October 1, 2011

New analysis: Preventing wrong surgery

By: OR Manager
Share



OR Manager; Vol. 27 No. 10; October 2011



What might be most effective in preventing wrong surgery?

A new analysis from Pennsylvania identifies best practice principles that might have prevented 431 wrong procedures reported in the state since 2004. The 21 principles were published in 2009 by the Pennsylvania Patient Safety Authority.

The authority’s analysts evaluated the reports subjectively to identify the possible best practices for reducing the risk of wrong surgery for each scenario.

Most likely scenario

For 72% (312) of the wrong procedures, the most likely scenario for prevention would have been for the provider (the surgeon doing the procedure or the anesthesiologist doing the block) to verify the information and mark the site with the patient, they found.

Information that might have prevented the error likely was in the schedule, the history and physical, the consent, and, on occasion the office records and/or preoperative imaging studies, notes the report in the September 2011 Pennsylvania Patient Safety Advisory.

“Confirming the correct site marking with the patient and initializing the mark are proof of that verification,” the report says.

The next most common principle, considered possibly preventive for 53 reports, would have been to use intraoperative imaging to verify the location of the target structure. Among these errors were wrong-level spinal procedures, stents placed in the wrong ureter, and a wrong-rib resection. For 49 of these, no other best practice principle for prevention was identified.

A proper time-out

Principles for performing a proper time-out were considered for 48 of the 66 remaining events. For 43, the single time-out principle considered was explicitly referencing the site marking in the prepped and draped surgical field during the time-out.

Adding proper verification of the patient’s information by the circulating nurse and empowering team members to speak up would have made time-outs maximally effective for the 48 narratives, the analysts found.

For 13 of the remaining 18 reports, having adequate patient information for the verification was considered the best practice principle.

Only 5 of the narratives involved unusual situations not covered by the best practices. Examples were vascular access devices placed in less-preferred arteries instead of veins, an operation based on an incorrectly dictated pathology report, a selective abortion with multiple fetuses, and regrasping an adjacent left-side anatomic structure after localizing the intended right-side anatomic structure.

The 21 best practice principles were outlined by the authority in 2009 during its Preventing Wrong-Site Surgery Project.

The report and tools for prevention of wrong-site surgery, including the Principles for Reliable Performance of Correct-Site Surgery, are at http://patientsafetyauthority.org


Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat