On September 15, 2022, AORN released its updated Guideline for Processing Flexible Endoscopes. Over the past several years, there has been significant research on flexible endoscope processing—research that met the stringent requirements and has been included in this revised guideline by AORN’s lead author and team.
Leadership is responsible for the safe working conditions and management of the entire endoscope process; therefore, the leader must be knowledgeable about sterilization and high-level disinfection (HLD).
Leaders need to confirm that endoscope processing is being performed to professional standards and in compliance with regulations pertaining to flexible endoscope processing. A recommendation in the guideline states that leaders should ensure there is sufficient time and staffing to perform all processing steps in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions for use (IFU), standards, and regulations.
Education is a critical part of successful endoscope processing. Evidence shows the importance of point-of-use treatment, and the revised guideline includes education recommendations for personnel at the point of use who handle flexible endoscopes. Because flexible endoscopes may also be used in other areas, such as the emergency department, intensive care units, etc, a new recommendation has been added to the guideline to include education and competency verification for all who handle and process endoscopes, regardless of their location.
Another issue addressed in the revised guideline is that some flexible endoscopes are used infrequently, which can result is personnel forgetting some steps. A conditional recommendation has been added to consider increasing the frequency of competency verification for endoscopes that are used infrequently.
The guideline features some major additions, the first of which begins with the initial step in the process: pre-purchase evaluation. Before the purchase of flexible endoscopes, equipment, or supplies that will be used for processing, it is recommended to convene an interdisciplinary team to develop a standardized process for product evaluation and selection. Having the correct people on the interdisciplinary team is essential, and this revised guideline suggests key stakeholders, including sterile processing professionals, to participate on this team.
This recommendation also provides a list of what to evaluate during product reviews, and specific criteria are identified to review flexible endoscopes, automated endoscope reprocessors (AERs), storage cabinets, borescopes, cleaning solutions, and detergents. What is more, many facilities struggle with purchasing decisions surrounding single-use or reusable flexible endoscopes and accessories; this revised guideline provides criteria to review when making these decisions.
The revised guideline separates sterilization and HLD into their own sections. Just as ANSI/AAMI ST91:2021 Flexible and Semi-Rigid Endoscope Processing in Healthcare Facilities recommends sterilizing reusable flexible endoscopes that have a manufacturer validation for sterilization whenever possible, the revised AORN Guideline for Processing Flexible Endoscopes also makes this recommendation.
This recommendation is consistent with the Spaulding Classification system, which recommends that items—such as flexible endoscopes that come in contact with nonintact skin or mucous membranes—are semi-critical and are recommended to be processed by sterilization or, at a minimum, by HLD. Further, flexible endoscopes and accessories (eg, biopsy forceps) that enter sterile tissue should be sterile when used or placed on a sterile field.
Not all flexible endoscopes can undergo sterilization according to their IFU; however, the sterilization recommendation notes that sterilization provides the highest level of assurance that processed items are free of viable microbes, and packaging systems protect the integrity of the sterilized contents until the package is opened for use while permitting the aseptic delivery of the contents.
If a liquid chemical sterilization (LCS) system is used to sterilize an endoscope for a critical procedure (endoscopes that enter sterile tissue or the vascular system), the endoscope should be immediately transported to the point of use in a closed processing container. Endoscopes used for a semi-critical procedure that are processed in a LCS system may be processed in the same manner as those that receive HLD.
After the completion of the HLD method and when removing the endoscope, it is recommended that personnel perform hand hygiene and don clean, nonlatex examination gloves (labeled as “not made with natural rubber latex”) to protect the endoscope from contamination by the personnel’s hands.
Duodenoscopes have gained heightened attention over the past several years due to associated infections. The updated AORN guideline provides a conditional recommendation to conduct a risk assessment to determine whether to perform supplemental enhanced methods for processing duodenoscopes, and it provides the types of enhanced methods for processing. Research is presented on these methods, which provides information to aid in the decision.
It is being recommended to use an automated process instead of manual for HLD because automated processes may be more efficient and consistent and may reduce personnel exposure to high-level disinfectants. Flexible endoscopes are sophisticated, complex, and expensive devices that require multiple processing steps. For that reason, it is recommended to have flexible endoscopes reprocessed in the same manner across all processing locations and shifts, including weekends.
Transport of the endoscope after use to the decontamination area now includes a hand-over process from the transporter to decontamination personnel and a list of information that should accompany the endoscope.
This list includes:
• the time that point-of-use treatment was completed
• whether treatment began immediately after use of the endoscope (and if not, the time that endoscope use was completed)
• whether the endoscope was kept moist until point-of-use treatment could be performed.
This information is critical because it alerts decontamination personnel to determine how long the endoscope has been awaiting processing. This helps establish priority order and determine whether routine processing within the manufacturer’s recommended time for cleaning is achievable (if not, employees are recommended to implement the manufacturer’s procedures for delayed processing).
Another important factor communicated in the updated guideline is what the endoscope was exposed to during the procedure (eg, simethicone, lubricants, tissue adhesives).
Leak testing is critically important when processing flexible endoscopes. Therefore, it is crucial that the leak tester functions properly. Verification of the leak tester’s pressure accuracy or calibration of automatic leak testers ensures that the leak tester is producing the correct pressure. Under-pressurizing an endoscope may allow a leak to go undetected, and over-pressurizing may stress seals and damage the endoscope. For those reasons, a new recommendation was added to verify the pressure of the leak tester in accordance with the manufacturer’s IFU. When using an AER that has a mechanical leak test, it is also recommended that the leak test performed by the AER be considered as an adjunct to leak testing performed before manual cleaning. The results of the leak test should be recorded, and if the leak test shows a failure, it should be removed from service and reported according to the healthcare organization’s policy.
New recommendations for cleaning verification have been added. The previous version of the guideline had a conditional recommendation that internal channels may be inspected with a borescope, whereas the new version recommends using a clean borescope to visually inspect accessible channels of flexible endoscopes before sterilization or HLD.
The use of a borescope for inspecting internal channels may identify damage or debris that would otherwise go undetected. It is recommended that the person performing the borescope inspection be competent to perform this task, and use of the borescope should be in aligned with the borescope manufacturer’s IFU. Healthcare organizations should identify high-risk flexible endoscopes, including duodenoscopes, bronchoscopes, ureteroscopes, and cystoscopes. These high-risk endoscopes should undergo cleaning verification testing after each use, and the results of those tests should be recorded.
If the endoscope does not pass the cleaning verification test, the endoscope should be re-cleaned and re-tested. If the device repeatedly fails cleaning verification testing, it should be removed from service and labeled as needing repair to prevent it from being used. The damaged endoscope should be reported according to the healthcare organization’s policy and with the endoscope’s unique device identifier and patient identification information.
There has been a great deal of research into flexible endoscopes and accessory drying, and this research led AORN to add new drying recommendations to the guideline. Thorough drying of flexible endoscopes is necessary because any moisture remaining on the surfaces of an endoscope can facilitate microbial growth and biofilm formation during storage. Research has shown that moisture retained in processed flexible endoscopes has been associated with patient infections, biofilm growth, microbial contamination and increased adenosine triphosphate (ATP) values.
Thorough drying is so important that there is a recommendation to perform drying even when using an AER with an air purge cycle or extended dry time feature. It is recommended to dry all accessible channels for at least 10 minutes, and if visible moisture is still present, to extend the dry time until visible moisture is no longer observed. Even so, there is a conditional recommendation that a compatible automated drying system—such as a drying cabinet with pressure-regulated, HEPA-filtered air—may be used to dry endoscope channels. Included in the drying topic is a recommendation to avoid using the same drying nozzle and adaptor that was used to dry the endoscope prior to sterilization or HLD because using the same drying nozzle or adaptors can contaminate the endoscope after HLD. The recommendations provide guidance on using the endoscope immediately or placing it into storage.
Endoscope storage time is a complex issue and varies for each facility based on numerous factors. To help determine endoscope storage time, a new conditional recommendation was added on conducting a storage time risk assessment. Also included is a list of considerations pertinent to a storage time risk assessment.
A new topic has been added to provide recommendations on transporting the endoscope to the point of use. Recommendations are provided for how to transport endoscopes, which type of container to use, and how to properly clean and disinfect the container. A conditional recommendation is provided that does not require an endoscope to be placed inside a transport container when transporting it to the point of use (as long as it is transported through a controlled, connected corridor within the endoscopy suite).
Water and irrigation bottles can be a source of endoscope contamination, and this new section has recommendations pertaining to water bottles. It is recommended to label the water bottle with its contents and the date the bottle was filled or opened. Evidence has shown that simethicone may be difficult to remove from water bottles, tubing, and endoscope channels; for that reason, it is not recommended to add simethicone to water or irrigation bottles.
Additionally, recommendations pertaining to the use of sheaths is now in its own section.
A new topic was added for prion transmission (eg, Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease). There has been concern regarding the use of flexible endoscopes on patients with suspected prion disease. Evidence shows that flexible endoscopes may be used on patients who are at an increased risk for prion disease as long as the devices are processed using standard procedures for cleaning and sterilization or HLD. The reason for this recommendation is that flexible endoscopes do not become contaminated with the high-risk tissue for prion transmission and, therefore, does not present a risk for prion transmission. Research has shown that there have been no cases of prion disease transmission by flexible endoscopes.
The topic of record-keeping has been expanded, and some of the new recommendations call for recording leak testing, cleaning verification, and borescope inspection. Specific record-keeping recommendations are provided for AER or LCS processors. In addition, new types of processing equipment have been added—such as automatic titration units, automatic flushing and drying systems, and cleaning verification—and new recommendations have been incorporated to help guide quality assurance testing and record-keeping on these types of equipment.
The guideline lists several important systems that should be reviewed such as providing adequate resources (eg, time, personnel, inventory, space), prioritizing worker safety and ergonomics, standardizing processes among departments within the healthcare organization that use flexible endoscopes, and establishing systems to improve traceability. These recommendations were added because evidence shows that processing systems and human factors can contribute greatly to errors in endoscope processing. This section acknowledges that the identification of a breach in flexible endoscope processing can be disheartening; however, the greater hazard to patient safety is the presence of an unidentified breach or one that is not reported. To address this, the recommendation to create and maintain a strong patient safety culture.
Audits are an important part of an effective quality system, helping to ensure that endoscope processing practices comply with manufacturer IFU, standards, regulations, and the healthcare organization’s policies and procedures. Quality audits can identify problem areas, assist personnel in evaluating and improving the quality of endoscope processing, and formulate plans for corrective actions.
A new recommendation has been added to evaluate water quality and water filtration systems at established times and after major maintenance to the water supply system. This will prevent poor water quality (including water that is considered contaminated) from being used. It is important to note that water quality varies seasonally and after water-source maintenance.
Other new recommendations pertain to preventative maintenance for flexible endoscopes and equipment used in their processing. It is a regulatory requirement that healthcare organizations report any suspected device-related serious injury or death to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the manufacturer (or only to the FDA if the manufacturer is unknown). A conditional requirement is also included in the revised guidelines and states that a healthcare facility may report any device malfunction to the FDA.
This article provided a broad overview of some of the key changes to the revised AORN Guideline for Processing Flexible Endoscopes. The updated version added 10 new topics that provide additional detailed guidance and delivers best practices for all stages of flexible endoscope processing based on an extensive evidence-based research review.
The complete revised AORN Guideline for flexible endoscopes provides more information and has been updated in the e-guidelines at https://www.aorn.org/eguidelinesplus. The print version will be available for purchase in 2023 on the AORN website at www.aorn.org.