Is there really a nursing shortage?
“Is this a question or a statement?” asks Ruth P. Shumaker, BSN, RN, CNOR, executive director perioperative services, Regional One Health, Germantown, Tennessee.
“It’s a little bit of both,” she answers. “Some of it has been self-made, and some of it is because we are living through some very difficult times.”
The nursing shortage in the US has been here for years, says Shumaker, adding that the American Nurses Association (ANA) says more RN jobs will be available through 2022 than any other profession in the US.
This is good news and bad news, she says. “The bad news is there are a lot of openings; the good news is that, for the younger generation, this is the perfect time to become a nurse.”
The increase in the number of new nurses entering the workforce coupled with the retirement of thousands of experienced nurses is leading to a more novice workforce and a workforce that did not learn the OR in nursing school, so they have a steep learning curve, she says.
“On top of that, the last couple of years maneuvering through the COVID-19 pandemic have been the most difficult since AIDS entered healthcare,” says Shumaker. “This time, we shut down our ORs when they told us to; then we opened them up; then we shut them down again; and then we opened them up again. The stress of COVID-19 caused many nurses to burnout.”
Baby boomers retiring. Currently, the US has the highest number of people over the age of 65 than at any other time in its history, says Shumaker. In 2029, the last of the baby-boomer generation will reach retirement age, resulting in a 73% increase in Americans 65 years of age and older. There are approximately 1 million RNs older than 50 years of age, and one-third of the workforce could be at retirement age in the next 10 to 15 years, she says.
Nursing salaries. “Valuing nurses and paying them their worth, asks a fundamental question,” says Shumaker. “In an occupation facing dangerous levels of shortages, why don’t wages rise to attract more new nurses and prevent current workers from leaving?
Shumaker says she has recently put strategies in place, such as retention bonuses and recruitment bonuses for nurses and surgical technologists who do not leave.
Pandemic. The global COVID-19 pandemic has made things worse for nurses, by adding stress and a mass influx of patients, says Shumaker. It is likely too early to get a clear picture of the long-term impact on nursing employment, but there are certainly indications it has not helped. Nurses are reeling from the burden of caregiving, and a lot of nurses decided they wanted to leave.
Regional differences. Shortages can vary greatly depending on the region of the country. Larger areas tend to suffer more from nursing shortages because of the population density of major metropolitan areas. Simply put, says Shumaker, there are not enough nurses to manage the volume of people who need medical care within most large cities.
Educational obstacles. Students appear to have a high level of interest in nursing careers, but they encounter a gauntlet of obstacles. One of the major factors in nursing education is low faculty numbers. “There are just not enough teachers to educate the nursing students,” she says.
Burnout. Currently, the national average of nurse turnover is 8.8% to 37%, depending on the geographical location and nursing specialty, according to a 2022 study by Haddad et al. In 2017, a survey by Kronos found that 63% of hospital nurses reported experiencing burnout.
Though she has never burned out, Shumaker notes there are times when she is unhappy, and then she steps back and reprioritizes what is most important in her life. “The one thing I have never lost sight of is that there is one reason I am here, and that is the patient.”
“This tale about a nursing shortage is as old as time, and we are fooling ourselves when we act like this is a new problem,” says David A. Wyatt, PhD, RN, NEA-BC, CNOR, chief nursing officer, University Hospitals, UT [University of Texas] Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas.
“We in the nursing profession have known about this shortage and have not done anything about it, and the truth is, we have to,” he says.
Referencing the American Association of Colleges of Nursing, Wyatt notes that in 2020, 66,000 qualified applicants were turned away from nursing schools. “That’s a lot of people we are turning away every single year,” he says. “The average person who doesn’t know anything about healthcare looks at nurses and wonders what’s wrong with us. We complain that there aren’t enough nurses, but we won’t let people get into school, and we don’t want to hire people just out of school. None of this makes sense, and we have got to figure out how to solve this problem.”
Wyatt adds that a 2021 American College of Healthcare Executives’ annual survey reported in Becker’s Hospital Review “absolutely floored” him because it was the first time in 17 years that hospital CEOs acknowledged there might be a shortage of nursing personnel.
“Where have they been for 17 years?” he asks. “They have not been paying attention, and that’s very concerning.”
Part of the problem, Wyatt says, is that “we are comparing the number of nurses we think we need to an unknown number. We really don’t know how many nurses are practicing and at what level they are practicing because we don’t have good agreement and collaboration among our state boards of nursing.”
In his work with the Competency and Credentialing Institute (CCI), James Stobinski, PhD, RN, CNOR, CEO of CCI, Englewood, Colorado, says there are three sources of data for the makeup of the perioperative nursing workforce—CCI has data on some 42,000 certificants; AORN publishes an annual salary survey that has demographic data, and OR Manager has an annual salary survey that has historical data on perioperative nurses. However, Stobinski notes in the March 2022 OR Manager, each of these sources is a partial picture of the overall profession, and there is no mechanism to combine them or standardize the data gathered.
All of this compels some to say there really is not a shortage of nurses. Instead, there is a shortage of solutions for a complex and systemic problem.
Part of the problem is that the division of nursing into specialties has limited its ability to look at the broader picture.
“I am a unicorn,” says Wyatt, who was featured in OR Manager’s Leadership Series in May 2022. “I am a perioperative registered nurse who is the chief nursing officer at a major academic medical center. And I am a man. There are not many of us.”
The reality is that most chief nursing officers do not want to get near the OR because it scares them, he says. They do not know what is happening on the other side of the red line, so they tend to focus on the inpatient settings.
Wyatt says he understands this, but he tells his colleagues they have to have a better understanding of what all RNs are dealing with in their organizations, not just the areas they are comfortable with.
Likewise, he adds, perioperative nurses need to be more interested in what their colleagues outside the OR are experiencing. “When you choose not to go to the practice council because all that is discussed are inpatient issues, you are divorcing yourself from your profession and your professional colleagues in the hospital,” he says. “That does not help us. We have to fight our battles together and move to some systematic solutions.”
To problem solve, nurses have to ask the right questions, says Wyatt. It is not just about how to get more nurses, but how to get qualified nurses, and what is impacting this.
“In a complex system, you have to address the right problems and the right questions in the right order,” he says.
Everyone wants experienced nurses, but there are a number of issues affecting this—workload demand, salary compression, and aging workforce. All of these problems have to be solved to get more experienced nurses, and they have to be solved in order. “You are never going to have experienced nurses if you don’t have novice nurses, newly licensed nurses, newly graduated nurses, nursing students, or applicants to nursing school.”
In the April and May issues of OR Manager, Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, describes various student pipelines to perioperative nursing, including nurse residency and fellowship programs, educator-manager partnerships, surgery-school partnerships, role of preceptors, and social onboarding.
Faculty shortages are indeed impacting the number of applicants that can get into nursing schools, he says. For example, California has mandates by law that nursing schools can only admit so many students based on the number of clinical seats and faculty members. This has hampered their ability to recruit more nurses.
This has also increased competition for admission, which is good in that only the best and the brightest are admitted, says Wyatt, but some of these best and brightest progress through their bedside nursing careers very quickly and become nurse anesthetists and nurse practitioners. “This is not a negative thing, but it is a variable that we have to account for,” he says.
“We as nurses have got to own this shortage problem, and we need to expect more from our professional associations,” says Wyatt.
The American Academy of Nursing (AAN), ANA, and AORN are beginning to become engaged, but it has been a long time coming, he says.
Wyatt has been asked by AORN to participate as its representative to the ANA task force on the nurse staffing crisis. “I am happy to do this,” he says, “but there is a part of me that asks: Why are we just now doing this?”
Nursing leaders need to engage in this crisis, and they need to stop being scared, he says. They need to remember that they do not serve the CEO of the hospital, they serve the nurses they represent in the organization.
The reality is, the education industry is not healthcare, which is the fundamental difference between physician education and nursing education, says Wyatt.
Physician education is still associated with medical centers. They are still where the money is generated; whereas, nursing education is for the most part completely separate since the demise of diploma programs.
The outcomes that interest nursing academia are not the same that interest hospitals, and because of that, their outcomes are not congruent with the healthcare industry.
“It is important to align outcomes,” says Wyatt. For example, he says he has had to remind his hospital’s education department that the outcome is not educating residents; the outcome is a staffed hospital. “The residency is a tactic to staff the hospital, but it’s not the outcome in and of itself,” he says. “It is important as nurses that we also engage in a review of our education industry.”
“We can’t talk about the nursing shortage without mentioning money,” says Wyatt.
This has to start with an appropriate base salary, but it also has to account for the workload and the skill set. “Sometimes we are more concerned about being fair than anything else, and that has not served us well from a salary standpoint,” he says.
Some nurses believe cardiac surgery nurses with very high competency requirements should be paid the same as a nurse who works in an area with lower requirements. However, they do not have a problem with cardiac surgeons being paid more than family practice physicians.
At some point nurses have to be okay with rewarding and recognizing nurses who have chosen a specialty that requires a high level of preparation and competency, he says. “And they have got to be rewarded for that from a financial standpoint.”
Experienced nurses need to understand that teaching is a part of their professional obligation. Wyatt says if there is one thing that gets him “fired up” it is when experienced nurses say they do not want to have new nurses assigned to them. “You have a professional obligation to teach a new nurse,” he says. “You have an obligation to the profession.”
Nurses should expect more from their professional associations. Professional associations have to be engaged in addressing the issues—not just repeating the problem, says Wyatt. AORN’s work with Chamberlain University is a great start, he says, and perioperative nurses have to build more relationships like this. In addition, AORN needs to be involved in endowing chairs for perioperative nursing in universities across the country. “We’ve got to stack the deck with faculty who are interested in perioperative nursing, and one way to do that is through endowing chairs because education, just like hospitals, follows the money,” he says.
The AAN is nursing’s brain trust with some of the smartest people in the profession. They have to become more focused on overhauling nursing education and investing in faculty, Wyatt advises.
“If you wonder why NCLEX [National Council Licensure Examination] doesn’t have very many questions on perioperative nursing, it’s because it is all about who is leading and who is interested. You won’t attract perioperative students if you don’t have faculty who are interested in the practice setting,” he says.
In addition, the ANA needs to invest in a better understanding of the workforce supply and demand and force the State Boards of Nursing to work together to better help nurses understand the workforce dynamics.
Nurses need to determine how they will know they are making progress.This is not something that will happen overnight, Wyatt says. “If you are talking about the nursing shortage, and someone starts a sentence with ‘all you have to do,’ stop listening to them. They don’t know what they are talking about if they think it is that simple. It is going to take a massive effort.”
It is not just about paying nurses more, he adds. It is that everything that needs to be done has to be addressed in the correct way. “The truth of the matter is that there is too much money in healthcare, and we have to remember this because nursing will not be allowed to compromise that revenue.”
If nursing doesn’t figure this out, someone else will, and they will take portions of nursing practice and delegate it to someone else, he says. “This has happened to our profession before.”
When nurses are solving the problems, they own their practice, but nurses will be behind the times if they allow someone else to do it, says Wyatt. “I guarantee you,” he says, “there is too much money riding on this.”
Wyatt notes that he has heard nurse managers say they have had to shut down their trainers and educators because they do not have enough staffing. “This will not be allowed to last too long,” he says. “We are fooling ourselves if we think this is the way it’s going to be. Eventually there will be a way figured out outside of nursing. It is important that we get ahead of this.”
A Chinese proverb says: “The best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago. The second best time is now.” Nursing should have solved the shortage problem 20 or 30 years ago. That was the best time, says Wyatt, and the second best time is now.
“If there is no desire to wake up and take action, then what we have now is what we will have in the future,” he says. “If we all continue to do the same things, accept the same things, accept people around us who are not engaged in the way we need to be, then we can’t complain because we are allowing our future to be what we have now. We have to think differently.”
The way ahead is understanding that complex problems are not solved overnight. Nurses have to insist on engagement of their nursing leaders, association leaders, and education leaders. “This is not a short-term problem,” he says, “this is a really long-term problem.”
—Judith M. Mathias, MA, BS, RN, is the clinical editor of OR Manager. Previously, she was clinical editor of the AORN Journal and a cardiac surgical nurse at Rose Medical Center, Denver, and Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston.
American Association of Colleges of Nursing. Fact sheet: Nursing shortage. September 2020.
American Association of Colleges of Nursing. Nursing faculty shortage. September 2020.
American Nurses Association. Nurses in the workforce.
Shumkater R, Wyatt D. Is there really a nursing shortage? AORN Global Surgical Conference & Expo. 2022.
Bureau of Labor Statistics. Employment projections 2019-2029.
Haddad L M, Annamaraju P, Toney-Butler T J. Nursing shortage. StatPearls [Internet]. 2022.
Institute of Medicine. The future of nursing: Leading change, advancing health. October 2010.
Kronos. Employee engagement in nursing. 2017.
World Health Organization. Preventing violence against health workers. 2022.