September 22, 2014

Little change seen in salaries despite greater case volume, responsibility

By: OR Manager
Awards  
Share

OR directors and managers in hospitals continue to see stable salary patterns, even though volume is increasing in many areas of the US and leaders have more responsibilities, according to the 24th annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. One-third of respondents said surgical volume has increased in the past year, compared to 26% in 2013, and only 30% reported a decrease.

A look back at 5 years ago indicates that OR leaders’ scope of practice has broadened considerably. For example, in 2009, 57% of respondents said preadmissions services reported to them, compared to 68% in 2014. The percentages of those reporting to the OR leader also rose for postanesthesia care, outpatient/same-day surgery, central processing, and GI/endoscopy, among others. Only rarely did a substantive decrease occur. For example, materials management dropped from 45% in 2009 to 34% this year.

Despite these changes, the average annual salary in 2014 was $123,000, only slightly higher than the $120,000 figure from the past 2 years. The average annual raise dropped slightly from 3.3% last year to 2.6% this year. The Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U) increased by 2.1% for the year ending in June 2014, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

 

Survey highlights

Other key findings include:

• Far more teaching hospitals than community hospitals have earned Magnet recognition (55% vs 12%).

• The gap in earnings between OR leaders in teaching and community hospitals has widened over the past 5 years.

• Benefits are similar to those reported in 2013.

• Compared to other regions, respondents in the West most commonly reported an increase in surgical volume (57%).

• About 33% of respondents plan to retire by 2019, slightly lower than 38% in 2013, but still a significant number.

• Many OR leaders have taken action in response to the Affordable Care Act (see p 11).

 

Little gain in compensation

Wages, bonuses, and benefits add up to an average of $149,000 total compensation, compared to $147,000 last year, with leaders in the West and the Northeast reporting $157,000 and those in the Midwest and South reporting $145,000. As expected, those who oversee more than one OR earn more than those who manage only one.

Respondents who work in teaching hospitals earn more than those in community hospitals, and the gap has widened significantly when compared to 5 years ago. The difference between the two settings in average salary was $29,000 in 2014 compared to $18,000 in 2009, and the difference in total compensation was $40,000 this year, compared to $20,000 in 2009.

The gap between earnings and job title is higher as well. In 2009, the difference in salary between administrators/administrative directors and directors was $24,000, and now it’s $36,000. The gap between director and nurse manager was only $11,000 in 2009, compared to $23,000 this year. These gaps likely reflect changes in roles and responsibilities over the years.

The top three most common benefits remain the same as last year—health insurance, dental insurance, and 401(K) retirement plan. However, several benefit categories have decreased, including bonuses/profit sharing (31% in 2014 vs 55% in 2013), educational benefits (38% vs 56%), and pensions (34% vs 43%). It’s too soon to tell if the changes are an aberration or a sign of a trend.

Portrait of an OR leader’s job

Here is a closer look at the everyday job life of an OR leader.

Facility. Consistent with past surveys, 72% of respondents work in a community hospital, 18% in a teaching hospital, and 4% in another type of setting. Most respondents hold the title of director (45%), followed by nurse manager (25%) and administrator/administrative director (23%).

Scope of role. In all, 79% of respondents manage ORs in only one facility. Respondents with the title of administrator/administrative director are more likely than those with the title of director or nurse manager to be responsible for ORs in more than one facility.

Respondents oversee an average of 113 full-time equivalents (FTEs), slightly fewer than last year’s 123; that figure breaks down to averages of 89.9 clinical and 23.2 nonclinical FTEs.

As anticipated, those with the title of administrator/administrative director supervise the most total FTEs (164), followed by director (112) and nurse manager (51). OR leaders in teaching hospitals supervise more FTEs than do their counterparts in community hospitals (215 vs 83). Geographically, the totals were 163 for the Northeast, 125 for the South, 99 for the Midwest, and 82 for the West.

OR leaders have an average of seven departments reporting to them, unchanged from last year. The most common areas they supervise are the postanesthesia care unit, outpatient/same-day surgery, central processing, preadmission services, GI/endoscopy, and preoperative unit.

Budget. OR leaders continue to bear large financial responsibilities, and budgets are substantially higher among OR leaders in teaching hospitals and those who supervise ORs in more than one facility compared with colleagues in community hospitals and those who supervise in one facility. The average operating, capital, and personnel budgets were $27.3 million, $1.76 million, and $4.65 million, respectively.

 

Portrait of an OR leader

Currently, two-thirds of administrators/administrative directors, 46% of directors, and 33% of nurse managers hold a master’s degree. Overall, 9% of respondents have an MBA, 28% hold an MS or MSN, and 10% have another master’s degree. Only two respondents have a doctorate.

Compensation has remained fairly stable while managing ORs has become an increasingly difficult job. OR directors and managers face continued or increased pressure to reduce costs, and some hospitals have failed to invest in OR leaders’ professional development to help them respond to those pressures.

“Hospital CEOs want nurses to ‘step up’ and think more strategically, but they haven’t invested in education for OR directors,” Judy Pins, MBA, BSN, RN, vice president of Pins Productions, LLC, in Chicago, told OR Manager. Pins is a former OR director whose consulting firm provides development and educational resources to the healthcare industry.

“OR leaders should see themselves as owners of the business,” Pins says. That mindset helps directors and managers understand that if surgical volume is down 6%, they can’t have the same number of personnel on the job and the same number of supplies.

Marian McCann, MBA, BSN, RN, CNOR, a healthcare consultant and director of the OR at Long Beach Memorial Medical Center in Long Beach, California, cautions that OR leaders can’t just be numbers crunchers. McCann urges OR leaders to partner with physicians and other people in the organization. She says OR directors and managers should rely on their relationships with clinical experts such as surgeons and service line leaders and, on the business side, with experts in quality, finance, and infection control.

The ability of OR leaders to meet the needs of both the business and their perioperative services teams is crucial to success, and achieving this balance isn’t easy, especially with concerns about readmission penalties and reduced reimbursement—among many other issues.

About half of this year’s survey respondents rated job satisfaction as a 4 on a 5-point scale (with 5 being “very satisfied,” and 1 being “not satisfied at all”). Although women comprise 87% of OR leadership, OR leaders of both genders report an average job satisfaction of 3.9 (comparable to 4.1 in 2013). The percentage of respondents reporting they are very satisfied dropped from 32% in 2013 to 24% this year, however, and 25 (19%) rate their satisfaction as a 3. Just seven (5%) of respondents rate their satisfaction as 2, and only one respondent reported not being satisfied at all.

The future

The average age for respondents was 55.2 years, compared to 52.3 in 2009 and 55 last year. The median age of 57 is comparable to last year’s 56. Only 16 respondents were younger than 44 years, and seven were 65 or older.

Many OR leaders will be retiring soon: 4% this year and 29% between 2015 and 2019. Right behind them are the 39% who plan to retire between 2020 and 2024, and 15% who plan to retire between 2025 and 2029. Just 12% plan to retire in 2030 or later.

Concern about who will replace retiring OR leaders remains high. Given the relatively flat financial rewards in recent years, the dearth of perioperative nursing education in most nursing schools, and apprehension about the impact of the ACA, it will be interesting to see the responses to next year’s survey. ✥

Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

Salary/career survey

Data for the OR Manager Salary/Career Survey were collected from April to May 2014. The survey list comprised 800 OR Manager subscribers who are directors (or equivalent) of hospital ORs. The survey was closed with 138 usable responses—a 17% response rate. To ensure representation of the target audience, results were filtered to include only the 131 respondents who work full time as a manager or director. The margin of error is±7.9 percentage points at the 95% confidence level.

This article reports the compensation and management findings from the survey. Results from the staffing portion of the survey appeared in the September OR Manager.

We thank everyone who generously took time to complete this year’s survey and provide the information that will be of interest to our readers.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat