The Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI) released the updated ANSI/AAMI ST91:2021 Flexible and semi-rigid endoscope processing in healthcare facilities. The revised version reflects current research and advancements in flexible endoscope processing. What follows is an abbreviated summary of some of the key revisions and additions. Future columns will delve further into the major changes.
The revisions made are based on research that has shown outbreaks of multi-drug-resistant organism infections related to flexible endoscopes. Review of the processes and procedures used to reprocess these complex and sophisticated devices revealed failures in reprocessing steps that could jeopardize patient safety. In fact, multiple peer-reviewed publications in several countries, including the US, have documented breaches in processing that led to patient exposure to improperly processed flexible and semi-rigid endoscopes, and subsequent infections. Mitigating these risks hinges on proper processing techniques from point-of-use treatment through all processing steps [including complete drying after high-level disinfection (HLD)] and then to safe transport of the devices for patient use.
Thorough cleaning of these complex instruments is critically important. To accomplish this task, the revised ST91 includes additional recommendations for cleaning equipment, techniques, and implements. In the decontamination area, three sinks are ideal, according to the standard (one sink used for leak testing, another for manual cleaning, and the third for critical water rinsing); however, at this time, two sinks or one sink with two separate basins may be used. There should also be additional space provided for delayed processing. Sink size and location(s), flushing accessories, and ergonomics are all important considerations to facilitate effective cleaning as well as employee safety. Sink size can affect processing because tightly coiling of the endoscope could damage components, including image or light bundles, internal channels, tubes, and/or angulation wires. Using ergonomic height-adjustable sinks helps personnel avoid bending over to perform cleaning tasks. Sinks located too high or too low increase the risk of back injury or strain.
Inadequate training often lies at the heart of flexible endoscope processing errors. To prevent processing errors, it is recommended that all personnel performing endoscope processing tasks complete formal training and competency verification in all aspects of endoscope processing prior to their first solo assignment to perform these tasks. Additionally, the standard recommends that all personnel performing processing of endoscopes should be certified in flexible endoscope processing within two years of employment and should maintain that certification throughout their employment.
There has been much debate about the sterilization of flexible endoscopes. To provide a higher level of assurance, evidence supports the sterilization of all flexible endoscopes, including those used in both semi-critical and critical procedures. Factors supporting this transition include high microbial load after patient procedure, the complex design of flexible endoscopes, and the risk for biofilm formation on these devices. Sterilization can reduce this risk because of the greater margin of safety in the overkill process, and it provides a sterile packaged endoscope. HLD is a multi-step process that is expected to inactivate most pathogenic bacteria, viruses and fungi; however, it may not reliably inactivate certain types of microorganisms, including bacterial spores. The ST91 standard committee recognizes that transitioning from HLD to sterilization as the standard of care will take time in terms of the endoscope and sterilizer manufacturers implementing necessary technological advances and for healthcare facilities to provide the budgetary and site accommodations to implement this change. The standard does not mandate sterilization but recommends healthcare facilities begin making the necessary steps toward sterilization for flexible endoscopes, when possible.
Water quality is important for flexible endoscope processing. For that reason, a new section has been added to ST91. To ensure that the correct water quality is used in each stage of processing, the manufacturers’ written instructions for use (IFU) for all equipment and supplies should be used. This includes endoscope and accessories, automatic endoscope reprocessors (AERs), and processing chemicals used. To ensure the correct water quality is being used, the healthcare facility should monitor and control the water supply to endoscope processing sinks and processing equipment.
Point-of-use treatment has been modified to include all aspects of point-of-use treatment, which now includes hand-off communication from point of use to the decontamination area (to include, at minimum, patient identifier, date of procedure, time point-of-use treatment was completed, and employee contact).
Significant revisions were made regarding leak testing, including having automated leak testers placed on a calibration schedule to verify the leak tester is producing the correct pressure. It is possible for leak testers to fail. Manual handheld leak testers and leak tester tubing should be inspected for damage, leakage, and pressure output. Pressure verification should be performed for each type of leak tester in the facility each day endoscopes are used; calibration ensures that an endoscope will be challenged with the proper pressure each time when being tested for leaks. Documentation of the leak testing results should be recorded.
Some AERs include mechanical leak testing, and the updated ST91 recommends that when using this type of AER, the endoscope and AER manufacturers’ written IFU must be followed (with the outcome of the leak test documented). Additional guidance was added for leak test failures, including labeling the endoscope to identify it as defective equipment, removing it from service, and following facility guidelines for repair. The failure should be reported according to the organizational policy and procedure, including the endoscope product identification and traceability information.
Cleaning is such an important part of the process, the cleaning section had numerous additions. The first change relates to the timing of the cleaning process after use. Delayed processing has been added.
The previous version of ST91 recommended keeping all reusable removable parts, such as the valves and caps, together for traceability. To minimize risk of transmission of infection, healthcare facilities can now use one of the following methods for these parts:
• use of single-use biopsy port caps and single-use valves
• sterilization of reusable valves and caps, preferably with steam sterilization when materials are compatible
• HLD of valves and caps (either keeping the valve/caps together with the endoscope as a set or tracking the individual valve/cap to the patient and the procedure).
Cleaning verification has been added to detect debris that cannot be seen without magnification. Cleaning verification used after endoscope cleaning and before disinfection or sterilization may detect residual organic soil and microbial contamination present on a surface, even if the device appears clean. The updated version recommends cleaning verification tests be performed after each use of high-risk endoscopes, notably duodenoscopes, linear ultrasound endoscopes, bronchoscopes, endobronchial ultrasound endoscopes, ureteroscopes, cystoscopes, and others as determined by the facility.
The use of borescopes is now recommended in the revised ST91. Inspection using a borescope allows for visualization of the internal working channels to identify unacceptable damage. It is important to check the endoscope manufacturer’s written IFU, maintenance bulletins, and other labeling for direction on what is considered a defective or damaged scope. The updated standard does not specify how often borescope inspection should occur and recommends that the frequency be determined by the facility. If a borescope is used as a quality monitor after disinfection/sterilization, the endoscope will need to be processed again before clinical use. As with all medical devices, the borescope should be processed in accordance with the manufacturer’s written IFU.
Recent research has led to many revisions to ST91’s drying recommendations after completion of the cleaning and disinfection process. Based on evidence, it is recommended that endoscope channels be dried for a minimum of 10 minutes with pressure-regulated forced instrument air (or, at minimum, HEPA-filtered air). If moisture is still observed, the drying time should be extended until no moisture is visible. The endoscope manufacturer’s written IFU should be reviewed for the maximum PSI. Note: Manual drying should occur, even if an AER is used, and it has an air purge or extended dry time feature.
Additional language was added to the ST91 section, “Terminal sterilization by gaseous chemical sterilization processes.” Sterilization of endoscopes is recommended because sterilized endoscopes provide an increased safety margin over HLD-processed endoscopes. Terminally sterilized endoscopes are completely dry and packaged, distinguishing them as patient-ready.
New recommendations were also added regarding the storage of liquid chemically sterilized endoscopes. Liquid chemical sterilization (LCS) of endoscopes intended for use as critical devices should not be stored with a claim as being patient-ready; instead, they should be used immediately after processing. They may also be used immediately in semi-critical applications. If endoscopes are processed using LCS but are not meant for immediate use, they can be stored in the same manner as those processed with HLD but must be processed again before use as a critical device.
Upon completion of the previous processes, the scopes, if not used, are placed into storage to protect them from damage and contamination. Two types of storage cabinets are being recommended for HLD- and LCS-processed endoscopes: drying cabinets, which are closed cabinets designed for storage of flexible endoscopes that circulate HEPA-filtered or instrument air through the cabinet and each endoscope channel at continuous positive pressure, and conventional cabinets, which are closed cabinets that circulate HEPA-filtered or instrument air through the cabinet at continuous positive pressure, but do not include forced air through endoscope channels. There is no clear consensus at this time among professional organizations regarding which type of cabinet is best; however, drying cabinets have been shown in scientific studies to reduce the risk of retained moisture and microbial contamination. Endoscopes hung in HEPA-filtered storage cabinets that do not have drying capabilities should be dried prior to storage.
The updated ST91 recommends that cabinets be located in a secure location, such as in the clean workroom and not within the endoscopy procedure room. Storage cabinets should have doors that are kept closed, and the cabinets should be located at least three feet from any sink to prevent endoscopes from becoming contaminated by water. It is further recommended that cabinets and endoscopes be visually inspected to ensure cleanliness when the endoscope is placed into the storage cabinet and also when the endoscope is removed for patient use. Storage cabinets should be cleaned following the manufacturer’s IFU, or at least weekly and when visibly soiled.
—Susan Klacik, BS, FCS, ACE, CHL, CIS, CRCST, AAMIF, is clinical educator at Healthcare Sterile Processing Association (HSPA) and its representative to the Association of the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI). Klacik has authored numerous articles and represents IAHCSMM for regulatory affairs dealing with sterilization and disinfection.