What if unprofessional behavior in the OR could be managed through something as simple as an informal chat over a cup of coffee? This peer-to-peer approach advocated by Vanderbilt University School of Medicine led to the development of two well-established, scientifically validated programs designed to offset unprofessional behavior: the Patient Advocacy Reporting System (PARS®) and the Co-worker Observation Reporting System (CORS™).
Unprofessional behavior from physicians affects everything from organizational culture to retention rates and can lead to a host of problems outside of the operating room, including poorer patient outcomes and malpractice suits.
Unprofessional behavior—which includes rudeness, refusal to practice handoffs or observe protocols, extreme delays in response, jousting, and failure to adhere to safety guidelines—happens in every hospital. However, studies using data from PARS and CORS found that a small percentage of physicians account for the majority of complaints.
When it comes to patient complaints, 5% of physicians account for 35% of complaints and 50% of claims dollars. Furthermore, these same physicians have patients who are more likely to have poor surgical outcomes. When it comes to coworker complaints, just 3% of professionals are associated with half of coworker complaints regarding unprofessional behavior. Around 85–95% of professionals receive no coworker complaints.
The two programs out of Vanderbilt’s Center for Patient and Professional Advocacy (CPPA) provide a means for intervention to combat patient and coworker concerns and have improved outcomes at hundreds of hospitals around the country.
PARS provides intervention for doctors who act unprofessionally toward patients such as dismissing their concerns, refusing to answer them, or belittling them. Through the program, unsolicited patient complaints are sent to the Office of Patient Relations in order to identify and address the small percentage of physicians who exhibit problem behavior.
CORS provides intervention for physicians acting unprofessionally toward their colleagues, such as refusing to follow safety protocols in the OR or lashing out at surgical team members. In both programs, the focus is on introducing a trained peer messenger to have an informal chat about the complaints over a cup of coffee. With feedback provided by a non-authority figure in a private non-judgmental environment, it diffuses the recipient’s defensiveness and allows the physician to correct his or her behavior without fear of punishment or reporting.
“We call it cup of coffee conversation training,” says Lynn Webb, PhD, assistant dean of Vanderbilt School of Medicine who leads CPPA’s CORS program. “We train individuals to have a conversation that is nonjudgmental, collegial, and non-punitive. We’re not trying to decide who is right or wrong.” It’s important that this intervention happens between peers, says Webb, adding that “We know it’s hard for leaders to not be seen as the boss.”
Vanderbilt’s research has shown that the vast majority of healthcare professionals improve their behavior after just one informal conversation.
Keith Gran, CPA, MBA, the Chief Patient Experience Officer at University of Michigan, says his institution implemented PARS and CORS 3 years ago and has seen demonstrable improvement in unprofessional behavior from physicians, with most not needing additional intervention after their first peer conversation.
“At end of the day, most faculty will be self-reflective,” Gran says. “Once they see the data, 90% accept it as fact and then go about their work with that in back of their minds. They try to be more professional.”
Empathy is key, Webb adds. “We want our peer messengers to also be empathic messengers,” he says. “‘How are you doing? You seem stressed. From talking with you, I can understand how challenging this must be.’ Not excusing, not enabling; but certainly, empathic.”
Should a physician’s behavior not improve and he or she receives three or more patient or coworker complaints, the PARS and CORS programs provide a tiered approach to address and improve his or her behavior. If unprofessional behavior continues after the coffee conversation, a physician would receive an awareness intervention, essentially a longer discussion with a peer messenger. This intervention would determine if there are significant life stressors or if the physician might be struggling with burnout or exhaustion.
Creating a larger structure in which wellness and open communication are valued is important in providing outlets for physicians under added stress, says Webb. He adds that it’s essential for hospitals to have wellness resources to serve their staff, such as support groups, counseling, and hotlines.
If the unprofessional behavior continues, a guided intervention by an authority figure would take place. If there is no change at level three, it would escalate to disciplinary action.
Gran says they have trained 70 to 80 peer messengers at different ranks and specialties at University of Michigan and the success rate for both programs is around 85% improvement.
These programs have also helped health systems to uncover a less obvious problem driving a physician’s unprofessional behavior, such as cognitive impairment.
In a study using patient complaint data from PARS, Vanderbilt researchers looked at data for over 33,000 physicians practicing in 144 US hospitals and compared words from patient complaints about physicians with and without cognitive disorders. There were 15 physicians who had been diagnosed with early cognitive impairment in the study. 11 of the complaints, or 73%, had at least one word that pointed to cognitive impairment in a related patient complaint such as “forgot,” “confused,” “strange,” “odd,” or “inappropriate.”
PARS was launched 25 years ago by Vanderbilt, and CORS 11 years ago. Both programs have now been implemented at hundreds of hospitals and have national data that can provide more nuanced understanding about who is the subject of complaints, how unprofessional behavior impacts surgical teams, how patient and coworker complaints differ by specialty, and the impact of unprofessional behavior on malpractice suits and patient outcomes.
For instance, a recent study in JAMA Surgery, using PARS data, found that surgeons who behave unprofessionally undermine patient safety, prevent teamwork, and have increased risk for medical errors and surgical complications.
“If a surgeon had zero reports of unprofessional behavior, the rate for post-surgical complications for their patients was as expected for the procedure being performed,” says Webb, referencing the study. “If they had four or more reports of unprofessional behavior, the patients were almost 30% more likely to have a post-surgical complication.”
Since 2013, over 1,300 messengers have been trained by CORS and nearly 10,000 cups of coffee conversations have taken place. Thanks to those interventions, 90% of individuals flagged for unprofessional behavior improved. Meanwhile, the University of Pennsylvania Health System saw a 50% reduction in malpractice costs since implementing PARS in 2006.
Ultimately, says Webb, the success of these programs relies on the people, the organization, and the systems they have put in place. “First, you need committed leaders; organizationally, what drives the work is values,” he says. “At Vanderbilt, we have a single policy that applies to students, faculty staff, residents—it has to be clear to everybody. Finally, you need a tiered intervention model; every event is important. Have a cup of coffee and talk about it in a non-threatening, non-punitive way.”
—Brita Belli is an award-winning writer and PR professional with published stories in the New York Times, National Geographic, MSN.com, and Alternet.