January 1, 2007

Improving the OR’s medication safety

By: OR Manager
PDF
Share

Unlabeled medications on the sterile field are a known patient safety hazard. In 2006, the Joint Commission on the Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations issued a requirement under the National Patient Safety Goals mandating labeling of all medications, medication containers, and other solutions on and off the sterile field. Research at New York-Presbyterian Hospital/Weill Cornell has found, however, that labeling is not the only source of potential medication safety issues on the sterile field.

“As we looked into this, we realized this was a bigger issue than just proper labeling of medications—it was also about all of the processes needed to get the medications to the sterile field,” says Anthony Dawson, RN, MSN, a Six Sigma Master Black Belt for clinical quality and patient safety.

Dawson and other leaders organized a proactive risk assessment of the entire intraoperative medication use system for the 38 operating rooms at the Cornell site. The project was divided into 2 parts to look at:

  • sterile field medications administered during surgery
  • the process for getting medications into the hands of the surgeons.

The project team included, in addition to Dawson, the hospital’s chief quality officer, the vice president of pharmacy services, 2 patient safety nurses, and a research pharmacist who directed the project’s day-to-day operations. The team worked closely with the staff from perioperative services. The surgical and anesthesiology faculty were consulted as needed.

Sterile field medications

Simplification and standardization were the safety tools employed in this project. This required review and collection of data normally not analyzed in the OR. Six months of data documenting medications given to patients from the sterile field were analyzed to assess usage patterns among surgeons and to identify possible areas for standardization. Medications were classified into 9 categories for analysis.

Two specific medication groups were selected for initial evaluation:

  • use of injectable local anesthetics
  • use of antibiotic irrigations.

For local anesthetics, the data revealed 17 different products in various concentrations and combinations in use, notes Michael Orsini, RPh, the project’s research pharmacist. Of these, 5 accounted for 93% of all local anesthetic use.

The medication use data were instrumental in getting buy-in from the physicians, Dawson notes. Some surgeons, for example, didn’t realize they were using 17 different local anesthetics.

“When we first told them, they didn’t believe us,” says Dawson. “We presented the data and explained that when you have 17 types of drugs, there is more opportunity for error than if you reduce that to 4 or 5.”

A multidisciplinary task force of surgeons, anesthesiologists, and nurses was formed to work on standardizing medications like the local anesthetics and eliminating mixing on the sterile field as much as possible. Through this group, the list of available local anesthetics was reduced from 17 to 6.

Antibiotic irrigation solutions were also examined.

“There is controversy in the literature about whether these work or are even needed,” stated Orsini. “In our data, we found 3 antibiotics were primarily used but in no standard concentrations.” Though the task force could not get consensus to eliminate antibiotic irrigations, use has been reduced by 16% and standardized to one antibiotic and one concentration.

Sterile field medication use process

Because there was no published information on the sterile-field medication-use process, systematic review and analysis was done. First, a survey was conducted to gather baseline process data about how medications were ordered. Data was collected to determine the average number of sterile field medications and sterile field mixtures per case. The investigators also wanted to see what percent of medication orders were written or verbal, or whether medication orders were based on information on the surgical preference cards. Other information sought included how many dosing calculations were required, how many were double checked, and whether medications were brought into the OR and not used.

Key findings showed 24% of medication orders at the start of a surgical case were verbal orders, translating into approximately 24,000 orders annually.

“Verbal orders are a documented source of medication errors,” Dawson notes.

There was also heavy reliance on preference cards for supplying medications. A subanalysis was conducted of 400 preference cards with 2 or more medications listed randomly selected from the perioperative database to determine the error potential of the information on the cards.

Results showed there were no standard ways to display a medication name. In some instances, brand names were used and in others, generic names. On average, there were 9 abbreviations per card related to medications. Some were later included on the hospital’s “Do Not Use Abbreviations” list.

Finally, it was found that the cards were not updated on a regular schedule, with most going over a year between updates.

Once baseline data collection and analysis were completed, sterile field medication use was more rigorously evaluated.

“We were able to show there were parts of the process that could be improved through our initial data survey,” said Orsini. “Next we wanted to see what was causing some of the things we were finding.”

Learning more about the process

To learn more about the medication use process in the OR, 3 focus group meetings were conducted with perioperative nurses, surgical technologists, and operating room pharmacists. Focusing on the 5 steps in the process—prescribing, dispensing, preparing, labeling, and administering—focus group members were asked, “What would you like to see more of, and what would you like to see less of?”

For prescribing, focus group members wanted to see more written orders and less use of verbal orders and preference cards.

Variations in dispensing practices in the OR were also identified. It was found that 11 areas outside the normal distribution channels were sometimes used to procure medications for a surgical case. Some of these were anesthesia providers, the surgeon, blood bank, medications kept in supply at the front desk, or medications left over from a previous case.

Conducting an FMEA

Based on the focus group information and survey data, the project team decided to conduct a failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) of the entire sterile field medication process. Over 11 weeks, an interdisciplinary team of OR nurses and pharmacists mapped out the process in great detail and identified reasons (failure modes) for deviations from standard practice. Surgeons were kept abreast of the proceedings and their input sought as needed.

The FMEA identified a complex process of up to 247 steps to get a medication to the sterile field and 131 potential failure modes. This was by far the most in-depth analysis of any medication use process conducted. The 247 steps represented the total of all the different pathways combined that could be taken. In general, depending on the path, 20 to 30 steps were required.

“The failure modes were not necessarily just in the medication use process,” Dawson says.

“Distractions were a big thing—trying to get medications ready during a case and having to answer the telephone or deal with other distractions, such as setting up equipment, looking for supplies, or even orienting new staff.”

Some of the failure modes were specific to a step in the process; for example, using an abbreviation when writing an order. Others occurred throughout the process; for example, the types of distractions mentioned above.

When the dispensing process was reviewed, reasons were identified that could be addressed to prevent use of medication sources outside the control of the pharmacy. An example was the location of the automated dispensing cabinets related to some of the operating rooms.

Lowering the risk of medication errors

The goal of this project had always been to make a safe system safer. Based on the data collected a number of process changes were proposed:

  • Medication terminology and abbreviations used on preference cards are being standardized. The “Do Not Use Abbreviations” list is being enforced.
  • All the data collected was shared with all the stakeholders in the operating room areas to reinforce the requested medication standardizations and to make surgeons, nurses, and technologists more aware of the potential for errors.
  • An online error reporting system was set up so staff can enter an anonymous report that is automatically routed to a manager. The manager reviews the reports and forwards them to the quality department for tracking.
  • Some medications are ordered premixed from the manufacturer so less mixing on the field is required.
  • Obtaining a larger automated supply station with space for more medications provided better control over access and tracking.
  • The clinical pharmacy became more involved in medication selections and standardization.
  • Nurses and physicians were educated on the importance of getting medications for cases from approved sources, like the pharmacy.

“We have tried to create a blame-free culture where people can report near misses. Then we can look at the systems and processes to see if fixes are needed,” says Dawson.

Orsini adds, “Medication use on the sterile field is a multistep process that is tightly coupled to other activities happening in the OR. Yet it is independent of other steps in the medication process.

“What would seem like a simple process—getting a medication onto the sterile field for administration to the patient—is in fact, fairly complex. Reduce the complexity, and you reduce the potential for error.”

Tools for improving med safety

Don’t reinvent the wheel. Take advantage of tools like these:

Sample FMEA

Sample failure mode, effect, and criticality analysis from the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations.

—www.jointcommission.org.

Look under Patient Safety, then Failure Mode, Effect, Criticality Analysis Resources.

Focus groups

Help for organizing focus groups.

—www.isixsigma.co. Enter search term “focus groups.”

Flowchart software

SmartDraw is one example.

—www.smartdraw.com

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat