December 16, 2014

Getting all OR staff to buy into debriefing process boosts efficacy

By: OR Manager
Share

The main distinction between good and bad debriefings comes down to the level of staff engagement. That’s what the surgical team at the University of Colorado Hospital, Aurora, learned during a project designed to improve the quality of the 30- to 60-second conversations held after surgery.

“In a good debriefing, everyone is engaged. They don’t necessarily stop what they’re doing, but they can speak while the surgeon is closing. The surgeon, anesthesia provider, scrub person, and circulating nurse are all engaged. Everybody has a piece of it,” says Suzanne Sortman, MA, BSN, RN, CNOR, manager of the inpatient operating room at the hospital.

The team had hit a stumbling block because people were having difficulty speaking up about what they thought went well or what didn’t, according to Katherine Halverson-Carpenter, MBA, RN, CNOR, patient care services director for obstetrics and perioperative services. “We were very good at validating counts and specimens, but we weren’t doing as well with the qualitative concerns.”

They set out to improve the debriefing process in 2012. But the team’s journey toward optimal perioperative communication actually began a few years earlier.

 

Briefing and debriefing

The debriefing, which is held after every surgical procedure, is designed to facilitate appropriate handoff of care, verify pathology reports, ensure that specimens are labeled correctly, and—ideally—give everyone a chance to identify opportunities to improve patient care.

“It’s good for process improvement to get instant feedback. Otherwise, you won’t remember,” says Paul Maroni, MD, associate professor of surgery at the hospital and one of four physician champions of the project to improve the debriefing process.

In early 2008, the hospital conducted a pilot program implementing both briefings and debriefings in the cardiothoracic surgery department. Denver-based Safer Healthcare (www.saferhealthcare.com) was hired to conduct a 4-hour training for all staff members. That training included a Situation Background Assessment Recommendation, a standardized way of communicating aimed at improving patient safety, as well as briefing and debriefing checklists. Over the following 9 months, the hospital expanded the communication training to all surgical departments.

In October 2010, the World Health Organization (WHO) launched its Surgical Safety Checklist (http://whqlibdoc.who.int/publications/2009/9789241598590_eng_Checklist.pdf?ua=1), which included questions to be asked and standard steps to be taken before the induction of anesthesia, before skin incision, and before the patient leaves the operating room. In line with the WHO’s recommendations, the University of Colorado Hospital staff revised the checklist to fit the facility’s specific needs.

Briefings last about 60 seconds before each procedure and include elements such as confirmation of the patient’s identity, surgical side, and site; information about the operating plan and any backup plans; introductions of staff members and discussions of any particular concerns about the patient; and verification that all necessary equipment is available.

Debriefings include standard questions to be addressed following all surgical procedures (except obstetrics, which has a different list):

  • Are the sponge, sharp, and instrument counts complete?
  • Has the name of the operative procedure been verified?
  • Are the specimens labeled and verified?
  • Did you identify what went well/what did not, and reformulate a response plan?
  • Did you identify key concerns for recovery and management of this patient?

The form also includes a checklist for patient handoff and follow-up.

In April 2011, the hospital used grant money from the Cardinal Health Foundation (www.cardinal.com) to bring back Safer Healthcare, this time as outside consultants to observe and evaluate the quality of their briefings and debriefings.

The verdict: The briefings were going well, but there were problems with the debriefings. “We adopted the briefing aspect more quickly than we did the debriefing. We needed to make the debriefings more robust,” Sortman says.

Using proprietary tools, Safer Healthcare evaluated engagement of the anesthesiologist, nursing staff, and surgeon, and the quality of their communication. Deficiencies were seen in terms of discussing what had gone well or not well and following up with any problems.

“The surgeon would say he didn’t have a particular instrument or that an antibiotic wasn’t given on time, but no one ever followed up with what didn’t go well. That was part of our [subsequent] training,” Halverson-Carpenter notes.

One problem, she says, is that the briefings and debriefings had been entirely nurse-driven. “Part of the gap, we realized, is we didn’t have surgeon champions to initiate [the briefings and debriefings.] We needed the physician to flatten the playing field and give the staff permission to speak up if they saw something wrong.”

In 2012, the department applied for and received a second Cardinal Health Foundation grant, which was used to bring back the Safer Healthcare consultant team to help improve the debriefing process.

 

Beefing up the debrief

Although some organizations have mandated that the surgeons lead the debriefing process, the Colorado hospital team decided not to do that. “We didn’t make it mandatory because people tend to push back when you say they have to do something. This has been a very grassroots approach. The surgeons agreed to modify the debriefing to better meet the needs of their patient population and to increase the quality of the communication,” Halverson-Carpenter says.

Some of the surgeons were initially reluctant, but a few instances of mislabeled specimens and wrong implants convinced them the extra effort was worthwhile.

“We tried to communicate early on what’s in it for the surgeons. We have made them believers. Some of the surgeons who pooh-poohed it through the whole 4-hour training session have become our strongest advocates. I think it’s really important to capture the ‘good catches’ and communicate the good catches, then staff will buy into it,” Halverson-Carpenter says.

“Ultimately,” she says, “they became very invested in this as a patient safety technique. No one wants to do the wrong thing.”

One of the most effective improvement tools was a series of videos demonstrating “good” and “bad” debriefings, with Dr Maroni “starring” as the surgeon and other staff members playing their own roles. In a bad debriefing, people kept talking and didn’t focus on the task at hand, or they covered only one or two of the components in the surgical procedure. In a good debriefing, everyone was focused.

“That was one way to have some fun with the educational piece and help the team reach the next level,” Sortman says.

“It’s a time management and judgment call. If it’s a routine closure and you’re getting close to the end and applying dressings, there’s time to discuss how the case went,” Sortman explains.

One helpful tool for the debriefing is a preference card for each type of procedure that lists all of the necessary equipment and can be modified as needed. Using preference cards can help avoid situations where a needed instrument is discovered missing after the procedure has already started, Dr Maroni says.

It can take 5 to 10 minutes to retrieve a missing tool, which is a substantial amount of time lost in a 20- to 30-minute procedure, Dr Maroni notes.

When things like that happen, they are addressed in the debriefing. “We check our recipe card and make sure the tool is there. Those are things we talk about,” Dr Maroni explains.

Monthly chart audits are another key to achieving and maintaining success, Sortman says. “Our documentation keeps us on the straight and narrow.”

 

Measuring success

At Safer Healthcare’s follow-up 4 to 6 months later, 98% of the focus group surgical teams had participated in the trainings and included all of the required elements in their briefings, compared with just 60% of other teams from the hospital that did not participate in the trainings. Debriefing scores for the participating teams were 63% favorable, compared with just 30% favorable for the control group (nonparticipating) teams.

The reviewers determined that physician engagement and leadership were subjectively improved in the participating teams and played a key role in the superior results.

It took persistence, Sortman says. “It certainly didn’t happen overnight. It took us a good year.”

And revisions continue. In answer to the debriefing question, “Are the specimens labeled and verified?” chart audits revealed that the “no” box was being checked frequently. Through staff discussions identifying barriers to successful debriefings, staff members acknowledged that they were checking that box when there actually wasn’t any specimen. The problem was, there was no option for that situation. To resolve this, they added a “not applicable (NA)” box to the script.

“It’s an ongoing education related to the briefing and debriefing,” Sortman says.

Halverson considers the hospital’s entire communication initiative a success. “It has improved teamwork between the surgeon and the anesthesia and nursing staff. It has improved provider satisfaction in their perception of quality and teamwork in the OR,” she says.

“Having a stable OR team that meshes well together makes for efficiency in the OR,” Dr Maroni notes. “Everyone wants to feel they’re doing something important for the patient. I think the debriefing is a good way to make sure we’re acknowledging the needs of everyone who’s in there.” ❖

 

Miriam E. Tucker is a medical journalist in Bethesda, Maryland.

 

Reference

Babu N, Sandoval M F, Halverson-Carpenter K A. Improving teamwork and patient safety through the redesign of the surgical debrief. Poster session, 2014 AORN Conference & Expo.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat