Total joint replacements have grown rapidly in recent years, thanks to an aging population and advances in surgical techniques and pain management. As a result, many healthcare facilities have added joint and spine procedures to their service lines. Others would like to know how to do this.
What’s involved in adding a service line? Who are your key stakeholders? How do you determine appropriate staffing levels and case volume? And once things are up and running, what must you do to ensure ongoing success?
Answers to these questions may be gleaned from Virtua in Voorhees, New Jersey, which has been operating a successful orthopedic service line since 2003.
Surgeon and staff collaboration, dedication, and a commitment to patient satisfaction are the key ingredients, according to Jennifer Smith, MSN, RN, ACNS-BC, CPHQ, director of clinical outcomes for the orthopedic service line, and Carol Childress, BSN, RN, CNOR, director of surgical services. They shared their insights during the 2016 OR Business Management Conference. Much of what they’ve done could be applied in other facilities looking to add service lines, regardless of procedure type.
When Virtua leaders decided to add an orthopedic service line, orthopedic surgery was being performed at two of their acute care hospitals. Rapid growth of the orthopedic service line, which focused on joints, spine, and sports medicine, resulted in decreased OR block time and inpatient bed availability.
Senior leadership decided to create a third location for joint replacement surgery. In 2012, the Joint Replacement Institute (JRI), a 53,000 square foot facility, was added as a wing of one of the acute care hospitals, thus creating a “hospital within a hospital.”
The JRI is dedicated to minimally invasive hip and knee replacements, Smith said. “We do a minimally invasive knee replacement called ‘quad sparing,’ which means we don’t cut the quadriceps muscle. Most patients go home the same day or the day after surgery,” she explained.
“We wanted to be efficient and streamline processes, using very few resources from the main hospital,” Smith said. “We have our own preadmission testing area [PAT], surgical services area, prep area, postanesthesia care unit [PACU], six ORs, 30 inpatient beds, a physical therapy department, and our own sterilization processing department.”
In 2015, more than 2,000 primary hip and knee replacements were performed at the JRI, and the MAKOplasty robot was added for partial knee and hip procedures.
In April 2015, the JRI entered electively into Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ bundled payment program, and has consistently provided care under its established Medicare target without compromising quality, according to Smith.
“Our health system is the result of two systems that merged in the late 1990s,” Smith explained. “When we first started our service line, the health systems weren’t yet integrated, and we had two different medical staffs with different bylaws. In one hospital, orthopedics was a section of the department of surgery, and in the other hospital it was its own department. We had two different nursing unions and different policy and procedure manuals,” she said. The two hospitals’ physical facilities, staffs, and leaders were also very different.
Other challenges, according to Childress, were as follows:
• Block time availability was limited, and it was hard to onboard surgeons because new surgeons could add only one or two cases per week.
• Increased volumes in robotic and bariatric surgical procedures put a strain on sterile processing because of the complex instruments used in those procedures. Turnover times for orthopedic instrument processing increased.
• Wait times for inpatient beds sometimes stretched to 6 hours in the PACU, which created bottlenecks in the OR.
Leaders including the assistant vice president, medical director of the joint replacement program, and orthopedic department chairs for each hospital first had to define the service line and everyone’s role and responsibilities. They also had to identify key stakeholders, including the caregivers responsible for patients pre- and postoperatively.
Multidisciplinary meetings were held monthly with service line and hospital leaders as well as representatives from physical therapy, case management, home care, rehabilitation, quality measurement, and marketing.
“We realized we also needed to include infection control, supply chain, and staff from surgeons’ offices,” Smith said. Surgeons’ offices schedule the procedures, so it was important to communicate any process changes to ensure patients would receive current information.
Early on, stakeholders were asked to imagine 6-month, 1-year, 5-year, and 10-year goals. To encourage participation, these ground rules were set:
• Leave titles at the door; this removes hierarchy and allows every opinion to be valued.
• Whatever happens in the meeting stays in the meeting.
• Hand over day-to-day responsibilities to someone else for the duration of the meeting, and give the meeting your full attention.
Ultimately, the JRI was designed for optimal flow, and key stakeholders collaborated with architects, Childress said. “The architects built foam models and set them up in a local warehouse so that the stakeholders could walk through and try things out. One surgeon even sat down on a model toilet to make sure it was high enough for the total hip patients.”
Processes were developed through Lean methodology, Childress said. Departments that interacted and influenced each other’s workflow were divided into subgroups:
• office staff, scheduling, and PAT
• inpatient, physical therapy, and case management
• OR and central sterile services (CSS).
“Over a 9-month period, groups mapped out processes and together identified a new design with best practices,” Childress said.
Surgeons participating in the JRI must be trained in the minimally invasive quad-sparing technique, perform a minimum of 50 joint replacements per year, and agree to use a standard vendor, according to Childress. Surgeons and anesthesia providers aim for length of stays of less than 3 days.
A nurse navigator is assigned to each surgeon. The navigator schedules the patients’ PAT appointments and helps coordinate the preoperative workup with the primary care provider. Outpatients go through the PAT process 4 weeks preoperatively to allow time for clearances.
The PAT process was driven by anesthesia providers, who worked to eliminate unnecessary testing and minimize lab work. H&Ps are done 2 weeks preoperatively by a physician’s assistant, and anesthesia providers then review charts so that 100% of patients are cleared prior to surgery.
To reduce turnover times, nurses help break down equipment and clean rooms.

The Joint Replacement Institute dashboard is reviewed at least quarterly with the entire leadership team, results are shared with staff, and a dashboard is posted in each staff lounge to ensure data transparency.
Source: Virtua. Used with permission.
Standardizing practice at each facility and focusing on quality outcomes have been key to success, Smith said (sidebar, p 9).
For example, each OR is stocked exactly the same way, furniture and equipment setup is standard, and cases are set up exactly the same way, Childress said.
Childress is proud of the fact that the immediate use steam sterilization rate has been 0% over the past 3 years. OR and CSS staff have worked to improve their case cart system. They now use large enclosed carts that are lined up and labeled with a generic procedure list.
“After trays are sterilized and cooled, they’re taken directly from the sterilization racks and placed onto the labeled, predesignated cart,” Childress said. “This avoids excessive handling and eliminates the extra step of putting them onto a storage rack and then onto a case cart. It also eliminates unnecessary storage and keeps us in compliance with the recommendation not to stack wrapped trays on top of each other.”
In addition, each cart is set up exactly the same way, and instruments sent to CSS after surgery are organized according to a protocol that speeds up breakdown of the instrument table and helps CSS when they’re loading sterilizers.
After the first 3 months at the new JRI, custom packs were reviewed and revised, Childress noted. Items used less than 60% of the time were removed.
“We streamlined from four packs (two knee and two hip) down to one total joint pack for all procedures,” Childress explained. “The pack currently has about 38 items in it. We then had to change our preference cards and streamlined those, too. In a recent survey, we learned that an average knee preference card lists 163 items. Ours has 91,” she noted.
Smith pointed out several other changes that have boosted efficiency and outcomes:
• elimination of autologous blood donation, continuous passive motion devices, and epidurals
• use of evidence-based, standardized pre- and postoperative order sets
• standardization of patient education—provide the same information in pre- and postoperative classes regardless of where surgery is done
• use of only one vendor
• use of joint replacement teams at both locations to familiarize staff with surgeons’ preferences
• standardization of staff education and competencies to ensure consistent patient outcomes, regardless of where surgery is done
• shift from day-oriented to goal-oriented care pathway—instead of setting goals for postoperative days 1, 2, and 3, patients are allowed to progress from one goal to the next, working closely with their physical therapists toward earlier discharge.
Twice a year, metrics including volume, projected volume, cost per case, net revenue, strategies, and gaps are reported to upper management, Smith said.
“Everyone in the health organization, even if they don’t do orthopedics, knows what we’re doing, and sometimes we’ll team up with other service lines like pediatrics or women’s health to help solve problems,” she noted.
In the years since the orthopedic service line was started, Virtua has become the tri-county region’s leader in joint replacement, Smith said, with some patients coming from areas like New York City and Philadelphia.
In 2006, only two to three joint replacement cases per day were completed. That rose to six per day in 2012, and is now at a volume of 14 to 15 cases per day.
“We’re only operating 4 days per week, and we’re not consistently using all six ORs. We have three new surgeons who recently finished fellowships. As their practices grow, we expect to be using all six of those ORs on 4 days, and eventually schedule cases on Fridays, too,” Smith said.
Other accomplishments:
• 22-minute average turnover time
• 98% first case on-time starts
• 0.15% surgical site infection rate
• 1.4-day length of stay
• 1% surgical case cancellation rate
• 99% HCAHPS scores (Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems) for 3 years.
“Our surgeons thank the staff individually at the end of the day,” Childress said. “Our lead surgeon has paid random visits to CSS to thank them. Surgeons meet with the CSS supervisor to review tray changes, and they meet weekly with inpatient staff to discuss any concerns.”
Their most recent employee engagement survey showed that 76% of employees are highly engaged and 0 were not engaged, which put them in the 96th percentile nationally, Childress added. ✥
Smith J, Childress C. Six Sigma strategies help start a service line. OR Business Management Conference, 2016.