January 13, 2020

FCOTS increase through smarter scheduling and surgeon accountability

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN
Share

Starting the first cases of the day on time is key for maintaining the OR schedule. A delay in first case on-time starts (FCOTS) can lead to less OR utilization, greater facility costs, and dissatisfaction among physicians, OR staff, and patients. It’s a problem in many surgical suites, but when OR nurse leaders make FCOTS a priority, they can usually achieve some improvements.

Diane Fecteau, MSA, RN, CASC, NE-BC

Analyzing the causes for delays and holding physicians accountable are key ingredients for success, as demonstrated in a performance improvement initiative at Maine Medical Center Scarborough Surgery Center (SSC) in Scarborough, Maine. “Patients expect to have a procedure started in a reasonable time after their arrival,” executive director Diane Fecteau, MSA, RN, CASC, NE-BC, told OR Manager. “Delayed cases cause patient and family anxiety and further delay cases the rest of the day.”

In October 2018, FCOTS at SSC, a 10-room ambulatory surgery center, averaged only 50.2%. An Operational Excellence performance improvement project was developed to increase the percentage of FCOTS to 70% or greater.

 

Causes of first-case delays

“We had very dismal first case on-time starts for a long time,” says Fecteau. “We had looked at it as a group and kept coming up with the surgeon’s late arrival as the main cause, but there was only so much we could do at that point to address the surgeon problem.” About 8 months later, however, based on input from the surgeons, surgical services leadership decided to look at OR efficiencies and chose FCOTS as the place to begin. “That really gave us the leverage to address the issue from a surgical services perspective,” she says.

A multidisciplinary workgroup was formed, and they began collecting case delay data.

A root cause analysis of the causes for late first case starts found that 66% of the late starts were tied to:

• surgeon late arrival (42%)

• patient late arrival (16%)

• medication issues (8%).

“These findings gave us the traction to notify all of the surgeons that this was a priority and that we would be tracking their first case on-time starts,” says Fecteau.

 

Addressing causes of delays

Actions were taken to address the issues causing the delays, including:

• one-on-one conversations with late surgeons

• adjusting patient arrival times for specific patient populations

• calling first case patients the day before surgery to remind them of arrival time

• staffing an onsite pharmacist.

“We notified all of the surgeons that first case on-time starts were a priority and that we would be tracking and talking with surgeons who were late,” says Fecteau. “We also started calling the first case of the day patients the day before surgery to remind them of their arrival time, and posted reminders to surgeons on communication boards above the scrub sinks,” she says. “They have 3 minutes to scrub their hands and do nothing else but read the notices we post.”

Another change was to adjust patient arrival times. There had been a big drive to not have patients come to the surgery center any sooner than they had to, and a blanket arrival time of 1 hour before surgery had been instituted. This made it almost impossible for patients who had to have blocks infused to be ready on time.

Fecteau says they began to identify the patients who would need more time, such as children, elderly patients, eye patients who need a lot of drops preoperatively, and those having regional blocks. They adjusted those patients to arrive an hour and a half before their surgery start time.

There had also been a problem with antibiotic allergies in some patients, and they took advantage of another program to get an onsite pharmacist. “This helped us because before we were calling a pharmacist on the phone to talk to the patients, screen for antibiotic resistance, and determine if the patient had a true allergy,” she says. “Having a pharmacist onsite has made this much more efficient.”

 

Monthly calendar

Fecteau says they began to see some improvement in FCOTS, although challenges with patient arrival remained. “Some people are just late, and there is only so much you can do,” she says. “We tried to do the best we could in areas we had control over.”

Surgeons continued to be a problem, and the workgroup decided to start posting surgeons’ names when they were late on a big monthly calendar. Every day surgeons were late, their names were posted on the calendar (photo at right).

If surgeons were late a second time, their names were posted in bold, and if they were late a third time, their names were in caps, and for a fourth time, it would be all caps and underlined. “It became very apparent, very fast who the problem people were,” says Fecteau. If there was a day when all of the surgeons arrived on time, a congratulations or some other icon would be posted.

Fecteau noted that they began to have “a bit of a revolution” from surgeons who didn’t like that the calendar was calling them out and from surgeons who weren’t late but who didn’t think the calendar created a good environment.

Some staff were calling the calendar “The Doghouse,” so it was renamed the “Wall of Opportunity,” to point out that this was “our opportunity to get cases started on time,” she says.

 

Improvement up and down

FCOTS improved to 76% and 69% in May and June, 2019, respectively. Improvement waned over the summer, but it is now back up above the target of 70% at least 3 days of the week.

Part of the problem in the summer stemmed from the fact that there are three anesthesiologists overseeing the start of cases by certified registered nurse anesthetists (CRNAs) in 10 rooms. “This made it impossible for all 10 rooms to start at 7:30 am,” says Fecteau. “To fix this problem, we decided to stagger start times to 7:20, 7:30, and 7:40 am,” she says.

The anesthesiologists assign themselves to rooms based on the type of patient.

Even with staggered starts, it became clear that mastectomy patients with reconstruction had consistently late starts.

“We got a group together who were responsible for the care of these patients, including a general surgeon, a plastic surgeon, an anesthesiologist, a CRNA, OR staff, and preop staff, to map out everything that had to be done for these patients before going to the OR,” she says. “We were not only doing blocks on them, but they were high-need patients who would come in the day of surgery still with a lot of questions.” In the end, the group decided to change the start times of these patients to later in the morning.

Fecteau notes that this project has been a huge challenge for them because of so many professions involved. “In the beginning, anesthesia blamed nursing, nursing blamed surgeons, and surgeons blamed anesthesia. But there is less finger pointing now, and it is becoming more of a blame-free perspective that looks at the system’s issues,” she says.

For example, there are situations where surgeons are late on Thursday mornings because they are giving a conference at the main campus and then they have to travel 4 miles to the surgery center. “For these surgeons,” Fecteau says, “we have had to adjust their start times because it doesn’t make sense to hold them to a start time that can’t be met.”

 

Daily feedback

The surgery center receives a graph every day that shows what percentage of cases started on time. At 2 pm every afternoon, charge nurses from the OR and ambulatory surgical unit, along with anesthesia representatives, review the cases that ran late and started late and the reasons for delays.

Most weeks, FCOTS are 70% or better 3 out of 5 days, and there have been some weeks with a couple of days with 100% of first cases starting on time, she says.

Some of the chronically late surgeons also have been stepping up or attempting to step up to be at the surgery center on time. There are a couple who simply have no concept of time who have been moved to later times, she says.

None of this would have been possible without the fact that OR efficiency became a divisional priority, says Fecteau. “That gave us the leverage to really look at late starts fully because surgeons will always say they want to start on time but not enough to do whatever it takes for them to get there on time.”

At a recent advisory committee meeting, Fecteau says they talked about the success of the on-time starts project. One of the surgeons told the group: “I will tell you that seeing your name up there is powerful motivation. I haven’t had my name up there, but that is part of the reason for the success of the project.”

Besides posting names on the calendar, Fecteau says she and the surgery center’s chief of surgery send an email to each late surgeon that says: “You were late today. That impacts us, our ability to get your cases started on time, and patient satisfaction. We really appreciate you doing whatever you can to fix this. If we made a mistake, let us know.” ✥

 

Reference

Fecteau D, Reid S, Green S, et al. Project: Increasing first case on-time starts in an ambulatory surgery center. Poster. OR Manager Conference, 2019.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat