November 17, 2022

Negotiating contracts with anesthesia: Set clear expectations and hire who you know

By: Jennifer Lubell
Share

David Shapiro, MD, who is a risk manager/medical director at several ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) near Tallahassee, Florida, has seen his fair share of contracts with anesthesia services.

David Shapiro, MD

Navigating these types of contracts at a time when anesthesiology is suffering from a workforce shortage and high costs for services is often tricky and complex. The biggest mistake ASCs make is that they do not know what they want, says Dr Shapiro, an anesthesiologist who serves on the boards of the Florida Society of Ambulatory Surgery Centers and the Ambulatory Surgery Center Association. “They create the inference that they didn’t have specific needs from the anesthesia practitioners,” he says.

As a result, the ASC pays more than it wants to, or it ends up partnering with an anesthesiology provider that falls short of expectations on hours and safety. Conversely, anesthesiologists need specifics on what the hours are, what role they have in taking care of patients, and what the OR utilization is expected to be.

Successful negotiation means defining, clarifying, and formalizing expectations. Meeting these parameters means that ASCs can conduct the cases they desire to perform, experts tell OR Manager, offering points of view from the ASC and anesthesiology sides of contracting.

If an ASC is negotiating a contract with a new anesthesia provider or group of providers, they need to understand what their coverage needs are so that the team, individual, or entity with which they are contracting becomes aware of, and is committed to fulfilling, their obligation to provide enough coverage, says Dr Shapiro.

 

The landscape on anesthesia providers

Joshua Miller, MD

When considering a contract, ASCs have several anesthesia options from which to choose. They can partner with a national medical group, a smaller regional medical group, or employ its own providers. “Depending on volume and caseload, a fair number of ASCs use per diem anesthesiologists or certified registered nurse anesthetists [CRNA],” says Joshua Miller, MD, physician managing director at Surgical Directions, a healthcare consulting firm in Chicago. For per diems, the ASC will provide malpractice insurance through their larger policy, but that is it. Benefits and time off do not exist for per diem doctors. They are paid a flat rate for the day.

Some 30 states allow nurse anesthetists to practice independently without an anesthesiologist’s supervision. “There are also many states that have COVID-waiver supervision requirements for nurse anesthetists, which are a lower cost alternative,” says Dr Miller.

Studies suggest there is no risk benefit of using a CRNA versus an MD; however, it is difficult to find unbiased data, he adds.

Many states are allowing anesthesia assistants, but they need to be supervised. The cost of anesthesia assistants is half to one third of a CRNA. The bottom line is, “we need to figure out how to get anesthesiology costs under control. We’re not producing enough anesthesiologists or CRNAs, and the patient population is aging,” says Dr Miller. Hospitals and ASCs alike are struggling to figure out the optimal anesthesiology models to use.

Experts advise that ASCs shop around and do their homework—not just on the different services, but consider also their own data and patient needs.

Tina Piotrowski, MBA, BSN, RN

ASCs should also decide whether they want an exclusive contract with one group, advises Tina Piotrowski, MBA, BSN, RN, CEO of Copper Ridge Surgery Center, a multispecialty outpatient center in Traverse City, Michigan.

“That’s an important strategic decision,” she emphasizes. In her view, a contract between just one facility and an anesthesia group usually strengthens the partnership. This signals that the ASC is invested in working with this group, and in return, the anesthesia group knows it is going to get all the business from that center. “They know you’re not going to be shopping around and trying to bring a competing group into your center,” says Piotrowski.

 

Setting coverage expectations

In drafting requests for proposal (RFP) contracts, ASCs should know the differences between a large national group and a local group, or what a per diem model is. “The national groups are a little more expensive because they’re usually public companies or private equity rollups. They need to make a different margin than a local anesthesiologist or CRNA,” says Dr Miller.

While they may cost more, you are always guaranteed to have anesthesiology services with a national group, he notes. A national group also does their own billing and collections separate from the ASC. In per diem models, ASCs generally take over the anesthesiology services.

Having your own anesthesia group or per diems may come with a marginal benefit. But especially with per diems, there is a risk of not being able to provide anesthesia if the anesthesiologist is suddenly unavailable. A per diem, for example, may decide they do not want to work on a Friday, which leaves the ASC scrambling to cover services for that day.

“If I’m an orthopedic ASC or total joints, and I can’t do a certain number of total joints in a day, I’m going to lose not only my professional fee but the facility fee,” says Dr Miller.

Katherine Grichnik, MD, MS, FASE

When drafting a contract, clearly laying out expectations on work and all financial aspects is a must, experts say. “It’s important to get extremely specific in the contract. This way, you’ll always get to an acceptable proforma on both sides,” says Katherine Grichnik, MD, MS, FASE, chief of anesthesiology services at SCA Health in Illinois.

The ASC and the provider should work together to balance the number of expected cases and needed coverage for anesthesia.

Specify what anesthesia’s role is in helping with the scheduling, moving of cases, and identifying problem patients, advises Dr Grichnik. “Someone who might have more comorbidities than somebody else may need to be done at a specific time in the day with a specific anesthesia provider. This mitigates the risk of having a controversy at the beginning of the day on the actual coverage for a patient,” she adds.

ASCs should also specify what they want in terms of the number of rooms covered, hours of service, and duration of coverage in terms of postanesthesia care, she notes.

The contract may have a salary guarantee for a certain amount of work at a given facility. Is the anesthesia group expected to start five rooms every morning at 7 am, or are they contracting to staff only three rooms? “If I need to hire three CRNAs to work in three different rooms, I know what the expectations are, and I’m not scrambling around to provide coverage,” says Dr Shapiro.

Find out how many days per week a per diem anesthesiologist will work and in how many ORs—and make sure that language is specified in the contract. “You have to build a model for what that’s going to look like so you know that you have coverage for all the rooms on the days you need them,” adds Dr Miller.

 

Other financial considerations

The anesthesia provider’s payer network should also align with the ASC. State that in the contract, says Piotrowski. “You don’t want a patient to come to your center who is in network with their commercial payer; the surgeon is in network, but the anesthesia group is not in network, and so the patient gets a surprise bill,” she says.

ASCs under new consumer billing protections may be responsible for providing uninsured and self-pay patients with a good faith estimate. “That is a different nuance than what we’ve dealt with in the past. Working with your anesthesia group on what may need to be disclosed to patients is important,” advises Piotrowski.

If the center agrees to provide initial subsidies to the anesthesia provider, your contract should have an end point for when that will cease to exist, she adds. This is especially true for an ASC startup. “Once you’re up and running, hopefully it makes financial sense for the center to drop those subsidies,” she says. “And financially, it makes sense for the anesthesia group because they’re getting the volume that they need to sufficiently cover their expenses.”

 

Examine staffing model, data

Be choosy in your contract models, Dr Miller continues. Compare and contrast; look at RFPs from different types of providers; examine what the clinical coverage and cost would look like for different models. And be cautious about low bidders because they might have trouble recruiting anesthesiology staff or may not have the extra resources to cover what is needed, Dr Miller adds.

Understanding the ASC’s staffing model needs is important, but so is understanding the data. Many ASCs and hospitals do not take the time to look through the details when drafting a contract. “They’ll just say, ‘We need more coverage,’” he says.

Some ASCs have evening cases or weekend endoscopies. “You need to have good data around what your clinical usage is, how many rooms you use daily. Find out when the anesthesiologist wants to work. Make sure the data associated with all of this is clean and correct,” he explains. If the ASC provides the wrong data in the RFP, the anesthesia company or group is going to come back with a maximum coverage model. “And that’s going to be more expensive. Tailor your RFP to exactly what you need,” he says.

Finding the right fit

Any anesthesia professional in your facility should aim high on quality and patient satisfaction. “Your anesthesia providers will need to be credentialed according to your credentialing policies and procedures; agree to follow your medical staff bylaws, rules, and regulations; and also comply with all regulatory requirements,” says Piotrowski.

This is not just about hiring a “warm body” to sit in the OR—it is about hiring an individual or group that is dedicated to safe patient care, says Dr Shapiro.

The anesthesiologist should be available either remotely or preferably onsite when the patient is onsite and after they are discharged. Observe how well they interact with the patient before surgery, deal with their families during surgery, and how they take care of the patient postoperatively.

Emergencies can arise after the patient has left the OR. “Make sure the personnel are there to provide emergency care and make clinical determinations about whether it’s safe for the patient to be discharged,” he says.

Achieving high expectations as part of contractual negotiations is not easy, Dr Shapiro admits. “But you want the anesthesia staff to be one of the strongest attributes of your facility. The staff should be so good that nurses and surgeons in your area will want to work at your facility. They know the anesthesia there will be of the highest quality,” he urges.

This is a very difficult bar to reach, especially if the negotiation with the anesthesia provider is happening for the first time. If the provider is local, ASCs should do a little research, asking local surgeons what their experiences were when working with that provider so everyone’s expectations can be met.

One way to build consistency and familiarity in service is to hire people you know. It is not as ideal to have anesthesiologists come in on a random schedule, according to Dr Shapiro. “If you’re contracting with a large group that staffs other facilities, it’s important to have that ability to choose and limit the number of people that comes into the facility,” he says.

In one contract between a large anesthesia group and an ASC where he works, Dr Shapiro negotiated that the ASC retain the ability to select the people with whom it wanted to work. “This enabled us to pick and choose the anesthesia providers that best fit our culture and allowed us to provide consistency,” he explains. “If we didn’t have that in our contract, they might send us someone who only works with us once or twice a year.”

While these individuals may be qualified, they do not have that ongoing relationship with the facility and are not as familiar with the rules of the ASC. They may not know where emergency equipment is located or even what drugs are available in the formulary.

“If you only have someone coming in once a year or even less frequently, they don’t have the benefit of experience with the facility to integrate themselves into the prevailing culture and routine,” he says.

Piotrowski advises that ASCs request a liaison or “a point person” from the anesthesia group to help smooth out the specifics of contract negotiations.

The liaison should participate in the ASC’s quality improvement committee and credentialing committee meetings, “and be a representative on some of the important decisions that ASCs have to make,” she says. They should also have an understanding on quality program reporting and ASC quality measures.

Anesthesia partners can provide valuable input with decisions on choosing the right types of patients for the center, as well as advising on the purchase of critical supplies for crash carts, malignant hyperthermia carts, and equipment such as anesthesia machines and ultrasound systems for nerve blocks.

 

The worst-case scenarios

When drafting contracts, always hire an attorney, experts advise. One important provision to consult an attorney about is an exit clause.

Both parties should have an out, advises Dr Shapiro. “If the relationship is not working out for the ASC or anesthesiologist, you need to have a provision where you can have a civil but expedited breakup,” he says. If such considerations are not in the contract, it is almost guaranteed that the issue will come up between the parties, he adds.

ASC managers do not want an anesthesiologist to call in on Sunday and say, ‘I’m done, fend for yourself tomorrow.” Conversely, it is best not to create a situation where an ASC suddenly tells an anesthesiologist, ‘You’re fired, don’t show up on Monday.’

ASCs should also reach out to their legal counsel to write a notification letter if a group is put on notice. “You want to make sure that you’re not putting the center in any jeopardy of a breach of contract,” says Piotrowski.

If any breaches in performance or the contract take place, the ASC should give the provider a certain number of days to resolve those issues. Put this in writing, adds Piotrowski. For example, the contract may give the anesthesiology group 30 days to fix any concerns or breaches. If the issues are not resolved, the ASC may have the right to send a notice of termination, giving the provider 90 days’ notice.

“Ideally any issues can be resolved quickly, so you don’t have to go down that road and start looking for another group to come in,” says Piotrowski.

—Jennifer Lubell is a freelance medical and health policy writer based in Rockville, Maryland.

 

References

Staff Care, an AMN Healthcare company. CRNAs Practice Updates and Trends. January 25, 2022.

Surprise billing & protecting consumers. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. January 1, 2022.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat