May 16, 2016

Operational efficiencies: Improvement in first-case start times

By: OR Manager
Share

Many OR leaders have taken on process improvement projects in an effort to save time and money, and some are more successful than others. For some facilities, partnerships with industry experts can enhance the likelihood of achieving and sustaining goals. Such was the case for Beloit Memorial Hospital, which teamed with Stryker Performance Solutions in February 2015 to improve operational efficiencies.

Beloit Memorial Hospital, a 100-bed community-based facility with six ORs, is part of the Beloit Health System in Beloit, Wisconsin. The Beloit team was led by Doris Mulder, CNO; Cindy Terpstra, director of surgical services; and Neel Karne, MD, FACS, a general surgeon.

Beloit Memorial Hospital OR Value Stream Map

Figure 1. The current state value stream map identifies areas in need of improvement. All figures courtesy of Beloit Memorial Hospital. Used with permission.

Defining ‘on time’

At the time, Beloit was trending at 3% on time first-case starts. Delayed on time first-case starts is a common surgeon complaint; it is important for surgeons to have a more predictable schedule not only for the first case but also throughout the day. By making start times more predictable, we maximize surgeons’ operative times.

First, the Beloit team identified the lack of a consistent definition for on time first-case starts. This definition can be patient in the room, anesthesia start, or incision time. The most common definition of the term is patient in the room or “wheels in.”

Next, the team discussed a grace period. Some organizations have a 5-minute grace period. Beloit decided on no grace period with a final definition of on time first-case start as wheels in. Once the Beloit team agreed on this specific definition, the OR policies were updated, and the definition was clearly communicated to all staff through the OR leadership committee, surgical subsection of the general staff, and preoperative and OR staff meetings, with statistics demonstrating the percentage of late case starts.

The OR leadership committee included the chief of surgery, chief of anesthesia (champion), surgeon champion, selected surgeons, chief medical officer, vice president of patient care, director of surgical services; charge nurse, and director of quality. Both the surgeon champion and the anesthesia champion were selected on the basis of several qualifications: respect of their peers, strong communication skills, understanding of the need for process improvement, and willingness to work with their colleagues.

 

On time interaction with patients in the preoperative area varies by care provider

Figure 2. On time interaction with patients in the preoperative area varies by care provider.

On time first-case starts improvement data

Figure 3. On time first-case starts have improved since August 2015.

A 44% reduction in tray instrumentation has been achieved

Figure 4. A 44% reduction in tray instrumentation has been achieved.

Approach

Process improvement efforts started with performing a baseline of the current state. The team began collecting real-time data for on time first-case starts for each OR every day of the week, including reasons for delays. The team then set specific and measurable goals for these metrics: 70% on time first-case starts by August 2015 and 80% by January 2016. The team also mapped the current value stream from surgical scheduling through postoperative recovery (Figure 1, p 29).

Using the PACE (Priority, Action, Consider, Eliminate) methodology, which evaluates each resolution based on overall impact and ease of implementation, the team then focused on the multitude of reasons for delays and prioritized their resolutions. Attempting to implement too many projects at one time would have consumed valuable resources and caused communication challenges with the magnitude of change taking place in a short time frame. Instead, the team made fewer strategic changes over time, allowing each improvement to be adjusted as necessary. Ultimately these changes were sustainable by the team.

 

Improvement

The team started looking upstream to understand what was causing delays for the timely arrival of the patient in the OR. One of the first projects identified was to understand at what time in the preoperative area the anesthesia provider, surgeon, and circulating nurse needed to see the patient in order for the patient to arrive in the OR on time.

The team determined that the anesthesia provider needed to see the patient 15 minutes before wheels in, the surgeon 10 minutes before wheels in, and the circulating nurse 5 minutes before wheels in. This expectation was appropriately documented in OR policies, thoroughly communicated to staff through the OR leadership committee and the surgical subsection of the general staff, and was supported by the anesthesia and surgeon champions.

As demonstrated in Figure 2 (p 30), with the exception of the circulating nurse, it was initially challenging to engage the care providers to consistently meet the defined time frames. The team asked the anesthesia and surgeon champions to speak with their colleagues about the benefits of arriving on time and to demonstrate how meeting these expectations would improve first-case on time starts. To date, all care providers are trending well above 80% for seeing their patients on time in the preoperative area.

The Beloit team continued to work on additional barriers that delayed patients in the process, such as scheduling issues, missing history and physicals, and missing test results. The on time metrics identified above were tracked daily and reported weekly to ensure ongoing awareness and ability to address issues immediately before they became negative trends. The information was posted in the OR lounge area.

With continued focus, process improvement efforts, and metric tracking and reporting, on time first-case starts began to improve. As shown in Figure 3 (p 30), the initial goal of 70% by August 2015 was achieved. The team set an ongoing goal of 80% starting in January 2016. Through daily tracking and collaboration to identify and address outliers as they happen in real time, the team continues to trend around the 80% goal.

The work done to improve on time first-case starts resulted in a more predictable OR schedule, which improved efficiency. Beloit’s annual case volume was 4,330 procedures in 2015, including open heart surgery. The highest volume specialties are general and orthopedic surgery.

Case volume increased by 5.16% compared to the previous year, and total surgical staff hours per case decreased by more than 7% (nearly 2.5 hours per case). This translates into a savings of more than $440,000 annually in staff labor. In addition, the improved efficiency and predictability increased patient, surgeon, and staff satisfaction.

During the value stream mapping process, the Beloit team identified multiple other opportunities to improve efficiency, including reduction of tray instrumentation, standardization of OR turnover, implementation of visual signals, and formation of daily OR huddles. Again, the team used PACE to prioritize these projects.

To save time in both the sterile processing department (SPD) and the OR, it was decided to remove the unused instruments from instrument trays. A cross-functional team of surgical assistants, scrub technicians, and sterile processing specialists reviewed 18 of the most frequently used trays to develop a proposal for the surgeons to approve. As a result, two entire trays were eliminated and instrumentation was reduced by 44%, as shown in Figure 4. These changes eliminated reprocessing of more than 104,000 instruments annually, reducing SPD processing times and increasing OR efficiency through reduced setup and teardown times.

Surgical services optimization is a journey with no end. To achieve continuous process improvement, the team must be engaged, educated on process improvement techniques, and constantly asking, what is next? In this process, it is critical to identify the issues, apply scientific problem-solving techniques, set targets, and track and report results. ✥

 

 Marita Parks, Operational efficiencies: Improvement in first-case start timesStephanie Trevino, Operational efficiencies: Improvement in first-case start timesMarita Parks, MHA, RN (left), and Stephanie Trevino, BSIE, MBA, are program managers for Stryker Performance Solutions, Chicago.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat