our senses passes through the limbic system—the emotional center of the brain—before reaching the rational center of the brain, often causing us to react without stopping to be aware of what those emotions are and how we should (or want) to respond to them.

David Caruso, PhD, operating room, emotional intelligence

David Caruso, PhD

“Emotional intelligence consists of the ability to accurately read people’s emotions, understand them, and manage them effectively,” says David Caruso, PhD, a psychologist at the Yale Center for Emotional Intelligence, special assistant to the dean of Yale College, and cofounder of the Emotional Intelligence Skills Group. “It’s a hard skill that can be defined and measured in an objective manner.”

 

EI benefits managers

Caruso, who speaks about EI around the world, is a codeveloper of the Mayer–Salovey–Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test and coauthor of The Emotionally Intelligent Manager. He says the concept of EI, developed by psychologists Peter Salovey and John Mayer, dates back to 1990. In 1995, Daniel Goleman published Emotional Intelligence, bringing the phrase to a wider audience.

Since then, many have seen the value of EI for leaders.

Rose Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, CNL, FAAN, operating room, emotional intelligence

Rose Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, CNL, FAAN

“There is strong evidence that leaders who have high emotional intelligence are more effective in their roles, have a more satisfied staff, are far better at negotiation and collaboration, and promote healthier work environments,” says Rose Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, CNL, FAAN, professor and director of the Nursing Leadership Institute at Christine E. Lynn College of Nursing, Florida Atlantic University, in Boca Raton. “Leadership really begins when you are able to manage yourself, and self-management or personal mastery requires emotional intelligence.”

EI skills have been categorized in different ways (sidebar, p 14), but in general, EI has proven benefits for leaders of all types.

EI and transformational leadership

Studies have found a correlation between EI and transformational leadership. Lauraine Spano-Szekely, DNP, MBA, BSN, RN, lead author of a 2016 study of front-line managers that found this correlation, says the results “lead you to believe emotional intelligence is really important for our leaders and our managers to cope in today’s healthcare system and to lead through the amount of change that is occurring. The study highlights the importance of EI characteristics to transformational leadership.”

Spano-Szekely, senior vice president of patient care services and chief nurse officer at Northern Westchester Hospital in Mount Kisco, New York, adds that the correlation of EI with job satisfaction and better outcomes provides the business case for EI.

A 2015 study, coauthored by Brenda Tyczkowski, DNP, RN, RHIA, also found a correlation between EI and transformational leadership, but not with transactional or laissez-faire leadership styles. Tyczkowski, assistant professor and academic director of the health information management and technology program at the University of Wisconsin Green Bay, notes that EI improves leader-staff relationships.

“There is a deepening of understanding,” she says of leaders with EI skills. “You really focus in on the person you’re talking to and tune into the people around you to see how you can interact with them in a meaningful manner.”

EI has even been credited with facilitating wise management decisions that led to smooth transitions of perioperative care at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, for victims of the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing, according to a report in the American Journal of Disaster Medicine.

 

Enhancing EI

Janet Wessel Krejci, PhD, RNA, operating room, emotional intelligence

Janet Wessel Krejci, PhD, RNA

2015 study by Weiszbrod associated EI with healthcare leadership competence. So can leaders foster their EI abilities? Caruso cautions, “It’s extremely difficult to develop these [EI] skills on your own.”

Leaders must be able to detect subtle nuances and signals in the feedback they get from colleagues and staff. For example, a staff nurse could say, “That was a great meeting you ran.” The leader who lacks EI skills could take the statement at face value, missing any irony or hint that the nurse was only being polite and not sincere in the feedback.

Despite these challenges, EI skills can be improved if leaders are committed to the process. “The good news is that we can develop and improve in our own emotional intelligence, but there has to be intentionality on the part of leaders and their staff to do this,” Sherman says.

“It’s a commitment to say to yourself, ‘If I’m going to be a stronger leader, I have to understand my influence on others,’” adds Janet Wessel Krejci, PhD, RN, vice president for academic affairs and provost at Illinois State University, Normal.

Krejci, who consults on leadership topics and speaks on EI, says, “That seems very basic, but most people will overestimate how emotionally intelligent they are and underestimate the problems they can cause in terms of their influence over others.” For example, few leaders will self-identify as a bad leader.

Brenda Tyczkowski, DNP, RN, RHIA, operating room, emotional intelligence

Brenda Tyczkowski, DNP, RN, RHIA

Getting honest feedback from a mentor, completing continuing education courses, and reading research and books about EI can help improve skills.

“You can enhance your own ability for emotional intelligence and make it a conscious part of yourself in the work place,” Tyczkowski says. She suggests leaders engage in self-reflection. “After you have an interaction with your staff, reflect back on that and think how things could have been better or different.”

A key part of improving EI is developing awareness of emotions. “Self-awareness is at the base of emotional intelligence,” says Krejci. Without an understanding of how verbal and nonverbal behavior affects others, leaders can’t be emotionally intelligent.

According to the book Emotional Intelligence 2.0, only 36% of people can correctly identify their emotions as they occur. “That’s a powerful finding based on a lot of data,” Caruso says, adding, “Some of this might also be due to the lack of a basic emotion vocabulary.”

When asked, “How are you?” most people simply give a short answer such as, “Fine,” which provides little useful information. Even when people start assessing their own emotions, they often don’t use concrete words to describe those feelings. But until you understand your feelings, you can’t manage them.

“Emotions are data points,” Caruso says. By understanding these data, leaders can better understand what is happening with themselves and with others (sidebar, p 15).

Sherman offers the following advice for honing your EI skills:

• Seek feedback on your behavior to understand how others see you.

• Evaluate all negative feedback and reactions to your behavior to see where you may have problems with EI.

• Self-reflect on how you have managed your emotions in highly charged situations with conflict. Ask yourself if there is room for improvement.

• Assess how you manage your stress level and whether this interferes with relationships with others.

• Determine your EI strengths and weaknesses, and develop a personal action plan.

• Do cognitive rehearsals when confronted with difficult situations; assess in advance how you will manage if you are losing control of a situation.

“You can teach these skills in the workplace and develop an individualized plan for strengthening your EI,” Sherman says.

Caruso acknowledges that leaders and staff can be resistant to these efforts. In his work with nurses and other healthcare professionals, he says, “I think there is a concern that, ‘my life is hard enough as it is; please don’t make it harder by asking me to open myself up to the troubles of the world by becoming more aware of my emotions and the emotions of everyone around me.’”

To reduce resistance and to be a more ethical practitioner, Caruso suggests emphasizing the skill of effectively managing your own emotions. “To me, that’s the most important EI skill. That’s where you want to start,” he says. “I think what resonates with a nurse is, ‘We’re going to teach you strategies to help you more effectively manage your own emotions. As we master those, we will be helping you manage the emotions of others that you interact with and acquire other skills.’”

 


Emotional intelligence skills

Emotional intelligence (EI) skills are often categorized as follows:

Personal competence

  • Self-awareness: You recognize your own emotions and how they affect your thoughts and behavior, know your strengths and weaknesses, and have self-confidence.
  • Self-management: You’re able to control impulsive feelings and behaviors, manage your emotions in healthy ways, take initiative, follow through on commitments, and adapt to changing circumstances.
    Social competence
  • Social awareness: You can understand the emotions, needs, and concerns of other people, pick up on emotional cues, feel comfortable socially, and recognize the power dynamics in a group or organization.
  • Relationship management: You know how to develop and maintain good relationships, communicate clearly, inspire and influence others, work well in a team, and manage conflict.
    This information, put forth by Daniel Goleman in his book Emotional Intelligence, differs somewhat from the ability model of EI, which focuses on the following set of skills:
  • Accurately perceiving emotions (How do I feel? How does the other person feel?)
  • Using emotions to help you think and to connect (Is the mood helpful? Does it focus our attention, motivate us, or blind us?)
  • Understanding the causes of emotions, how they change, and how to describe complex feelings (Why do I feel this way? Why does the other person feel this way? How will we feel?)
  • Managing emotions so they can be used to motivate, inspire, and problem solve while not overwhelming us. (Do the decision and actions include emotional and logical data to achieve an adaptive outcome?)

For more information, see: http://www.eiskillsgroup.com/about-ei/.
Source for Goleman definitions: Rose Sherman, EdD, RN, NEA-BC, CNL, FAAN.


 

Fostering an EI environment

“Potentially, emotional intelligence can also help eliminate or decrease bullying and build a healthier work environment,” Sherman says. Fostering a healthy work environment starts with the nurse leader.

“The best nurse managers are modeling [EI] behaviors and coaching around those behaviors even though they don’t call it being emotionally intelligent,” Caruso says. “They see it as simply doing their job.” But becoming aware of the behavior they are modeling can help nurse leaders and staff better connect with the desired EI behavior.

Krejci advises leaders to think about what their verbal and nonverbal behavior is communicating to others. “If I’m someone who depends on you to lead me, or you are the person to evaluate me or to have influence over my life at work, those messages are magnified,” she says.

Krejci adds that leaders have to be clear about their daily goals and then be sure their actions are congruent with their goals. “If your goal is to create an environment where people feel they have a sense of belonging, they’re valued, they’re trying be the best they can be, and they’re working together as a team to get the best outcomes, you have to ask yourself if what are you saying, doing, and projecting would lead someone to believe that’s really your goal,” she says.

Hiring the right people is one step in creating an environment where EI thrives. According to Emotional Intelligence 2.0, EI accounts for 58% of performance in all types of jobs.

“We should be looking to see if they [job candidates] have emotional intelligence characteristics before we hire them,” Spano-Szekely says. “If you hire people with emotional intelligence, you’ll spend less money on recruitment because they will succeed in their role.”

One possible criterion to look for in nurse managers is certification. Spano-Szekely found that administrative certification was associated with EI, and a 2015 study by Ohlson and Anderson found significantly higher EI scores in nurse managers who were certified in any specialty compared to those not certified at all.

For nurse leaders, Spano-Szekely recommends including EI concepts in management training. “It’s not just teaching them things like how to do a budget or performance appraisal,” she says. “It’s giving them the know-how for building relationships, navigating the organization, and understanding how they are approaching a situation.” EI should also be incorporated into leadership development programs.

Tyczkowski suggests having staff take a test that assesses EI. “You can then open a discussion based on the results,” she says. For more information on assessment options, see:

• Mayer–Salovey–Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test (http://www.eiconsortium.org/measures/msceit.html)

• Daniel Goleman’s website (http://www.danielgoleman.info/ei-assessments)

• EQ-I 2.0 (https://tap.mhs.com/EQi20.aspx).

 


Understanding your emotions

David Caruso, PhD, a psychologist at the Yale Center for Emotional Intelligence, uses the grid below to help people better understand their emotions. On a scale of 0 to 10, rank how you are feeling in two areas: energy and pleasantness. The results will fall into one of four quadrants, each of which defines emotions within that quadrant. Caruso notes that the emotions in each quadrant have value, depending on the task at hand. “It’s not possible to always be happy, and it’s not even smart,” he says. “It’s important to match the mood to the task.” For example, an OR leader in a sad mood would be better able to identify errors in the business plan he or she is preparing to justify outpatient total knee surgery.

emotional intelligence grid, operating room management


 

Harnessing emotions

OR leaders have a wealth of emotions flowing around them during the day. “They’re there, and you have a choice,” Caruso says. “You can ignore them at your peril, or you can harness them.”

One way to harness them is through EI. “Research shows that leaders with high emotional intelligence have staff who want to follow that leader, who want to work with that leader, who want to do their best for that leader, and that leaders with high emotional intelligence get more opportunities, more promotions, and are more engaged,” Krejci says. ✥

 

 

References

Bradberry T, Greaves J. Emotional Intelligence 2.0. San Diego: TalentSmart. 2009.

Chang B P, Vacanti J C, Michaud Y, et al. Emotional intelligence in the operating room: Analysis from the Boston Marathon bombing. Am J Disaster Med. 2014;9(2):77-85.

Dugan J W, Weatherly R A, Girod D A, et al. A longitudinal study of emotional intelligence training for otolaryngology residents and faculty. JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2014;140(8):720-726.

Ohlson S M, Anderson M A. Ability emotional intelligence of nurse managers in the Midwestern United States. Asia-Pac J of Oncol Nurs. 2015;2(2):82-88.

Pichoff A M, Lin D M, Stiegler M. Emotional intelligence: Critical for patient safety and professional success. American Society of Anesthesiologists Newsletter. 2015;79(5). http://www.asahq.org/resources/publications/newsletter-articles/2015/may-2015/emotional-intelligence.

Spano-Szekely L, Quinn Griffin M T, Clavelle J, et al. Emotional intelligence and transformational leadership in nurse managers. J Nurs Admin. 2016;46(2):101-108.

Tyczkowski B, Vandenhouten C, Reilly J, et al. Emotional intelligence and nursing leadership styles among nurse managers. Nurs Admin Q. 2015;39(2):172-180.

Weiszbrod T. Health care leader competencies and the relevance of emotional intelligence. Health Care Manag. 2015;34(2):140-146.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat