March 16, 2017

OR leader job analysis helps sort out roles, responsibilities

By: Cynthia Saver
Share

DiAnna Young, BSN, RN, CSSM, CNOR

A new tool is available to help OR leaders both develop their careers and prepare their successors to take over when they leave. An OR manager job analysis, released in September 2016, provides an evidence-based approach to building the careers of OR leaders, both novice and experienced.

“It really helps you define what you need to focus on as a leader, and is a valuable tool for training,” says DiAnna Young, BSN, RN, CSSM, CNOR, director of surgery for Jennie Stuart Medical Center in Hopkinsville, Kentucky, and a member of the task force that contributed its expertise to the analysis. “I’m also using it to transition staff into leadership roles.”

 

What a job analysis can do for you

Linda Waters

A job analysis is often conducted as the first step in developing a certificate or certification program, as was the case with the OR manager analysis. The job analysis was developed by Prometric, a test development and delivery company based in Baltimore, on behalf of the Competency & Credentialing Institute, Denver, which used it to create the certified surgical services manager (CSSM) examination.

“But the rich data from these analyses can also be leveraged in other, powerful ways,” says Linda Waters, vice president of Prometric. For example, OR leaders can use results from the OR manager job analysis for the following:

  • Identify professional education opportunities. The tasks and knowledge statements in a job analysis provide leaders with an extensive list of content areas where professional education can be focused. “You can compare what’s on the list to identify education needs for yourself and your staff,” Waters says.
  • Create accurate job descriptions. Knowing which tasks and skills are considered by experts as most important for a job role helps managers draft accurate job descriptions. “Using these statements as the foundation, job descriptions can be customized to match the vision, mission, and values of the employing institution,” Waters says.
  • Provide a benchmark for performance appraisals. Job analysis information can serve as a benchmark for evaluating an employee’s performance.

The job analysis uses survey-based methodology that includes establishing the domains of a role.

“You can think about a domain as if you had lots of things in your pantry and wanted to organize them according to category, for example, bread-associated products such as flour and cornmeal,” Waters says. “In any job there will be major buckets of content, and those are the domains.”

 

Help from subject matter experts

Draft domains, along with associated tasks and knowledge statements for the OR manager role, were created based on information in the literature, job descriptions, and analyses for similar roles. Then it was time for subject matter experts—in this case, OR managers—to weigh in.

Cryssie Tino, MSN, RN, CSSM, CNOR

Prometric formed a task force of OR leaders who provided input. “We spent a lot of time carefully reviewing the material,” says member Cryssie Tino, MSN, RN, CSSM, CNOR, director of perioperative services for Mercy Health—West Hospital in Cincinnati. “We fine-tuned some of the verbiage, making sure it was universal to nurses in different practice settings.”

The 12-person task force included nurses from across the country. “We had multiple levels of education, levels of experience, and levels of job roles,” Tino says.

Next, the task force reviewed a pilot survey. “We went through every question to be sure it was clear,” says task force member Cambria Nwosu, MSN, RN, CSSM, CNOR, neurosurgical and orthopedic spine specialty coordinator for the John C. Lincoln Medical Center in Phoenix.

In the final distributed survey, respondents rated knowledge and task statements that described the job role and assigned ratings based on such variables as frequency, criticality, and importance. The results were used to formulate the final list of domains, knowledge, and tasks (sidebar below).

Only about 200 completed responses are needed to analyze data from a job analysis; 1,079 responded to the OR manager survey.

The results matched the task force’s expectations. “They were on target with what we discussed in our group,” Nwosu says. “It gave a good picture of what we do [as OR managers],” adds Young.

“There are many things we do that we don’t necessarily have documented anywhere, and this captured them,” she explains.

Applying the analysis to practice

Task force members have already applied what they learned from the job analysis in practice. “It was good to compare the ideal state to my current state,” Tino says. “I’m using the gap analysis to plan career development for myself and my team.”

Nwosu also found the job analysis helpful in identifying areas of improvement in her leadership skills.

Tino adds, “For new and experienced leaders, it’s easy to get caught up in the daily grind and not take time to reflect. You can use this tool as a reference point to evaluate what you and your team are doing. It’s quick and concise.”

OR leaders can take a deeper dive into the job analysis by examining the linkages between tasks and knowledge (sidebar above). The tasks can be used in developing job descriptions and education programs.

 

Carving out time

It takes time to digest the information provided in a job analysis. For those who believe that a job analysis is just one more task for an already long to-do list, Young has this advice: “Taking the time to read over this, learn about it, and utilize it in your own day-to-day operations is going to be extremely beneficial.” ✥

 

Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat