May 12, 2020

Hospital-wide ERAS adoption hinges on leadership support

Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) is arguably the greatest advancement in surgery in the last 20 years. But even healthcare leaders who support the use of ERAS to achieve better outcomes can find it daunting to implement the protocols throughout their hospital systems.

Standardizing practices across areas that have historically functioned as silos can raise concerns about whether the evidence supports these changes, whether changes are locally and institutionally supported, and whether changes may make it harder to meet other performance expectations.

At Virginia Commonwealth University Health System (VCU Health) in Richmond, starting with a focused implementation in one surgical subspecialty (colorectal surgery) led by a well-supported champion and then presenting the improved outcomes data to other specialties allowed us to demonstrate the real-world impact ERAS can have on patient outcomes. We were able to address concerns and overcome resistance to achieve lasting change. (Details of how ERAS was implemented and the improved outcomes that resulted are described in “Providing cost-benefit analysis for ERAS-related solutions,” OR Manager, January 2020, 26-27.)

 

Expect resistance and plan ahead

Difficulties with ERAS implementation have been described in the literature. Some of the main barriers include:

• time constraints

• opposition from colleagues

• logistical reasons such as composing/distributing memos and devising care maps

• the need to provide continuous training

• the additional work required to implement ERAS

• lack of leadership and administrative support

• resistance from providers, resistance to change in general, and even resistance from administrators.2, 3

Despite general agreement with the clinical principles of ERAS, we have encountered pockets of resistance in the form of both active resisters—those who voice opposition—and passive resisters—those who fail to change by not engaging in the design or participating in the implementation of protocols. It is important to understand the emotional and personal factors that contribute to resistance and prepare accordingly. At VCU Health, a key strategy to overcoming resistance has been to ensure a variety of providers and clinicians are provided the opportunity to participate in designing the change.

 

Know your key senders and understand your receivers

There are many factors that influence what the receiver of a message hears. According to Prosci, a leading provider of change management publications and training, the most important senders are the senior leaders and direct supervisors.1 Senior leaders bear the responsibility of communicating why ERAS is important, the risk of not implementing it, and how ERAS aligns with the vision and direction of the organization.

As with any complex, multidisciplinary healthcare model, success is dependent upon a comprehensive, evidence-based strategy that aligns with the organization’s mission, vision, and strategic goals. Stated strategic goals solidify the vision of the organization, allowing and supporting a common message to the team members, providers, leaders, and board members.

Direct supervisors are best at addressing how ERAS impacts the individual and the team, the effect on daily work, and how individuals will benefit. Key messages here include how a well-implemented ERAS program improves team efficiency, fosters a better work environment, reduces OR cancellations and delays, and reduces the amount of caregiving time and labor needed for each patient.

By providing communications using standard formats and channels at regular intervals, we have better engaged team members in the change. Examples include a weekly one-page update sent via email with a printable attachment, regular presentations at grand rounds, and cascading message kits.

 

Establish sponsorship that is active and visible

In healthcare systems with an increased focus on value, many strategic priorities fall within the organization’s quality improvement structure. For VCU Health, it is a strategic priority to improve performance in our ranking compared to other academic medical centers. To effect this, organizational improvement in areas related to mortality, hospital-acquired complications, and length of stay—all outcomes that are positively impacted through ERAS—are required. As a result, our quality and safety officer is seen as a natural ERAS program sponsor.

Characteristics of a successful governing structure include:

• combined executive, provider, and clinical sponsorship

• ability to remove barriers

• ability to secure funding

• visible sustained support for implementation of the program.

ERAS governance at VCU Health started with forming a focused ERAS steering committee consisting of key leaders in surgery, anesthesia, nursing, allied health, quality and safety, and operations. The steering committee, co-chaired by the quality and safety officer and the VP of perioperative services, is supported by a combination of ERAS program champion teams and reinforced by the operational structure for clinical governance (sidebar below).

The ERAS Nursing Committee and ERAS Provider Champions Team consist of committed champions representing anesthesia, surgery, nursing, pharmacy, and allied health professionals who are influential leaders among their peers and well respected in their field.

These individuals, who exhibit strong listening and collaboration skills, may be in the early stages of their careers and, therefore, years of experience should not be the primary deciding factor when selecting champions.

These influencers are a key ingredient to ERAS implementation success and must be actively supported by the program sponsor, the steering committee, and management.

To ensure that recommendations and decisions made within the program governance model would have broader support across the entire perioperative arena, changes were brought first to the Quality, Safety and Regulatory (QSR) Committee for acceptance and implementation guidance and then formally ratified via the Perioperative Executive Committee (PEC). (Details of the function of these operational governance bodies were shared in “Establishing quality standards for ERAS care elements,” OR Manager, December 2019, 13-16.)

Together, these oversight teams signify the unified, committed sponsorship of ERAS that is necessary for sustained success.

Increasingly, there is pressure for hospital systems to reduce their focus on costs and expand efforts to improve quality. Previous articles in this series have addressed this concept, but it is worth repeating that Medicare payments are shifting away from volume toward value (quality outcomes). Although other payers may lag behind Medicare in adopting value-based care, there is little reason to expect the fee-for-service model will last for much longer.4 Strategies that can achieve the aims of excellent clinical care—fewer complications and reduced costs—are key to the value system of healthcare provider organizations.

Comprehensive implementation of an ERAS program can help achieve these aims in the surgical population. ERAS was founded on the principle of producing a predictable quality outcome by reducing morbidity and shortening hospital stay. This is accomplished by incorporating optimized multimodal perioperative care in a variety of different surgical specialties, which leads to reduced cost of care.

 

Incremental vs radical change

There are 24 core elements of ERAS underlying these components. No single element by itself will improve outcomes of surgery—the goal must be to implement all 24 elements. (Many of these elements are described in “Enhanced Recovery After Surgery: The new standard for perioperative care,” OR Manager, October 2019, 1, 14-17.)

At VCU Health, our approach has been to implement these elements across surgical specialties as standard work. We have introduced variation by specialty only where that has been clinically indicated. This approach requires the engagement of every surgeon, anesthesiologist, and nurse who works in perioperative services, the outpatient clinics, and the inpatient units where surgery patients recover.

It is challenging to introduce simultaneously a large number of new interventions among providers of differing specialties and across multiple geographic areas of the hospital. Even implementing 24 core elements one specialty at a time can be complex. When determining your approach, consider the degree of difference between your current and future state, how much disruption the transition will cause, and the resources you have to support the change.

 

Use meaningful data to engage stakeholders

High accountability and resiliency are characteristics needed to move large projects through change even if the change is one that is readily accepted or “is the right thing to do.” The best way to engage medical professionals in change is through the use of meaningful data. (Examples of such data were given in “Establishing and leveraging data analytics for ERAS,” OR Manager, April 2020, 22-23.)

Measures of comparison must be utilized as “vital signs” to help healthcare leaders understand recent performance and where improvement is needed. In addition, the data must be valid and transparent as possible to ensure the team(s) have confidence in the protocols.

By aligning these system goals with the professional ethics of providers, we shift the focus from improving comparative measures toward improving patient outcomes. Identification, planning, and implementation of a systemwide ERAS program is a journey encompassing passion, strategy, leadership, governance, and data. Leaders and stakeholders need the determination, resiliency, and patience to guide and sustain process changes. ✥

References

1. https://www.prosci.com/resources/articles/seven-change-concepts.

 

2. Martin D, Roulin D, Grass F, et al. A multicentre qualitative study assessing implementation of an Enhanced Recovery After Surgery program. Clin Nutr. 2018;37:2172-2177.

 

3. Pearsall E A, Meghji Z, Pitzul K B, et al. A qualitative study to understand the barriers and enablers in implementing an Enhanced Recovery After Surgery program. Ann Surg. 2014;261(1):92-96.

 

4. Burwell S M. Setting value-based payment goals—HHS efforts to improve US health care. N Engl J Med. 2018;372(10):897-899.

 

Resources

Bond-Smith G, Belgaumkar A P, Davidson B R, et al. Enhanced recovery protocols for major upper gastrointestinal, liver and pancreatic surgery. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016;2:Cd011382.

 

Cerantola Y, Valerio M, Persson B, et al. Guidelines for perioperative care after radical cystectomy for bladder cancer: Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS(®) society recommendations. Clin Nutr. 2013;32(6):879-887.

 

Greco M, Capretti G, Beretta L, et al. Enhanced recovery program in colorectal surgery: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. World J Surg. 2014;38(6):1531e41.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat