January 14, 2019

Funds earmarked to enable nurse-led research

By: James X Stobinski, PhD, RN, CSSM (E), CNOR
Share

The United States is amid a conversion to a value-based system of healthcare. Although this new delivery model has contributed to the closure of some hospitals and the realignment of others into larger health systems, the primacy of the OR as a source of revenue for hospitals has remained constant. The OR is the economic engine of the hospital.

The growing importance of the revenue generated by the OR, combined with the disruptive change inherent in the transition to a value-based system of care, has markedly increased the performance pressure on perioperative nurse leaders.

The need for financial acumen in OR leadership is apparent and has contributed to the emergence of multidisciplinary teams that include business managers and supply chain management specialists.

As unsettling as these changes are for perioperative nurse leaders, they also present opportunities for those who can adapt to the changes.

As the chief executive officer of the Competency and Credentialing Institute (CCI), the organization that develops, maintains, and administers the accredited CNOR and CSSM (Certified Surgical Services Manager) credentials, I have insight into how perioperative nurse leaders can establish their value in a rapidly changing American healthcare system. I believe perioperative nursing can solidify its value, in part, through research activity. I also think that organizations such as CCI have a role in facilitating that research.

Although this will not be easy and there are some formidable obstacles, I believe perioperative nurse leaders have a rare opportunity to better understand and direct their profession during these challenging times.

In this article I speak to these obstacles and discuss how CCI is actively working to support perioperative nurse leaders who wish to pursue research opportunities.

The economics of surgical care and the role of perioperative nurse leaders in these processes and models is a research topic that has the potential to provide immediate, actionable results. Perioperative nurse leaders are increasingly tasked with quantifying the value of surgical care within the larger context of healthcare expenditures. Here is one example of how nurses might contribute in this area.

 

Research opportunities for perioperative nurses

In a 2017 article, Peter Nichol, MD, addressed the markups typically found in surgical supplies. As a pediatric laparoscopic surgeon, Dr Nichol asked pointed questions about the connection between quality of care and costs of care linked to choices in surgical supplies.

The entities providing payment for surgical care are raising questions about costs and altering payment methods, which cut into the margins long seen in surgical services. Facilities providing surgical care are being forced to increase efficiency and demonstrate value. Therefore, research on these topics is warranted.

In addition to economic considerations in the OR, perioperative nurse leaders must stay abreast of the evolving skills and knowledge needed to function effectively in this changing landscape. Routes to acquiring these skills and the results of their implementation in the OR are additional attractive research topics.

Patient outcomes research has almost limitless potential for application in the perioperative setting. The correlation of nursing education levels, certification status, and the variety of specialty training programs for nurses entering the profession are all factors that might affect patient outcomes, but these relationships have not been extensively studied.

Financial management skills are requisite for perioperative nurse leaders, but the intricacy of American healthcare presents an opportunity for more advanced skills in this area. It may not be possible to acquire certain complex skills with workplace training alone.

Financial analysis methods such as cost effectiveness analysis (CEA) and comparative effectiveness research (CER) could be applied to the types of questions posed by Dr Nichol regarding value and effectiveness, but additional education is needed for nurse leaders to conduct such analyses.

Longitudinal data gleaned from the annual OR Manager salary surveys indicate that graduate-level education is becoming commonplace for perioperative leaders. But performing complex analyses such as CEA and CER, working in multidisciplinary teams with physician colleagues, analyzing large data sets, and generating new knowledge all speak to the need for at least a small group of nurse researchers prepared at the doctoral level.

To better understand the current state of perioperative nursing research, CCI conducted a search of Internet-based resources. That search revealed a paucity of resources for perioperative-specific nursing research.

The search, performed by Carole Martell of the ShyParade marketing firm, revealed that research foundations often focus on diseases such as cancer and diabetes versus the practice of nursing specialties such as perioperative nursing.

A review of publications often read by perioperative nurses, such as OR Manager and the AORN Journal, reveals some original research done by non-nursing researchers. Nursing research is not the focus of either publication, but both contain some research by multidisciplinary teams that lack nurse researchers. Thus, it appears that there is ample opportunity for additional research and for greater participation from perioperative nurse researchers.

 

Limiting factors

If we agree that there is a place for research centered in the perioperative environment and that perioperative nurse leaders are well suited to do that work, we must answer the question: What limits perioperative nursing research?

I believe some of the limiting factors are ingrained in perioperative nursing practice. These factors are not insurmountable, but perioperative nurse leaders must make a concerted effort to address them.

 

Historical context

In Perioperative Nursing: An Introduction, Hamlin et al explain that perioperative nursing is among the oldest of the nursing specialties, with roots traceable to the 1890s. The practice of perioperative nursing, originally described as operating room nursing, has always been inextricably linked to advances in surgical technology.

The specialty of perioperative nursing was born of the increasing complexity of surgery and the need for assistants to the surgeon. From these origins, the profession has spanned the nexus between care rooted in psychomotor skills and the traditional role of nursing as a caring profession. As such, technical skills for the wide range of technology found in the setting are highly valued.

Hamlin and her co-authors stress that the perioperative nurse “…has an imperative to explore strategies not only for professional development through continuing education but also for practice development through engagement in research and evidence-based practice.”

It should be noted that these are Australian authors and that this call for research as a foundation for perioperative practice does not resonate as strongly among American perioperative nurses.

The value ascribed to technical proficiency, as opposed to academic achievement in areas such as research, is much stronger in American perioperative nursing practice. However, it is worthwhile to consider models espoused by other countries as American nurses proceed forward in the research arena.

The perioperative nursing role has traditionally centered on coordination of care among the multidisciplinary teams in this environment. This fact, combined with the holistic view of care espoused by perioperative nurses, would seem to make these nurses well suited to conduct research in this setting. However, a deficit of researchers prepared at the doctoral level makes it difficult for nursing to fully participate in research activities.

The inherent values of the profession in relation to academic achievement and the worth attributed to research activity are among the factors limiting perioperative nursing research in this country.

 

Perceived value of academic education

As a group, perioperative nurses in the United States have never achieved consensus on the value of additional education beyond that required for entry into practice. Despite the recommendations presented in the Institute of Medicine’s 2010 Report on the Future of Nursing, the necessity of baccalaureate-level education is still being debated in the perioperative nursing specialty.

This ongoing debate does not provide fertile ground for support for and completion of doctoral studies and research work. In a specialty that has historically valued hands-on skills and technical acumen acquired on the job, this is not surprising, but it may be time for us to question this approach.

Closely related to this debate regarding education level is the absence of perioperative nursing faculty in pre-licensure education programs. The scarcity of perioperative nurse faculty in nursing schools robs students of a perioperative nurse role model and exposure to the OR environment in graduate- and doctoral-level coursework.

Unlike countries such as England, Canada, and Australia, which have a well-established post-licensure education course, the United States does not have a standardized path for entry into perioperative nursing. This fact also points out the values of the profession regarding the necessity of post-licensure academic preparation.

 

Demographics and future of the profession

According to the 2018 OR Manager Salary Survey, the average age of perioperative nurse leaders is 52 years. Although possible, it is doubtful that nurses with many years in their profession who are now contemplating retirement options will begin doctoral studies to fill the need for researchers. Although 40% of survey respondents had graduate-level education, only six had doctoral preparation. The good news is that there will be an influx of nurses entering the profession because the demand for surgery will not abate soon.

In 2017, baccalaureate graduates comprised the largest group in terms of pre-licensure education to pass the NCLEX (National Council Licensure Examination) to enter nursing practice. This group, combined with the large numbers of RN to BSN graduates already in practice, is changing the makeup of the profession in terms of educational preparation.

Baccalaureate graduates are far more likely to progress to doctoral work, so we will have a larger pool of nurses who may go on to doctoral work to serve as nursing faculty and participate in nursing research.

 

A research infrastructure

One key factor that limits perioperative nursing research is the lack of basic infrastructure to support research work.

The infrastructure needed to conduct perioperative nursing research includes a core group of researchers familiar with the unique work of perioperative nursing and surgical care as well as a source of substantial and consistent funding for researchers.

The lack of a core group of established researchers makes success in a competitive grant writing process even less probable. In the larger field of nursing, the small group of current perioperative nurse researchers must compete in a much larger pool of established, successful researchers in the quest for funding and resources.

A sustained source of funding dedicated to perioperative nursing—which until recently has been lacking—and a system designed to develop perioperative researchers would be a meaningful step toward addressing these deficits.

 

Part of the solution

CCI has a proposal to address this key shortfall in the basic infrastructure. In the second quarter of 2018, CCI filed Articles of Incorporation in the State of Colorado for the CCI Research Foundation (CCIRF). This 501(c)(3) nonprofit corporation will be entirely funded by CCI and governed by an independent board of trustees consisting of four experienced perioperative nurse researchers and a public member.

The mission of this organization is: To fund research that contributes to the advancement of perioperative nursing science and the enhancement of perioperative patient care.

The foundational work structuring the organization is progressing steadily, and the 2019 budget has been funded. With this startup, some of the key factors limiting perioperative nursing research have now been addressed in terms of funding and a support structure for perioperative nurse researchers.

The website for CCIRF debuted in January, and research funding will be available in the third quarter of 2019 (http://cc-researchfoundation.org/). More details will be forthcoming as we progress into the new year, and anyone interested in this resource should keep an eye on the website.

As CCIRF matures, nurses aspiring to perioperative nursing research work will have a stable source of support. The priorities for funding from the CCIRF are listed in the sidebar below.

“ORs are like the economic engine room in a large, ocean-going vessel. If they fail to function optimally, the boat stops moving, and it is batted about by waves of economic disruption,” Dr Nichol wrote in 2017. To take Dr Nichol’s analogy one step further, perioperative nurse leaders are currently working in some rough seas as the American healthcare system transitions to a value-based system.

CCI and the CCI Research Foundation believe that the work of perioperative nursing research can have a positive impact in these unsettled times. We also believe that perioperative nurse researchers, once established, can help promote and establish the value of the perioperative nursing profession in improving American healthcare.

 

Favorable tides

I believe a quote from William Shakespeare’s “Julius Caesar” lends perspective to our current juncture regarding perioperative nursing research:

There is a tide in the affairs of men,

Which taken at the flood, leads on to fortune.

Omitted, all the voyage of their life is bound in shallows and in miseries.

On such a full sea are we now afloat.

And we must take the current when it serves, or lose our ventures.

The CCI Research Foundation believes that the tides favor our journey in this instance. Stay tuned; we believe there are some exciting times ahead, and we are proud to offer our help in this work. ✥

James X Stobinski, PhD, RN, CSSM (E), CNOR, is chief executive officer of the Competency and Credentialing Institute, Denver, which administers perioperative nursing certifications including the CNOR credential. He also serves as the CEO of the CCI Research Foundation. He maintains an active research agenda focused on nursing workforce issues.

Acknowledgment

Thanks to Carissa Homme, PhD, for her feedback and insights, which helped shape this article.

 

References

Hamlin L, Davies M, Richardson-Trench M, et al. Perioperative nursing: An introduction, 2nd ed. New South Wales, Australia: Elsevier Australia. 2016.

https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/william_shakespeare_395459

https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Quality-Initiatives-Patient-Assessment-Instruments/Value-Based-Programs/CMS-Quality-Strategy.html

Institute of Medicine. The future of nursing: Leading change, advancing health. 2010.

http://books.nap.edu/openbook.php?record_id=12956&page=R1.

National Council of State Boards of Nursing, Inc. 2017 NCLEX® Examination Statistics. Research brief. https://www.ncsbn.org/2017_NCLEXExamStats.pdf.

Nichol P. Do OR disposables have a future in value-based healthcare? Med Device. Published online August 14, 2017.  https://www.meddeviceonline.com/doc/do-or-disposables-have-a-future-in-value-based-healthcare-0001

Penner S J. Comparing costs and benefits. In Economic and Financial Management for Nurses and Nurse Leaders. New York: Springer Publishing Company, LLC. 2017; pp 217-242.

Saver C. (2018). OR leader job satisfaction high despite volatile industry. OR Manager. 2018;34(10):1, 7-11.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat