A perioperative staffing schedule that meets coverage needs during high- and low-volume times and satisfies the demand for better work-life balance can be difficult to achieve.
To help meet these challenges in its 50-room OR, the perioperative services department at Vanderbilt Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee, designed a perioperative float pool. The pool was created using full-time positions in time slots no one wanted, vacant positions, and an additional three full-time positions allotted for the float pool by administration.
Before creating the pool, OR leaders performed extensive data assessments of the number of staff, staff hours worked, staff preferences, block surgery times, block run over times, and overtime.
The float pool has allowed some staff to reduce their hours, and the department has reduced costly incentive overtime.
“Building a float pool isn’t easy,” says Cindy Kildgore, MSHA, RN, CNOR, Vanderbilt’s perioperative director. “We had to put a business plan together and stay budget-neutral, and we had to have the data to prove a float pool was actually necessary,” she says.
One of the main reasons a perioperative float pool was needed was that the hospital-wide float pool couldn’t keep enough nurses in it to match the waxing and waning of patient volume.
A perioperative float pool also was needed because:
• staff were tired, yet couldn’t take time off for better work-life balance
• some wanted to go to school, but there weren’t enough other staff to accommodate their school schedules
• some were tired of standing for 10 to 12 hours a day and wanted fewer hours.
“We had nothing to offer these people that would allow them to keep their benefits or that would incentivize a part-time position,” says Kildgore.
“We had to make our own definition of what a float pool would be for us in periop,” Kildgore says.
Criteria included:
• A flexible, nimble staffing pool: “We wanted a staffing pool that could be very flexible because we had what we called ‘the witching hour’ between 5 pm and 7 pm, during which nobody could leave,” says Kildgore. “We had late stay and overtime and other things we were using, but it wasn’t predictable, and the staff really didn’t like being what they called ‘captured.’”
• The ability to perform in multiple service lines, including specialties: “The pool staff had to be able to perform all service lines, except cardiac, although we have had a few who could circulate in cardiac,” notes Kildgore.
• Two years of experience: “We wanted them to have at least 2 years of OR experience so they would have a little maturity under their belts,” she says.
• Incentivized: “We wanted to incentivize the float pool positions, so we had to give them a bit more money than they would get by staying in their own service line,” she says.
To ensure success, Kildgore says they adopted the policies and processes of the hospital float pool and used its pay codes to incentivize the perioperative float pool.
Service line managers were tasked with assessing the needs of each service line, using the following guidelines and questions:
Retention. How many staff have left? Are exit interviews being done? Are staff leaving for more money? Are they leaving because they are not working the hours they want to work? Would they stay if work hours were different?
“For the most part, individual staff members have a set schedule that works for them, but every now and then someone wants to switch from 40 hours to 30 hours per week. This is where the float pool would give them the opportunity for that flexibility,” says Sonja Walsh, BSN, RNFA, CNOR, CSSM, manager of perioperative services.
Hours of operation. Are cases being done within their blocked hours? What is the plan for cases running past block time? Is it seasonal? Is it affecting staff satisfaction scores?
“We had to determine how many hours the surgeons were actually working, not just blocked hours, and how long cases were running outside the blocks and why they were running over,” says Walsh.
Overtime.What portion of overtime is used to cover cases running outside of the block? What service lines are impacted? What days of the week are impacted?
Walsh looked at how long the schedule was running over, the reasons for it, and if staff were being paid overtime to stay in a case. “We had to look at how those numbers affected our biweekly report and be able to speak to that and how a float pool would affect those numbers,” says Walsh. “We also had to identify specific days of the week when certain services would need more float people,” she says.
Staff satisfaction survey.Is retention linked to dissatisfaction with work-life balance? Is pay linked to retention?
“You have to look at your staff satisfaction surveys to understand why staff are dissatisfied or satisfied,” says Walsh.
Phase X is a methodology of assessing staffing to rooms running versus a set pattern of staffing to block scheduling.
“When we went to the management teams of the different service lines, we had to come up with a methodology, which we called ‘Phase X,’” says Kildgore. “X stands for the unknown factor,” she says, “and we had to determine what our unknown factors were to achieve our goals for the float pool and our budgeted dollars for staffing.”
The data assessment first looked at rooms running every day in the general, general oncology, urology, and robotics (GGUR) service line (11 to 12 ORs), and that was overlaid with block time (10 to 12 hours/day) and then staffing (2.25 full-time equivalent [FTE] room ratio), and then staffing was budgeted to the block.
This assessment was then repeated for the other service lines. “We overlaid this for each service line and then went to the managers and said: ‘Here is your data. These are the number of FTEs you have. Here is how you should be staffing,’” says Kildgore.
The GGUR ORs were targeted first because that service line has the largest number of rooms running on a daily basis.
Looking at the GGUR ORs for the hours they are run versus the block time that is scheduled, the analysis showed there were 9-, 10- and 12-hour shifts working Monday through Friday, and on each day it showed which rooms were running until 5:00/5:30 pm, 6:00/6:30 pm, and 7:00/7:30 pm.
“When I first saw the numbers, my reaction was, ‘that’s not true,’” says Walsh. “The analytics team ran through the numbers again with me and explained how they got there, and finally I saw the light,” she says.
Next, Walsh says, the analytics team showed the managers how to staff their rooms so nobody had to stay overtime in a room at the end of the day.
They broke it down by RN and surgical technician; by 8-, 9-, 10-, and 12-hour shifts; and by day of the week.
Walsh says her first question was, “How am I going to have 8-hour people work one shift on Thursday and two shifts on Friday and get their 40 hours?” In the end, she says, they decided to eliminate the 8-hour shifts.
Next they looked at the 9-, 10-, and 12-hour shifts to see what time staff were finishing cases, and they designed shifts to fit the hours the staff were actually working, such as 6:00 am to 6:00 pm. “We advertised those shifts, and they went like hot cakes,” Walsh notes.
“The information gathered with Phase X gave the managers the information they would need to create the float pool, including:
• knowledge of rooms running past block
• knowledge of FTEs needed for unplanned late coverage
• platform to discuss FTE coverage with managers
• thought process of FTE movement of late shift to the float pool.
One thing that was determined—based on Phase X and the overlay of staffing, different shift time offerings, and 10- and 12-hour shifts—was there were shifts nobody wanted, such as 9:00 am to 9:00 pm, says Rachael Poff, BSN, RN, CNOR, Vanderbilt’s operations manager.
“The data also showed that OR volume was seasonal, and that we had to figure out a way to ramp up during the high-volume time of year when we offer a lot of rooms until 9:00 pm,” she says. Only three rooms were supposed to be running after 7:00 pm for the trauma and surgery service.
The OR leaders determined that they had enough information to use Vanderbilt’s VandyWorks for their staffing template. VandyWorks is a software program that is used by all service lines to schedule their staff in 6-week blocks.
Poff says they entered parameters for when staff could and couldn’t request time off, how to swap schedules, and other maneuvers. Now they can just hit a button, and the program will tell them how many nurses are scheduled for each service line for each day.
“It tells us if we are running all 50 ORs, and if we don’t have staff for all 50, we can’t start rooms,” says Poff. “That’s when we bring in the float pool to fill in those gaps.”
Every day at 2 pm, Poff says the managers from the service lines have a huddle and run through the schedule and all of the needs for the next day.
Then the scheduling coordinator brings in the float pool list, and they start assigning float pool nurses to the staffing holes. Float pool nurses could work a 10-hour shift, a 9-hour shift, or a 6-hour shift, or cover for lunch breaks.
When the float pool was first proposed, the university added three full-time positions, which were all RNs. These three positions were broken down into whatever was needed.
To this was added the full-time positions that no one wanted, such as the 8-hour shifts and the 9 am to 9 pm shifts as well as vacant positions that hadn’t been filled.
“Once we broke it down, we came up with a guideline that said, ‘to be in our float pool, you have to guarantee us 24 hours in a 4-week period. It could be an 8-, 10-, or 12-hour shift,’” Poff says. “That’s how we started, and then people started signing up.”
In the beginning, full-time staff who no longer wanted to be full time moved to the float pool, but now there are actually full-time staff in the float pool because Vanderbilt has faced a big staffing challenge in the past year. With six hospitals within walking distance, everyone is very competitive, Poff says.
“We found that people we hired would not come to orientation because other hospitals had offered them more money, and we could not afford to keep losing those people,” says Poff.
Because the float pool could be anything we wanted it to be, we could offer people a full-time position in the float pool with a lot of flexibility,” she says.
For example, Poff notes that she also runs the command center, which hasn’t had a board runner for some time. The board runner position requires a very early start time. Because of the float pool, she was able to incentivize applicants to take the job and work the hours when they were needed.
Recently, Poff says, they took two of the night shift positions no one wanted to work, added them to the float pool, and turned them into 11 am to 11 pm positions.
The night shift had been staffed to run three ORs, but rarely are three emergency cases going on at the same time. They knew if they could keep the float pool staffed until 11 pm, they could get through the rest of the night with staff for two rooms.
One position has been filled, and three people have applied for the other position.
“They are ‘hog wild’ about signing up,” says Poff, “because they are getting more money, a set schedule, full-time benefits, and other incentives we’ve created.”
Poff notes that adding full-time positions has been eye opening. No one is going to the float pool just because they are paid more.
The float pool also has begun including first assistants and scrub technicians. “We can move in between disciplines however we want,” says Poff.
“Slowly but surely we have built up this float pool, and we have better predictability of when staff can go home, and we are seeing better staff satisfaction because they know they are going to get out on time,” says Kildgore. “Our big goals were to reduce overtime and to provide a better work-life balance for our staff. Those were the top two things that came out in a staff survey that staff were very unhappy about,” she says.
“We have really had people ‘beating down the door’ to come into the float pool, all for different reasons,” says Poff, “and we have the ability to adjust our expectations to meet reality.”
Poff says they work closely with the nursing and human resources recruiter. They meet weekly to discuss open positions and ways to transfer those positions into the float pool to acquire the help they need. They have added five positions to the original three pool positions, and are requesting two more in the next budget. ✥
Kildgore C L, Poff R, Walsh S. Building the case for a perioperative float pool. OR Business Management Conference. 2018.