January 31, 2025

Navigating difficult conversations as a perioperative leader

Perioperative leaders navigate some of the most challenging dynamics in healthcare. The precision required in the OR coupled with multidisciplinary teams and diverse personalities often lead to missteps or misunderstandings that can quickly brew into conflict. Effective communication is essential, particularly when addressing behavior, managing team dynamics, or delivering difficult news.

How to be comfortable leading difficult conversations? How to confront toxicity without alienating the entire team? How to best navigate generational divides in the fast-paced, high-pressure environment of surgery? These were just some of the questions posed during the panel, “Managing difficult conversations—How to respond effectively to your team,” held at the 2024 OR Manager Conference in Las Vegas.

The three panelists were:

• Brian Dawson, MSN, RN, CNOR, CSSM, CEO and president of BD Perioperative & Healthcare Consulting, LLC and former system VP of perioperative services at CommonSpirit Health

• Cindy Hess, MSN, RN, FNP-C, CNAMB, director of nursing at Northeast Missouri Ambulatory Surgery Center

• Vikram Tiwari, PhD, professor of anesthesiology, biomedical informatics, biostatistics, management, and senior director of surgical analytics at Vanderbilt University Medical Center and Vanderbilt University.

Drawing on decades of combined experience across different areas and facilities, these seasoned leaders shared practical approaches and field-tested strategies to navigate difficult conversations while maintaining team morale, ensuring professionalism and empathy, and prioritizing patient safety.

 

Q: Describe a difficult conversation or dynamic and how you handled it.

Dawson: One case involved an SPD [sterile processing department] technician whose performance repeatedly fell below expectations. As a leader, I try to exhaust all options before making decisions that impact someone’s employment. With this individual, I initiated several meetings involving union representatives and direct supervisors to provide clear feedback and set measurable goals. Despite extensive remediation efforts, the performance did not improve. I ultimately facilitated his transition to another department, thinking he might succeed elsewhere. Throughout the process, my focus was on fairness and support. I never have these conversations alone or while angry. Instead, I think how I’d want it handled if I were in their position. Staying calm, collaborative, and transparent are key elements of my general approach.

Tiwari: A difficult situation I faced involved an employee who repeatedly made inappropriate comments, causing discomfort among colleagues. At first, the staff member most affected hesitated to report the behavior formally, fearing it would escalate into an HR [human resources] issue. I took a two-tiered approach. First, I addressed the issue informally with the employee’s supervisor to prompt a change in the problematic behavior. When that failed, HR became involved, and we made the tough decision to terminate the employee. This case taught me two lessons: Leaders must act decisively when behavior jeopardizes workplace culture, and providing a safe, judgment-free space for employees to voice concerns is essential for resolving conflicts early.

Hess: There was a question from the audience. Someone mentioned receiving repeated complaints about a manager with military background in charge of clinical education, and how some of the student nurses were feeling anxious and unsupported during the too-rigorous training. They [audience member] held several one-on-one conversations with that manager, outlined specific concerns, and saw promising changes at first. But that manager eventually fell back on old habits. I think sitting down to directly address the communication style issue was the right approach, even if it didn’t work long-term. I’d establish regular check-ins with that manager and find a balance between direct feedback and ongoing support to drive lasting change. I work at an ASC [ambulatory surgery center], and we don’t have HR. I wasn’t given the tools or the education to address behavioral issues. I tell myself that as a leader, I might not get it right the first time. Instead of seeing that as failure, I look at it as a learning opportunity and keep trying.

Dawson: Giving resources to that manager could be really helpful. There are tons of books, articles, and/or podcasts out there to help military personnel with communication and leadership. And reviewing some of the lessons in those resources with them during the regular check-ins would be valuable.

 

Q: How do you address generational conflicts in your teams?

Dawson: Generational conflicts often occur because of differing perspectives on work processes. For instance, I had a boomer nurse who felt undermined by millennial team members questioning her methods. I mediated by emphasizing shared priorities, such as patient safety, and encouraging each generation to see the other’s strengths. Through this open dialogue, we reached a compromise that improved workflow and their professional relationship. Leaders might be called to act as translators, and fostering respectful discussions and collaboration can be an effective way to do that.

Hess: I agree. At my ASC, generational tensions come from communication differences. I had a similar situation, a respected charge nurse with decades of experience who clashed with a younger scrub tech over procedure. The charge nurse was committed to ‘her way or the highway’ style, while the scrub tech questioned things and looked for ways to innovate. Instead of letting the conflict simmer, I introduced team-building workshops that included discussions about generational traits and preferences. These sessions helped them better understand each other and focus on shared goals. Be proactive when addressing conflict, and frame the feedback as opportunities for mutual growth, so no side feels discouraged or like the other is getting preferential treatment.

Tiwari: Generational conflicts usually boil down to resistance to change. For example, seasoned staff may view new protocols as unnecessary, while younger staff may see them as opportunities for improvement. I’ve found success using collaborative conflict resolution strategies, such as the ‘Win-Win’ model. This involves aligning individual goals with organizational priorities. Explaining the ‘why’ behind changes is particularly effective. I once reframed a discussion around procedural updates by showing how they would improve patient outcomes and efficiency. And when appropriate, I invite buy-in from staff. Engaging your teams in the decision-making process can help reduce resistance.

 

Q: How do you handle toxic dynamics among staff?

Dawson: Toxic dynamics don’t happen on day one; it stems from unchecked behavior over time. I had a group of senior scrub techs who constantly resisted change. Eventually, I learned that those techs felt empowered in their behavior because one or two surgeons favored them due to their specialized training. So, I met with the surgeons to explain the issue and make sure they understood what was happening. Once I gained the surgeons’ backing, I confronted that group of senior scrub techs directly. I was able to set clear expectations and outline consequences for non-compliance because I knew they’d no longer be ‘protected’ behind the scenes. Combining individual accountability with stakeholder alignment was critical in this case.

Hess: Toxic team dynamics will poison workplace culture if left unchecked. In one case, I dealt with experienced nurses who routinely belittled newer staff. I held meetings to try and get to the bottom of it, until I realized there was a ‘ring leader’ at the core of it. Through individual conversations with that person, I uncovered personal frustrations that were causing their behavior. I was able to address some of their frustrations, then set clear expectations for professional conduct moving forward. That slowly trickled down to the other experienced nurses also causing trouble. One influential person in your team can be seen as an ‘informal leader’; identifying and engaging that person goes a long way toward ensuring workplace culture stays positive. However, in cases where behavior doesn’t improve, leaders must make the hard decision to let said individuals go.

Tiwari: I use Lean principles to address toxicity. One strategy is conducting a root-cause analysis to uncover the underlying issues. For example, I worked with a team where the senior staff exhibited controlling behavior, which in turn was stifling innovation. I held solution-focused conversations with that staff, after which I incorporated their senior expertise into organizational decisions. That second part is important—it’s not enough to gather feedback. Staff want to see that feedback being put into use, so they feel valued and not like they wasted their time. That’s how I shifted their mindset from resistance to collaboration.

 

Q: How do you manage difficult news, like budget cuts/layoffs, while maintaining team morale?

Dawson: In 2011, I faced a significant challenge when budget constraints threatened layoffs in my team. While I couldn’t disclose all details, I was upfront about the potential consequences and worked with staff to identify productivity improvements to mitigate the need for cuts. We developed a tracking system, which staff used to monitor progress and take proactive measures, such as voluntary time off, if results were lagging. This collaborative approach not only avoided layoffs but also created a sense of shared responsibility. Honesty and transparency, even when constrained by confidentiality, are key to maintaining trust during tough times.

Hess: Delivering bad news is a delicate balance. During a period of staffing cuts, I focused on why they had to happen. I explained how the changes would ultimately benefit the organization and maintain quality care for the patients we serve. No one likes to hear that they’re losing hours, but odds are the staff already have an inkling of what’s to come. For independent ASCs in particular, we know the reality of our budget. Being transparent and framing the conversation around what matters to us—our patients—will lead to trust and ease some of the fear. My advice is be ready with the appropriate resources to offer emotional support, answer tough questions, and provide ongoing updates to maintain that trust.

Tiwari: Communicating difficult news requires clarity and empathy. I also have faced situations where budget cuts led to reduced staffing hours. I agree that framing the conversation around organizational sustainability and patient care is important. That’s how I was able to help staff see the bigger picture. Additionally, I held open forums to gather feedback and address concerns. I maintain that involving staff in problem-solving not only eases transitions but also strengthens their commitment to organizational goals.

 

Q: What strategies can leaders use to foster a culture of respect and accountability?

Dawson: Set expectations early and consistently. I’ve had to address disruptive behavior with surgeons, for instance, which can be tricky. One time, I confronted a surgeon known for throwing instruments and explained how his actions were making the OR—an already stressful environment—gratuitously traumatic. I outlined how that behavior was impacting staff morale and patient safety. But that early confrontation wasn’t enough, so I offered him to come to my office if he needed to blow off some steam. I told him, ‘Come punch a hole in my wall if you have to, but don’t ever behave like this in the OR again.’ He committed to changing his behavior, and it worked. We never had that problem with him again.

Tiwari: Leaders have to lead by example and display the behavior they expect from their teams. Using Lean principles, I’ve created performance metrics that align individual contributions with team goals. I not only recognize individual achievements, I show how each individual contribution is supporting the broader team, the organization at large, and every patient who crosses our doors. I try to drive home that they belong to something bigger, and when they perform at the top of their game, everyone benefits. That type of communication and consistent reinforcement builds respect and accountability. And regular feedback loops and recognition of achievements help accountability and respect to thrive.

Hess: Model the behavior you want to see. That’s how accountability starts. If you promise protection and support to your staff, then address issues that compromise their safety and keep an ‘open-door’ policy. They’ll notice if your actions don’t back up your words, and you’ll lose not only credibility but their trust. Whatever system works for you—recognition awards, open forums, training programs, shared governance, and so on—stay consistent. And celebrate the wins. A positive culture requires regular follow-through and a genuine commitment to fairness and growth.

Leadership in the perioperative environment requires more than clinical expertise. As highlighted above, navigating difficult conversations is an integral part of the job. The stories and strategies shared by Dawson, Hess, and Dr Tiwari showed the importance of transparency, empathy, and proactive communication to effectively respond to staff.

OR Manager’s online tools offer more actionable insights like these to empower leaders to meet challenges head-on. And the valuable live lessons exchanged at the OR Manager Conference, which this year takes place October 28–30 at the Anaheim Convention Center in California, are the ideal resource for new leaders to gain the confidence to navigate the complexities of the OR while prioritizing team cohesion and patient safety.

 

—Tarsilla Moura is content director of OR Manager.

 

Reference

Dawson B, Hess C, Tiwari V. Managing difficult conversations—How to respond effectively to your team. OR Manager Conference. October 2024.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat