March 1, 2011

New studies on preventing retained sponges

By: OR Manager
Share

Two new independent studies examine the performance of technologies for preventing retained sponges.

In the first study, which tested data-matrix-coded sponges (SurgiCount Safety-Sponge System), none of the sponges were retained out of 1.86 million counted over 18 months. The study conducted at the Mayo Clinic Rochester (MCR) in Minnesota was led by Robert R. Cima, MD, MA.

In the SurgiCount system, each sponge or towel has a unique data-matrix tag. Sponges are counted by scanning them into and out from the sterile field, and the system keeps a running ledger of sponges scanned.

In highlights of the findings:

  • Before implementation, a retained sponge occurred at MCR an average of every 64 days. During the study, no sponges were retained for 87,404 procedures performed over 18 months using the data-matrix-coded sponges.
  • Use of the system did not disrupt workflow or increase case duration. The average time to count a sponge in the same OR during a 4-day learning curve decreased from 11 seconds on day 1 to 5 seconds on day 4, or about the same as counting unmarked sponges.
  • Staff satisfaction with the system was acceptable with a high degree of trust in the system.
  • The researchers concluded that the data-matrix-coded sponge system “appears to be reliable and effective” and “should be considered as an adjunct to standard OR sponge-counting practices.”

The study was conducted in 3 phases. The first assessed the system’s function, efficiency, and ergonomics. The second phase was performed to validate the prior findings and test product improvements. In phase 3, after review of the previous data, the system was implemented in all 128 OR and procedure rooms on the MCR campus in 2009. Evaluation of use, performance, and staff satisfaction were assessed 1 year after implementation.

Radiofrequency sponges

The second study by Victoria Steelman, PhD, RN, CNOR, FAAN, found a system using sponges embedded with radiofrequency chips (RF Surgical Systems) had 100% sensitivity and specificity in detecting the RF sponges through the torsos of subjects of varying body builds, including the morbidly obese. Of the 210 subjects, about half (101) were morbidly obese. In all, 840 readings were taken with no false-positive or false-negative readings.

References

Cima, R R, Kollengode A, Clark J, et al. Using a data-matrix-coded sponge counting system across a surgical practice: Impact after 18 months. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf. 2011;37:51-58.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat