Theoretical advantages exist for both block and nonblock scheduling. Facilities with enough space and staff may be able to schedule cases on the basis of patient and surgeon convenience, but that doesn’t work for facilities with less flexibility.
At our facility, problems associated with first-come, first-served booking led to an initiative to convert to a block scheduling system.
A year after launching this initiative, we had increased first case on-time starts and decreased overall OR utilization, same-day surgery cancellations, and agency staffing. At the same time, our case volume increased.
Our journey to improve efficiency was based on very methodical data analysis and measurement, with protocols established to serve the needs of our physicians and staff. In this article we explain how we assessed our needs and implemented changes. Perhaps our methods can serve as a model for other perioperative services leaders striving to improve their schedules.
Bassett Healthcare is a 180-bed teaching hospital with 11 ORs in Cooperstown, New York. The Bassett Healthcare Network includes five hospitals and several regional clinical sites located about an hour by car from the primary hospital.
In our prior OR scheduling system, a surgeon could book a case, and before that surgeon could book another case, a different surgeon could fill the next time slot. In such cases, a surgeon might have split OR time on a given day, and time in between often was clinically nonproductive.
We lacked open OR space, and time utilization varied widely, from 50% to almost 80%. Studies have shown that optimal utilization (if service workloads were always the same each weekday) would be 68%.
Because the schedule was so unpredictable from day to day, we used a lot of agency nurses to fill gaps in staffing.
Before we could make changes, we needed to have a clear understanding of block scheduling concepts.
• OR utilization: the percentage of total OR time used compared to the total OR time allocated
• budgeted OR time: a figure calculated by historical usage that is used when deciding normal operating hours, staff hiring and assignment, and scheduling availability
• underutilization: unused budgeted OR time
• overutilization: use of the OR outside the budgeted OR time.
We aimed to develop a block time scheduling system for implementation in fall 2013. The initial grid was developed using average weekly OR times for the 45 surgeons who use the main operating rooms. We took care to subtract any vacation and/or continuing medical education weeks in the calculation, and all urgent/add-on cases were removed.
We also allotted time only to primary surgeons when there were assistant surgeons involved. For cases in which there were two or more primary surgeons (eg, breast removal with immediate reconstruction), time was allotted to each surgeon.
All blocks were allocated to be 8 hours long (7:30 am to 3:30 pm) to accommodate preexisting OR nursing and technician schedules. Surgeons were assigned only to full blocks based on the prior year’s utilization (ie, no partial blocks were assigned).
A total of 241 days were used to calculate initial blocks (Monday through Friday, excluding holidays) from 1/1/2012 to 12/7/2012.
This amassed a total of 12,736 elective operative hours.
OR time for each surgeon was defined as in-room to out-of-room time (thus did not include OR turnover).
For example, a surgeon who averaged 8 hours of elective surgery per week was given one block per week. A surgeon who averaged 2 hours of elective surgery per week was given one 8-hour block every 4 weeks, and so on.
Partial blocks were not given because surgeons had previously complained about having to wait for other surgeons to finish before beginning their own cases. Blocks were assigned by individual surgeon rather than by division because in some divisions, senior attendings routinely take first case starts.
Urgent case volume was calculated separately (Monday through Friday from 1/1/2012 to 12/7/2012). This totaled 2,204 hours and averaged 9.15 hours per day. Thus, one room at our institution is allocated as a full-time urgent room, with the room reserved and staffed for cases to be completed within 48 hours of booking.
We also developed a priority booking system based on priority levels 1 to 4. These levels were defined as follows:
• Priority 1: An immediate life- or limb-threatening situation. Cases in this category need to be started within 60 minutes of booking and are allocated to the next available OR.
• Priority 2: Cases that are not life-threatening but may lead to severe complications if not performed within 6 hours of booking.
• Priority 3: Cases that are not life-threatening but may lead to complications if not performed within 24 hours.
• Priority 4: Cases that are generally elective but need to be completed to move a patient through the hospital system.
In all instances, cases may move up if the patient’s status changes. The on-call anesthesiologist must be informed of all Priority 1 and 2 cases at the time of booking, and the charge staff anesthesiologist—in conjunction with the OR charge nurse—is responsible for designating case priority when equivalent cases are booked. Blocks are then addressed and audited quarterly, with emphasis placed on three parameters for change implementation.
Operating room metrics
Data comparison of the first 6 months of 2013 (prior to block time scheduling) with the first 6 months 2014 (3 months after initiation of block time scheduling).
Source: Bassett Healthcare, Cooperstown, New York.
We first set a goal of utilization of 75% or more as a rough basis for proper utilization.
Second, and perhaps most importantly, we looked at the number of elective surgical hours per week booked as a primary surgeon. This figure captures cases booked into released or other rooms, and is an indication that an individual surgeon may need more blocked time.
Finally, we looked at the number of future elective surgical hours booked. Using these parameters, block time is added or subtracted in 8-hour increments.
We compared data from the first two quarters of 2013 (first-come, first-served scheduling) against data from the first two quarters of 2014 (block scheduling). Data points included room utilization, case volume, turnaround times, first case on-time starts, same-day cancellations, and after-hours case numbers.
Utilization was defined as room setup, case, cleanup, and turnover for elective cases, Monday through Friday, in ORs 1 to 11.
First case on-time starts were measured as patients in the OR by 7:45 am. Reasons for late starts were recorded, and late starts caused by continuing medical education obligations were excluded.
After-hours surgery was broken down into cases extending after 5 pm, 8 pm, and 11 pm.
Overall case volume increased by 3% from the first half of 2013 to the first half of 2014—from 3,703 cases to 3,909 cases (sidebar, p 19).
This was accomplished with an overall decrease in OR utilization from 71% to 68% (sidebar at left). Average turnaround time remained relatively constant at 40 minutes in 2014 and 41 minutes in 2013.
After block scheduling was implemented, first case on-time starts rose from an average of 83% in 2013 to 91% over the same time frame in 2014. Agency expenditures for the first half of 2014 dropped by 40% compared with the first half of 2013, and same-day surgery cancellations fell from 4.8% in 2013 to 4% in 2014.
Data from the first 6 months of 2013 (prior to block time scheduling) and first 6 months of 2014 (3 months after initiation of block time scheduling) show improvements in (A) room utilization, (B) room turnover, (C) first case on-time starts, and (D) day of surgery cancellations.

Source: Bassett Healthcare, Cooperstown, New York.
When scheduling cases, the salaries of OR staff must be taken into account, so a model that maximizes both overutilization and underutilization should be considered.
For example, Strum et al have shown that optimization of classical utilization did not result in cost efficiency; however, by presenting cost as a function of underutilization versus overutilization, they calculated a minimal cost function based on surgical demand.
By reviewing case logs over a 6-year period and applying their model, they demonstrated substantial cost savings by allocating budgeted OR time based on surgical demand.
Their model used a first-come, first-served model to achieve this. Our model incorporated the same principles by allocating blocks based on historical usage. The decreased use of the OR during late hours shows that block scheduling decreased overutilization, thus reducing overtime pay and staff dissatisfaction caused by having to work late.
Dexter et al have published numerous articles on how to improve OR scheduling and efficiency. In a 1999 statistical analysis, they evaluated variables such as allocated hours of OR time, estimated hours of elective cases, actual hours of elective cases, hours of turnover time, hours of add-on cases, and hours of underutilized time. They concluded that scheduling elective cases carefully to fill all available staffed time was the most effective way to reduce underutilization.
By combining the two approaches described above—allocating budgeted OR time based on surgical demand and filling budgeted OR time with elective cases while making provision for add-on cases—we reduced classically defined OR utilization while increasing case volume. Using a block scheduling system thus improved both underutilization and overutilization at our institution.
This has been particularly important for us as we continue to expand and incorporate new surgeons into our department.
A primary driver of our conversion to block scheduling was turnover among OR nurses and technicians. We believe this was caused in part by unreliable daily schedules that necessitated working overtime and a lack of continuity with specific surgeons and teams. We did not tabulate OR staff turnover, but block scheduling allowed us to reduce our agency staffing by approximately 50%. OR staff are now assigned to particular surgeons consistently on similar days, and overtime has been reduced.
Numerous factors need to be considered when planning a conversion from a first-come, first-served OR booking system to a block schedule system. Using mathematical calculation and a relatively simple set of rules, we successfully converted our scheduling system and improved upon a number of quality metrics. ✥
C. Ross Baldwin, MD, a former surgical resident at Bassett Healthcare, is a general surgeon for the Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium in Anchorage.
David C. Borgstrom, MD, FACS, is chief of the division of general surgery in the department of surgery at West Virginia University School of Medicine in Morgantown.
Nicholas J. Hellenthal, MD, FACS, is chief of the department of surgery at Bassett Healthcare and a urologic oncologist.
Blake J T, Dexter F, Donald J. Operating room managers’ use of integer programming for assigning block time to surgical groups: A case study. Anesth Analg. 2002;94(1):143-148.
Dexter F. Changing allocations of operating room time. Anesth Analg. 2002;94(5):1272-1279.
Dexter F. How to schedule elective surgical cases into specific operating rooms to maximize the efficiency of use of operating room time. Anesth Analg. 2002; 94(4): 933-942.
Dexter F, Epstein R H, Marsh H M. A statistical analysis of weekday operating room anesthesia group staffing costs at nine independently managed surgical suites. Anesth Analg. 2001;92(6):1493-1498.
Dexter F, Macario A, Traub R D, et al. An operating room scheduling strategy to maximize the use of operating room block time: Computer simulation of patient scheduling and survey of patients’ preferences for surgical waiting time. Anesth Analg. 1999;89(1):7-20.
Dexter F, Macario A, Lubarsky D A, et al. Statistical method to evaluate management strategies to decrease variability in operating room utilization: Application of linear statistical modeling and Monte Carlo simulation to operating room management. Anesthesiology. 1999;91(1):262-274.
Dexter F, Macario A. Applications of information systems to operating room scheduling. Anesthesiology. 1996;85(6):1232-1234.
Magerlein J M, Martin J B. Surgical demand scheduling: A review. Health Serv Res. 1978;13(4):418-433.
Ozkarahan I. Allocation of surgical procedures to operating rooms. J Med Syst. 1995;19(4):333-352.
Strum D P, Vargas L G, May J H. Surgical subspecialty block utilization and capacity planning: A minimal cost analysis model. Anesthesiology. 1999;90(4), 1176-1185.