November 1, 2008

Getting ready for ASC quality reporting

By: OR Manager
PDF
Share

Ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) are preparing to join hospitals, physicians, and other health care providers in reporting quality data to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS).

Though it’s unlikely ASC quality reporting will be required in 2009, ASCs need to start preparing, according to David Shapiro, MD. He is a principal at the consulting firm Ambulatory Surgery Company, Tallahassee, Florida, and with Kim Wood, MD, co-chaired the ASC Quality Collaboration, a multi-disciplinary group formed in 2006 to develop a set of quality measures for surgery centers.

In that year, Congress ordered the Department of Health and Human Services to add outpatient care to its requirements for quality reporting. The penalty for not submitting data would be to forfeit 2% of any annual reimbursement increase, according to provisions in the Tax Relief and Health Care Act of 2006.

Though CMS is expected to postpone ASC quality reporting for 2009, Dr Shapiro advised ASCs to begin gearing up.

Working together

The collaboration included ASC associations and management companies, health care professionals, and accrediting organizations such as the Joint Commission. After the group agreed on a set of 10 quality measures, it submitted them to the National Quality Forum (NQF), a voluntary standards organization. The NQF board approved 5 of those measures.

“It was a very long process,” Dr Shapiro recalled. “It wasn’t easy, it wasn’t straightforward, and it didn’t happen overnight.”

One problem, which emerged when the group attempted to list and compare current ASC quality measures, was the lack of common terminology. “As for standard definitions, there were none,” he said. “People were collecting data concerning similar things, but nobody was talking about them in a common language.”

An example was the standard for patient transfer to a hospital. The time frame and the meaning of the term differed among different organizations.

The group first developed criteria that would apply to any quality measure they might consider. First, it would have to be within the scope of an ASC’s care or influence.

“They found some measures that were used in hospitals but were not applicable to ASCs because we have different types of patients in a different clinical environment,” Dr Shapiro recalled.

Second, ASC staff must be able to observe directly and verify the behavior to be assessed. Third, the measure must be understandable and important to all stakeholders, such as patients and insurers. “They were looking for data that is valid but also understandable.”

The final 5

At the end of the process, the NQF agreed to adopt the proposed standards for 5 treatment or procedural areas (sidebar).

The measures relate either to outcome or process. An outcome measure refers to what happens to a patient as the result of treatment. A process measure evaluates a particular aspect of the care. Of the 5, only the antibiotic timing measure is process; the others are outcome measures.

To quantify results, measures are expressed as a fraction, where the numerator is all patients receiving a particular process or having that outcome, and the denominator is the group of patients being evaluated.

In an implementation guide for members, the ASC Quality Collaboration gives the following instruction for computing the result: “To report each measure, count the number of patients meeting the numerator criteria and the number of patients meeting the denominator criteria. To calculate your results as a percentage, divide the numerator by the denominator and multiply by 100. Although the frequency with which these assessments are performed can certainly vary, we suggest you collect the data on a monthly basis.”

As an example, a measure for patient falls per 1,000 patient days would have as a numerator every admission to the ASC in which the patient fell “within the ASC.” A fall in the parking lot or elsewhere outside of the building would not be included.

The NQF’s decision to include this measure was based on the fact that falls associated with outpatient surgery are on the increase. “We ask patients to get up and dressed much sooner than in the old days,” Dr Shapiro noted.

The definition is specific: “a sudden, uncontrolled, unintentional downward displacement of the body.”

The transfer/admission measure tracks patients who, after leaving the ASC, are admitted to a hospital for inpatient care. A high number of admissions may indicate inappropriate patient selection or choice of procedure for those patients.

Reporting made simple?

There are 3 potential sources of data, but only 1 is preferred, Dr Shapiro said. The first, abstraction of clinical data, is a time consuming pencil and paper method, especially for smaller ASCs with limited staff. The second, using electronic medical records, would be better, but the adoption rate is still too low for this to be a realistic option now for most ASCs. The third, augmented claims submission, is likely to be the most feasible, Dr Shapiro said. With this method, ASCs would add supplemental tracking codes to each Medicare claim. These “Category II Codes” would refer to specific quality measures such as treatment given and test results.

Consolidation and reporting would be simple, reducing the need for chart review and production of record abstracts.

CMS originally planned to start requiring ASC quality reporting in 2008 and then in 2009. But in July, in the proposed 2009 Medicare outpatient and ASC payment rule, CMS said it would postpone issuing a rule on quality reporting. The final payment rule was expected by Nov 1.

Though Shapiro believes it is no longer likely that CMS will require ASC quality reporting in 2009, he said it is not too early to consider how to collect and organize quality data.

More information on the ASC Quality Collaboration is at www.ascquality.org.

Reference

ASC Quality Collaboration. ASC Quality Measures: Implementation Guide, Version 1.0. April 2008:3. www.ascquality.org.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat