May 24, 2022

Engaging student nurses to prime the OR nurse pump: Part 1

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

Concerns about the pipeline of OR nurses existed long before COVID-19, but the pandemic has heightened these concerns. Many nurses plan to exit the profession in the next few years (sidebar, Workforce outlook). Unfortunately, the pipeline of replacement nurses is nearly dry as student experiences in the OR have been eliminated or reduced to a day of observation with limited hands-on participation. Fortunately, this situation is changing as schools, health systems, and associations create programs that give students a robust perioperative experience.

Workforce outlook

Numbers from recent surveys point to nursing workforce challenges.

• A February 2022 McKinsey & Company survey found that 32% of RNs reported a likelihood that they would leave their current position providing direct patient care within the next year, up from 22% in February 2021.

• 33% of respondents to the 2021 AORN Salary and Compensation Survey said they were likely or very likely to quit their current role in the next year, up 4% from the 2020 survey. Among those planning to leave, 13% cited retirement as the reason.

• A 2021 nationwide survey conducted by the Competency and Credentialing Institute (CCI) noted that 29.4% of respondents were 55 to 64 years old, and 7.2% were 65 years or older. Only 18% of respondents were under 35.

• Younger nurses are leaving the workforce as well. A study in Health Affairs found that the decrease in nurses during 2021 could be traced more to younger rather than older nurses. For example, there was a 4% reduction in RNs younger than age 35, compared to 1% for nurses older than age 50.

Sources

AORN Salary Survey: 6 Compensation Changes in 2021. December 8, 2021.

Auerbach D I, Buerhaus P I, Staiger D O, et al. A worrisome drop in the number of young nurses. Health Affairs Forefront. April 13, 2022.

Berlin G, Lapointe M, Murphy M. Surveyed nurses consider leaving direct patient care at elevated rates. McKinsey & Company. February 2022.

Stobinski J X, Maio S, Homme C L. Select demographics of nationwide sample of OR nurses. OR Manager. 2022;38(4):20-23.

 

Carol Pehotsky, DNP, RN, NEA-BC, ACNS-BC, CPAN

“When students have a rich experience, they have a better appreciation of the care that’s delivered behind closed doors, and they may decide to choose OR nursing as a career,” says Carol Pehotsky, DNP, RN, NEA-BC, ACNS-BC, CPAN, associate chief nursing officer for surgical services at Cleveland Clinic Health System in Ohio. Pehotsky has hired several new graduate nurses who participated in student programs at the organization.

This two-part series explores creative approaches for engaging students in OR nursing. Part 1 focuses on school-based initiatives, and Part 2 on hospital-based programs. Given that student enrollment in entry-level baccalaureate programs increased by 3.3% in 2021, according to the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN), this is an ideal time to implement programs that can help draw students to the specialty.

 

A three-way partnership

Linda Groah, MSN, RN, CNOR, NEA-BC, FAAN

Schools, professional associations, and health systems have traditionally operated as silos when it comes to the nursing workforce. A partnership between Chamberlain University, AORN, and multiple health systems is breaking down those silos. The partnership grew out of discussions between Karen Cox, PhD, RN, FACHE, FAAN, president of Chamberlain, which has multiple nursing schools across the US, and Linda Groah, MSN, RN, CNOR, NEA-BC, FAAN, CEO and executive director of AORN. They noted that most schools do not have faculty with perioperative experience, and that only a limited number of schools were using AORN’s Introduction to Perioperative Nursing course tailored for students. The two saw the advantages of pooling resources. “That’s how the partnership between the academic, place of employment, and specialty organization came together,” Groah says.

Coley Vitztum, PhD, RN, CNS-BC, CRNFA

 

The partnership fits well with Chamberlain’s goal of helping students find the right nursing fit before graduation, which will help increase retention and address the current shortage. “We are building on a generalist background so students are practice ready, but have a specialty focus if they choose,” says Coley Vitztum, PhD, RN, CNS-BC, CRNFA, program director of “Practice Ready. Specialty Focused.™” at Chamberlain, who worked in perioperative nursing for 30 years and leads the current initiative. “We want to guide them to the type of job that has meaning to them” (sidebar, Practice Ready. Specialty Focused.™).

 

Students can learn about perioperative nursing through a non-credit course that is free, courtesy of AORN, to pre-licensure students in their senior year of the bachelor of science nursing (BSN) program. The course, launched in January 2022, encompasses roles and responsibilities of the OR nurse, knowledge of asepsis principles, safety concerns in the perioperative setting, and patient social determinants of health. Students complete the 16 online modules of a slightly modified version of AORN’s Introduction to Perioperative Nursing course over two, 8-week sessions. The modules cover topics such as infection prevention, surgical team communication, patient transfer and positioning, safety in the surgical suite, surgical counts, postanesthesia care, and surgical attire.

Those who complete the course receive a certificate of achievement and earn a digital education badge. Digital badges are evidence of microcredentialing, which shows achievement in a particular area. “Microcredentialing has become incredibly popular, so the digital badge is something they can use on Glassdoor [a job search portal] and LinkedIn,” Vitztum says. “It can give them a leg up in the job market because they can show they have had exposure to the perioperative area.”

Students who complete the course are eligible for an 8-week clinical rotation that includes the OR, postanesthesia care unit (PACU), and preoperative area. The rotation is based in participating health systems, including Emory, Loyola Medicine, Ochsner, Advocate Aurora Health, and Ascension. “They come out with a better understanding of the specialty that can benefit future employers,” Vitztum says. “Students who decide perioperative nursing is a good fit for their strengths and talents are more likely to have a sense of belonging and be engaged in their work,” she says.

During the rotation, students are placed with preceptors who have completed an AORN preceptor course. “Many times preceptors don’t understand the concept of adult leading, and [the course] goes into that, which is an important part of the learning process,” Groah says. Preceptors also use the AORN skills checklist as a guide when working with students. If a student cannot participate in an activity (such as administering medications), the preceptor takes time to explain what is happening and answer questions. “Preceptors help interpret knowledge so it makes sense to the student,” Vitztum says.

Currently, the perioperative course is available at three Chicago area schools, Atlanta, and New Orleans, but the plan is to expand it to all 23 Chamberlain campuses. The school uses marketing materials to recruit students and has had hospital OR nurses who are AORN members talk to students to generate interest. Those efforts have paid off. More than 100 students participated in the first cohort, and nearly 150 are enrolled in the current one. There will be three cohorts each year (January, May, and September). Vitztum works closely with AORN, leaders on campuses, and leaders and preceptors at the partner health systems.

The response from students has been positive. “This is not a proscribed course, so they like having the autonomy to decide to take it,” Vitztum says. “It gives them a sense of empowerment about their future.” She adds that perioperative nurses have been positive as well. “Whatever is impacting the shortage in the hospital is impacting us at the academic level as well,” says Vitztum. “These are not problems in isolation; we have to identify them and work together with health systems and professional associations to solve them.”

Other schools of nursing have taken different approaches to increase the OR nurse pipeline, including a required course and an immersive experience.

 

Required perioperative course

Rebecca Patton, DNP, RN, CNOR, FAAN

The Frances Payne Bolton School of Nursing at Case Western University in Cleveland, Ohio, has been aggressive in giving students perioperative experience, thanks to the efforts of Rebecca Patton, DNP, RN, CNOR, FAAN, chair of the Lucy Jo Atkinson Professorship in Perioperative Nursing. Perioperative nursing is one of the areas of studies listed on the school’s website, on equal footing with more traditional options such as medical-surgical and pediatric.

Patton developed a for-credit course, Care of the Adult and Older Adult with Complex Health Alterations & Care of the Perioperative Patient, for junior level students. The course is designed “to enhance the knowledge, cognitive, and psychomotor skills to care for patients undergoing operative or invasive procedures,” according to the course syllabus. Patton consulted Cleveland area OR leaders before starting the course in 2011. “They participated in designing the program and continue to provide input,” she says. This ensures that students learn what is needed in the clinical setting.

The Quality and Safety Education for Nurses (QSEN) competencies and AORN’s Perioperative Patient-Focused Model are incorporated into the 8-week, 3.5 credit hour course, which comprises didactic (14 hours), skills lab (21 hours), and clinical (98 hours) components (sidebar, Perioperative course schedule sample).

The skills lab includes simulation exercises related to topics such as how to position patients. “Positioning skills in the OR apply everywhere outside the OR,” Patton says, pointing out how the OR experience has wider application than students and faculty members might think. Students also can apply what they have learned in other courses. For example, their critical care experience will help them understand how patients with comorbidities need to be monitored.

The 98 hours of clinical time is distributed over 14 days—2 days each week for 7 weeks in a hospital or ambulatory surgery center. During the first two clinical days, Patton reviews basic perioperative information. On day 3, students follow a patient through the continuum, from the preoperative area through PACU. From then on, students are in the OR under the wing of a circulating nurse preceptor. There is also some flexibility for students; for instance, one might spend a half-day in the central processing department or ask to scrub in on multiple cases.

“By week 5 or 6, students have a high level of independence,” Patton says. “They can assess patients preoperatively, conduct a time out, do a closing count, and call report.” Patton attributes this independence to the willingness of staff preceptors to work with students. “They find experiences for the students and let them do things instead of making them stand in a corner and not touch anything,” she says.

Patton has worked to partner with clinical staff and leaders to build trust and partnerships. “I have regular meetings with OR educators and managers and make rounds on all clinical sites at least once a semester,” she says. In fact, some facility educators give guest lectures. “They are able to bring the information to life,” Patton says.

In addition to the junior-level course, students can choose the perioperative setting as their senior clinical practicum. “Before we offered the [junior level] course, very few students picked the OR,” Patton says. “Now we have more people picking the OR for their practicum than we can accommodate.” She estimates that about 5% to 8% choose the OR each year; already six are signed up for the fall semester.

Many of these students then go on to work in the OR as new graduates. Because they know what to expect, these nurses are more likely to stay. In other cases, new graduates who have been exposed to the OR through the practicum or original course might first choose other specialties such as medical-surgical or critical care, but end up working in the OR because they did not enjoy their initial choice.

 

An immersion experience

Rather than a single dedicated course, Ursuline College’s Breen School of Nursing and Health Professions in Pepper Pike, Ohio, has created an immersion experience that integrates the OR experience into student nurses’ sophomore and junior years. The program started in 2016 with University Hospitals of Cleveland, and in 2018, the Cleveland Clinic partnered with Ursuline to expand the perioperative experience to include precepted clinical time.

Laura Goliat, DNP, APRN, FNP-BC, ANEF

Laura Goliat, DNP, APRN, FNP-BC, ANEF, associate professor and interprofessional education coordinator for the school of nursing, leads the program, which was partly developed in response to the faculty’s desire to strengthen the curriculum in key areas, such as infection control and the QSEN competencies: patient-centered care, teamwork/collaboration, evidence-based practice, quality improvement, safety, and informatics. “The OR is the perfect place for students to develop these important competencies,” Goliat says.

The program consists of three phases. Phase I occurs during sophomore year, is held in a simulation lab or hospital OR department, and consists of a 4-hour classroom session on the essentials of perioperative nursing. The class includes a tour of the OR and hands-on learning activities, such as preoperative assessment, IV skills, gowning, gloving, sterile and aseptic technique, and postoperative assessment, led by OR nurse educators.

During Phase II, junior-level students complete a 12-hour clinical experience with an OR nurse preceptor. The experience occurs over 2 days for traditional BSN students and in a day for students in the second-degree accelerated nursing program. Students are paired with a preceptor for a hands-on experience in the preoperative area and OR. “We want them to experience the holistic nature of caring for a surgical patient,” Goliat says. The experience is also designed to strengthen students’ knowledge and care of postoperative patients when they return to their regularly assigned clinical units. Students provide direct patient care, under the supervision of their preceptor, and perform activities such as starting IVs, admitting patients to the OR, giving handoffs, critically assessing patients, and interfacing with the interdisciplinary team.

During Phase III, scheduled to start in Fall 2022, senior level students will complete a 12-hour clinical, precepted experience in PACU as part of their critical care nursing course. The experience will emphasize minute-by-minute assessments/evaluations, applying critical thinking skills, and communicating directly with the interdisciplinary team. Seniors in their last semester also will have the option of choosing an OR practicum experience of 180 clinical hours with an OR nurse preceptor.

Goliat says that since implementing Phases I and II, standardized scores for Assessment Technologies Institute (ATI) testing have significantly improved in safety and infection control and management of care. (ATI testing augments classroom work and helps students prepare for the National Council Licensure Examination [NCLEX].) She sees perioperative experience as having high value for students. “It improves key skills in teamwork and collaboration, communication, critical thinking, safety and infection control, and very importantly, their confidence in caring for patients on the surgical units and working as a member of an effective interdisciplinary team,” she says. “Nursing students aren’t typically exposed to perioperative nursing, so this experience may also serve to generate interest in the specialty.”

 

Making the case

OR leaders who live in areas where schools of nursing are offering little or no perioperative experience may want to meet with educators to encourage change. These leaders have a good story to tell. As noted, the perioperative setting is ideal for reinforcing QSEN competencies. For example, Patton at Case Western notes that during their clinical experience, students usually see an amputation as a result of a surgical site infection after a total knee replacement that did not respond to antibiotics. “This drives homes the importance of infection control, and that there’s no reason for not following standards related to prevention,” she says.

Learning in the perioperative setting does not preclude learning about what is traditionally considered medical-surgical topics, says Vitztum at Chamberlain. “We focus on infection prevention in the OR,” she says. “Why not take advantage and build on that rather than seeing it as not med-surg related?” Other transferrable areas include understanding blood loss, intake and output, and hemodynamics. Even the effect of social determinants of health can be seen in the OR, as nurses assess postoperative caregiver and transportation options.

OR leaders also can share the viewpoint of

Joan Stanley, PhD, CRNP, FAAN, FAANP

Joan Stanley, PhD, CRNP, FAAN, FAANP, chief academic officer of AACN. Stanley recognizes that nursing education must meet the healthcare system’s need for nurses in many specialties, and says: “New nurses entering the workforce must be prepared as a generalist to practice across a variety of settings with diverse patient populations across the lifespan.” She adds that the new AACN Essentials outline competency expectations of graduates, is used by schools in designing curriculum, and calls for students to have clinical experiences in the four spheres of practice: disease prevention/promotion of health and wellbeing, chronic disease care, regenerative or restorative care, and hospice/palliative/supportive care. “This new expectation presents a new opportunity for nursing programs to embed learning experiences focused on perioperative care in diverse settings, which would include working with other members of the healthcare team,” Stanley says.

Despite support for the perioperative experience, OR leaders should know that some faculty members may be resistant. Patton overcame resistance by structuring the perioperative course so that it focuses on leadership, quality, and safety, and explaining the importance of what OR nurses do. “Faculty who haven’t had OR experience see it as not nursing but technical skills and doing what the doctor tells you to do,” she says. “The first thing we teach the students is that nothing happens in the OR unless the circulating nurse wants it to happen, and you’re the patient’s advocate.” In the OR, students truly enact interprofessional practice because they have to talk with the surgeon and anesthesiologist about issues such as an incorrect count. “They learn how to interact during critical discussion times,” says Patton, who adds, “Some [faculty members] who were early critics of the program now talk very proudly of the course and what it adds to the program.”

OR leaders also could suggest to faculty that schools may gain a competitive edge by offering experience that other schools do not. However, Goliat notes that OR leaders should understand that the time it takes to revise a curriculum varies. For instance, adding a course is a significant curriculum revision that would require prior approval from the board of nursing and notification to the school’s governing body to ensure accreditation requirements are maintained, but integrating perioperative experiences into existing courses do not require pre-approval. For example, at Ursuline, Phase II and Phase III simply substitute one clinical day on a medical/surgical unit with one hands-on day in the preoperative, OR, and PACU settings.

It takes precious time for OR leaders to make the case for including perioperative experiences for student nurses, but the effort can reap rewards in the shape of new staff. Pehotsky at the Cleveland Clinic notes that just enhancing students’ observational experience can lead to someone deciding they would be interested in OR nursing. She suggests OR leaders reach out to educators to start or enhance these observational experiences. “Whenever I’ve reached out to academic partners and said, ‘Let’s make this better,’ no one has ever said no,” Pehotsky says. “They want their students to have a positive experience too.” Part 2 of this two-part series includes more suggestions for improving the observational experience.

 

The student-OR connection

The bottom line is that there is hope for strengthening the bonds between education and perioperative nursing. Innovative programs can fill the pipeline by engaging students. “The OR combines high tech and high touch nursing, which makes it appealing to younger people,” AORN’s Groah says. “They also want to be part of a team, and that’s part of the OR story.”

 

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial
services to healthcare publications.

References

Nursing schools see enrollment increases in entry-level programs, signaling strong interest in nursing careers. AACN. April 5, 2022.

 

Perioperative clinical immersion program offers student nurses hands-on experience. ConsultQD. n.d.

 

QSEN Institute. Competencies. 2020.

 

Stobinski J X, Maio S, Homme C L. Select demographics of nationwide sample of OR nurses. OR Manager. 2022;38(4):20-23.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat