Serious barriers—including resistance from nursing leaders—are keeping nurses from adopting evidence-based practices that could improve nursing outcomes, finds a survey of more than 1,000 RNs.
Leader and manager resistance was ranked among the top barriers along with politics and organizational cultures.
Asked what would help, respondents named education, access to information, and organizational support.
Evidence-based practice refers to making patient care decisions based on evidence from well-designed clinical research. Studies suggest evidence-based care can reduce complications and lower costs by as much as 30%.
Though a little more than half of respondents reported evidence-based practice was used consistently in their organization, only about one-third said their colleagues consistently used these practices.
Respondents with more education tended to have more confidence in adopting evidence-based practice. But the longer nurses had been in health care, the less interested they were in learning more about evidence-based practice.
“This was a distressing finding. And it’s a huge problem,” says the lead author, Bernadette Melnyk, PhD, RN, FNAP, FAAN, of Ohio State University, Columbus. The study, The State of Evidenced-Based Practice in US Nursing: Implications for Nurse Leaders and Educators, is in the September 2012 Journal of Nursing Administration.
The average age of nurses is 47, and many were educated when evidence-based practice was not well integrated into education programs. As a result, many RNs practice the way they were taught or are steeped in tradition, she says.
Another disconcerting finding, Melnyk says, was that a substantial number of nurses said their leader or manager is resistant to evidence-based practice.
“What I’ve seen as a consultant is that a lot of leaders and managers will say they want their clinicians to deliver evidence-based care, but they don’t walk the talk. If leaders do not role model evidence-based decision making and are not providing tools, education, and resources, it’s probably not going to happen.”
While 46% of respondents agreed that research findings are routinely applied to improve patient outcomes in their institution, 76% indicated it was important for them to receive more education and skills in evidence-based practice.
Fewer than one-third reported mentors were available to help them learn more about how to adopt these practices.
Nurses in hospitals with Magnet Recognition for nursing excellence were more likely to report the adoption of evidence-based care, along with education and support.
Melnyk says the findings indicate the need for widespread cultural change and a new direction for nursing education, which tends to emphasize research methods rather than how to put research findings to use. ❖