What does it take to get endoscopes dry? That is the question that prompted a new study on endoscope drying effectiveness by Ofstead & Associates (St Paul, Minnesota).
“We asked that question after a study we did 2 years ago found that increasing the automated endoscope reprocessor [AER] drying cycle time and increasing the alcohol volume made no difference in dryness. The scopes were still not dry,” lead researcher Cori Ofstead, MSPH, told OR Manager.
Ofstead, an epidemiologist who has published numerous studies on endoscope reprocessing and contamination, says that until that study she and her team had assumed that AERs dried endoscopes. After carefully reading the manufacturer’s instructions for use (IFU), however, they realized the instructions don’t claim that the AER dries the endoscopes, they just say it aids in drying.
Another finding of that study that posed more questions was the reliance on the “gravity method” for drying. Staff hung endoscopes vertically in a cabinet and assumed they would drip dry, says Ofstead. “If you think about the gravity method, however, there is a lot of the scope that isn’t vertical,” she says. “The insertion tube is hanging vertically, but the ports on the control handle are oriented horizontally when the scope is hung up.”
The new study, which was published March 30 ahead of print in the American Journal of Infection Control, evaluates the effectiveness of endoscope drying and storage methods. It also looks at whether different methods resulted in different amounts of dryness and whether there is an association between retained moisture and contamination.
Ofstead and colleagues conducted this new prospective study at three multispecialty hospitals.
A total of 45 endoscopes of different varieties (ie, colonoscopes, bronchoscopes, duodenoscopes, etc) were selected for the study. All had been fully reprocessed and stored for more than 24 hours.
The manufacturers of the endoscopes were Olympus (43 endoscopes) and Karl Storz (2 endoscopes).
Of the 45 endoscopes analyzed, fluid was detected in 49%, and the prevalence of moisture varied significantly by site (5%, 83%, and 85%) (photos, p 8).
High adenosine triphosphate (ATP) levels were found in 22% of the endoscopes, and retained fluid was associated with significantly higher ATP levels.
Microbial growth was detected in 71%, including Stenotrophomonas maltophilia, Citrobacter freundii, and Lecanicillum lecanii/Verticillium dahliae.
Reprocessing and drying practices conformed with guidelines at one site and were substandard at two sites. All sites had damaged endoscopes in use.
Ofstead and her team concluded that inadequate reprocessing and insufficient drying contributed to retained fluid and contamination found inside the endoscopes. They noted that more effective methods of endoscope reprocessing, drying, and maintenance are needed to prevent the retention of fluid, organic material, and bioburden that could cause patient illness or injury.
“After this study and another one we did last year, I am becoming more convinced that it is not humanly possible to do all the things that need to be done right every time in order for scopes to be safe for use,” Ofstead says.
All three study sites were using AERs with peracetic acid high-level disinfection (HLD). Reprocessing practices at one site conformed with current guidelines, but multiple reprocessing deficiencies were found at the other two.
The dirty-to-clean workflow and use of personal protective equipment were substandard. Staff wore the same gloves for handling dirty endoscopes during manual cleaning and for handling other endoscopes after they were disinfected.
Leak testing and manual cleaning were inadequate, and staff at two hospitals said their AERs’ automated cleaning cycles had been disabled to save time. No cleaning-verification tests or visual inspections were done at two of the three sites.
At one site, staff had to perform alcohol flushes manually because the reprocessing system did not perform this function. They then carried dripping wet endoscopes by hand to an unventilated storage cabinet and hung them vertically, without wiping the external surfaces, and inserted the distal ends into reused, dirty Styrofoam blocks. One ureteroscope was stored horizontally on the cabinet bottom because there was insufficient storage space, and the storage cabinets were visibly dirty.
At another site, where the AER performed an alcohol flush and air purge, technicians wiped the external surfaces of the endoscopes with reused towels when they removed them from the AER. Then, holding the endoscope with dirty gloved hands, they used an air pistol without a pressure regulator for 15 to 20 seconds to evacuate fluid from the channels. Pressures were high enough to eject spray in a visible plume from the distal end.
The endoscopes were stored vertically in closed cabinets with ventilation grills and cabinet fans, but the high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA)-filter fans were unplugged or disabled.
At both sites with substandard processing, more than 80% of the endoscopes retained fluid after 24 hours of storage.
At the site where reprocessing practices conformed to guidelines, 95% of the endoscope channels were dry when the AER’s alcohol flush and air purge were followed by 10 minutes of pressure-regulated, forced air drying.
Even though these endoscopes were drier, however, 62% of the HLD endoscopes had microbial growth, and pathogens were found, which suggests that factors beyond reprocessing adherence may affect outcomes.
“What is disturbing to me about our findings is that these hospitals are part of big systems that are Joint Commission accredited, and they were asserting that they were following guidelines,” says Ofstead. “It reinforces for me the value of doing real-world studies to see what is actually happening in hospitals.”
At all three sites, visual inspections found endoscopes with multiple defects were being used. Defects included scratches, non-intact channel lining, and damaged distal ends.
At one site, several endoscopes were up to 15 years old, and the manufacturer no longer provided maintenance. At the other two sites, many endoscopes were more than 3 years old, and staff were hesitant to send them out for repair because of cost concerns.
“Despite AORN, AAMI [Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation], and SGNA [Society of Gastroenterology Nurses and Associates] all saying visual inspections with lighted magnification should be done every time a scope is used, visual inspections are not being done, and we have only been to one site that had magnification stations,” Ofstead says. “These guidelines are 2 years old now, and yet we still aren’t seeing them being followed.”
In four endoscopes that were sterilized at the site with reprocessing practices that conformed to current guidelines, ATP levels were low and no moisture or microbial growth was found.
Though the sample size was too small for statistical significance, rigorous cleaning plus sterilization was more successful than HLD.
“Sterilization may be the answer because it is becoming clear to me that so many scopes are used for surgery so much of the time now that it is a ‘no-brainer’ that they should be sterile,” says Ofstead.
The idea of HLD for endoscopes came about in the 1960s when they weren’t being used for surgery, but it is pretty rare to have a flexible endoscopy without a biopsy today, and some gastroenterologists are doing full-thickness resections of tumors with gastroscopes and colonoscopes, she says.
“More patients are having minimally invasive procedures, and surgeons are performing more complicated procedures with endoscopes that are not only not sterile, but they are not even clean,” she says.
Single-use endoscopes such as bronchoscopes and ureteroscopes might be an alternative.
The study underscores the lack of progress by manufacturers, hospitals, and regulators in reducing the infection risk posed by endoscopes. “There has been little improvement in the 10 years since we have been looking into the quality of endoscope reprocessing,” notes Ofstead. “Some of the practices we observed in this study seemed unbelievable, and I am deeply troubled by this.”
Ofstead says she and her team have alerted the Food and Drug Administration and the Joint Commission about their concerns regarding institutions that have AERs with cycles that have been disabled and drying cabinets with HEPA-filter machinery that has been turned off.
“To intentionally disable equipment because the physicians were telling them they needed faster turnover is wrong,” she says, “and it should not even be an option.”
Ofstead says it is only because she and her team were in these hospitals for a week that they noticed the endoscopes were coming out of the AER too fast because the cycles had been disabled. “I don’t know how widespread this practice is, but we need to put pressure on these systems. There need to be audits by qualified experts who are on staff or who can come in and watch the processes being done,” she says.
“We need to get our houses in order to ensure patient safety.” ✥
Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation/American National Standards Institute. American National Standard, ANSI/AAMI ST 91: Flexible and semi-rigid endoscope processing in health care facilities. 2015:1-70.
AORN. Guideline for processing flexible endoscopes. Guidelines for Perioperative Practice. Denver, Colorado: AORN;2016:675-758.
Mathias J. Dirty scopes persist despite cleaning protocol compliance. OR Manager. 2016;32(11):1, 10-11.
Mathias J. Greater vigilance needed to combat ureteroscope contamination. OR Manager. 2017;33(12):1, 8-11.
Ofstead C L, Heymann O L, Quick M R, et al. Residual moisture and waterborne pathogens inside flexible endoscopes: Evidence from a multisite study of endoscope drying effectiveness. Am J Infect Control. Published online ahead of print March 30, 2018.
Ofstead C L, Quick M R, Eiland J, et al. A glimpse at the true cost of reprocessing endoscopes: Results of a pilot project. IAHCSMM Communique. January/February 2017.
Ofstead C L, Wetzler H P, Eiland J E, et al. Assessing residual contamination and damage inside flexible endoscopes over time. Am J Infect Control. 2016;44:1675-1677.
Petersen B T, Chennat J, Cohen J, et al. Multisociety guideline on reprocessing flexible GI endoscopes. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2011;32:527-537.
Society of Gastroenterology Nurses and Associates. SGNA Standard of infection prevention in the gastroenterology setting. 2015.
Society of Gastroenterology Nurses and Associates. SGNA Standards of infection prevention in reprocessing flexible gastrointestinal endoscopes. 2015.