October 1, 2008

OR managers’ salaries increase, but so do their responsibilities

By: Cynthia Saver, RN, MS
Awards  
PDF
Share

Over the past 10 years, OR managers and directors have seen their average annual base salary rise substantially, from $64,543 in 1998 to $102,000 in 2008, but their span of control has also expanded, from an average of 59.5 clinical FTEs in 1998 to 98.9 FTEs this year.

OR managers and directors now receive an average total compensation package of $124,000 and oversee an average annual operating budget of $21.8 million.

Most leaders in both hospital ORs and ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) like their jobs, scoring their satisfaction an average of 3.9 (out of a possible 5) for those in hospitals and 4.1 for those in ASCs. Retirement still looms large for a management workforce with an average age of 52.3 years for managers and directors in hospitals and 51 years for managers in ASCs.

Those are highlights from the 18th annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. The survey was mailed in April to 800 OR Manager subscribers in hospital OR management positions, with a response rate of 39%. The margin of error is ± 4.8 at the 95% confidence level. A separate survey was sent to managers in ASCs (see page 31 for a complete report). ReadexResearch conducted both surveys. Results from the staffing portion of the survey appeared in the September OR Manager.

Hospital-based OR managers and directors entered the realm of the 6-digit salary this year by earning an average of $102,000, up from $99,000 in 2007. Salaries are highest in the West ($112,000), with the other regions of the country similar to each other. Those in teaching hospitals earn an average of $16,000 more than their community hospital counterparts. Salary increases as the number of ORs managed increases and when managers and directors oversee multiple departments at more than one facility.

Those with the title of administrator or administrative director make an average of $115,000, directors average $100,000, and nurse managers $87,000.

Respondents report their last salary increase averaged 4.3%, the same as in 2007, with the West and the Northeast receiving slightly more.

Raises by region
West 4.5%
Northeast 4.5%
South 4.3%
Midwest 4.2%

Total compensation

When bonuses, insurance, pension, and other benefits are added, the average compensation is $124,000 ($121,00 in 2007). Nearly one-fourth (22%) of respondents earn total compensation of $150,000 or more, while 3% make less than $70,000. The most common benefits include:

Health insurance 95%
Life insurance 93%
Dental insurance 90%
401(k) retirement plan 88%
Tuition reimbursement 84%
Disability insurance 80%
Eye care 66%
Educational benefits 66%
Dependent health insurance 66%
Pensions 53%

All respondents receive paid time off, including vacation, sick time, and holidays, with an average of 30.3 days. Health insurance coverage for dependents was significantly lower than last year’s 75%.

Half of OR managers and directors receive either bonus or profit sharing as part of their total compensation package. In all, 40% received a bonus or profit sharing in the past 12 months, with an average amount of $6,030. Nearly one-quarter (23%) of these monetary awards were $10,000 or above, with 3% of respondents taking home $25,000 or more.

Monetary incentives are more common for administrators and for those overseeing a higher number of ORs.

Only about a third (34%) were eligible for an incentive bonus in 1998, compared to 40% in 2008. That jump is less impressive than it appears, because 40% were also eligible for bonuses 5 years ago.

Vacancies for OR management

Though there are anecdotal reports of large numbers of vacancies for OR managers and directors, only 6% of respondents report management positions are vacant. The average length of a vacancy is 9.3 months. Just 3% say an interim person fills the manager or director position, with an average tenure of 8.9 months.

In all, 6% are actively seeking a new job, while 18% are strongly considering a job search. This is consistent by job title and the number of ORs managed. OR managers and directors in teaching hospitals (11% vs 5% for community hospitals) are more likely to be considering or seeking a job change.

About your organization

About three-fourths (73%) of respondents work in community hospitals and 21% in teaching hospitals. Most (89%) are from nonprofit facilities.

More than half (54%) work in a single freestanding hospital with an average of 206 beds, and 43% are part of a multicampus system with an average of 1,000 beds.

About your role

OR managers and directors continue to have a wide scope of responsibility. Here is a closer look at titles, reporting structure, and elements reflecting span of control.

Title and work area. Most respondents report their title as director (41%), followed by administrator or administrative director (30%), and nurse manager (26%).

The title of the managed work area varies. Most administrators or administrative directors (16%) oversee “perioperative services,” while most directors (20%) manage “surgical services,” and most nurse managers (14%) oversee the “operating room.”

Average annual salary and total compensation

By number of ORs Annual salary Total compensation
1-4 ORs $83,000 $102,000
5-9 ORs $97,000 $114,000
10+ ORs $111,000 $136,000
By facility type
Community $97,000 $119,000
Teaching $113,000 $139,000
By title
Admin/admin director $115,000 $140,000
Director $100,000 $122,000
Nurse manager $87,000 $106,000
By scope of role
Manage:
OR in one hospital $89,000 $110,000
OR + other depts/one hospital $101,000 $122,000
ORs in multiple facilities $122,000 $149,000
OR + other depts/mult facilities $131,000 $157,000

How many sites do you manage?

By title
Admin director Director Manager
OR only within one hospital 3% 13% 36%
OR & other depts within one hospital 82% 77% 62%
OR only at multiple sites 1% 1% 0%
OR & other depts at multiple sites 10% 9% 0%

Reporting structure. Two-thirds of respondents (66%) report to nursing administration, while 30% report to hospital administration.

Those in community hospitals are more likely (68%) to report to nursing administration compared with teaching hospitals (56%).

Beyond the OR. Most OR managers and directors have responsibility beyond the OR, with 77% of directors and 62% of nurse managers managing the OR department and other departments in one hospital. Just 7% manage OR departments and other departments at multiple facilities.

Respondents oversee an average of 5.9 departments or services, with 3% having 15 or more.

Money talk. OR managers and directors head up large businesses. On average, respondents oversee an annual operating budget of $21.8 million, with 41% reporting $10 million or more. Surprisingly, 19% did not know the size of the operating budget.

Has surgical volume increased?

Which other departments report to you?

Postanesthesia care 75%
Central processing 67%
Outpatient/same-day surgery 64%
GI/endoscopy 59%
Preadmission services 54%
Anesthesia support personnel 51%
Materials management for OR 45%
Pain management 22%
Perfusion services 16%
CRNAs 12%
Cardiac cath lab 6%
Inpatient unit 5%
Emergency room/ trauma services 3%
ICU 3%
Others mentioned: Scheduling (2%), respiratory (2%).

One-third plan to retire within 6 years

OR managers and directors are a veteran group. By the end of 2014 (only 6 years away), 36% expect to be retired. More than half in this year’s survey have been in nursing for 30 or more years, and 56% have been in their position for 5 years or more. In all, 38% are 55 or older, with only 12% under 45.

How many clinical FTEs are under your span of control?

By type of facility By number of ORs By title
Community Teaching 1-4 5-9 10+ Admin director Director Manager
Clinical 82.0 150.1 33.8 64.4 147.3 140.1 94.1 53.1
Nonclinical 17.2 37.1 4.2 12.1 35.3 33.6 17.7 11.1

What is the annual budget for the ORs (in millions)?

By type of facility By number of ORs By title
Community Teaching 1-4 5-9 10+ Admin director Director Manager
Operating $16.1 $37.6 $3.4 $7.0 $36.2 $34.6 $15.5 $9.4
Capital $1.5 $2.4 $0.4 $1.0 $2.3 $1.9 $1.8 $1.3
Personnel $4.0 $11.4 $1.1 $2.6 $8.7 $8.0 $4.5 $3.3

The average operating budget for those in teaching hospitals is more than double that of community hospitals. Administrators and administrative directors have the highest operating budget by title ($34.6 million), more than double the average for directors ($15.5 million) and nearly quadruple the average for managers ($9.4 million).

Average annual OR budget managed
Operating $21.8 million
Capital $1.7 million
Personnel $5.5 million

People power. OR managers and directors have a big responsibility for people, directly or indirectly overseeing an average of 98.9 clinical and 21.9 non-clinical FTEs, for a total average FTE of 120.8. One-quarter manage 150 or more FTEs, while 14% are responsible for 1 to 29 FTEs.

Long hours. Given the scope of responsibilities, it’s not surprising that respondents report working an average of 53 hours a week. More than a fourth (27%) say their workweek is 60 hours or more. Only 6% of respondents work 40 to 44 hours on average.

Purchasing power. Hospital-based OR managers have plenty of purchasing clout. The vast majority influence the selection and purchase of OR supplies and equipment (91%) and capital equipment (83%).

That involvement comes mainly through membership on a decision-making committee or team (61%) or a value-analysis team (49%). Value-analysis teams are far more common (60%) in organizations with 10 or more ORs than those with 5-9 or 1-4 ORs, at 39% and 37% respectively.

In all, 39% report they are the primary decision maker on purchases, with half of those managing 1 to 4 ORs. About a third (34%) of respondents serve in an advisory capacity.

Three-fourths have computer in each OR

Automation is well established in the OR. Only 20 facilities responding do not have an OR information system, and 11 of these are small ORs with 1 to 4 rooms.

More than three-fourths now have computers in each OR, where they are used for intraoperative patient documentation, PACS (imaging), and other functions. Automated inventory control still lags, with only slightly more than one-fourth using computers for this purpose. Popular applications for information systems are communication (52%) and patient tracking (42%).

The computer in each OR is used for …

Intraop patient documentation 80%
PACS (imaging) 79%
Laboratory data 72%
Order entry 55%
Policy & procedure manual 52%
Communication 52%
Patient charges 51%
Patient tracking 42%
Inventory control 29%

By facility type

Community Teaching
72% 94%

By number of ORs

1-4 5-9 10+
56% 71% 86%

About your OR

Respondents oversee an average of 13.6 staffed ORs, and those with the title of administrator or administrative director manage the most.

Average number of ORs managed by title
Administrator/administrative director 19.7
Director 10.6
Nurse manager 11.2

The average annual case volume is 9,470 and, not surprisingly, size correlates with volume.

Annual surgical volume by number of ORs managed
1-4 3,220
5-9 6,250
10+ 13,760

Most adding or renovating ORs

As in 2007, nearly half (46%) of respondents are adding new ORs or planning to add ORs within the next 12 months. More than half (53%) are renovating or plan to renovate in the next 12 months. Leading reasons for adding ORs are to increase capacity or accommodate new technology. Top reasons for renovating are to update the facility, accommodate new technology, improve efficiencies, and add capacity/space.

Surgical volume continues to increase for many ORs, with 39% (40% in 2007) of respondents reporting a higher number of surgical procedures in the past 12 months. About a fourth (24%) report a decrease, while 36% say volume has stayed about the same. The growth in volume is slower than in years past; increases of 71% were reported in 2000 and 69% in 1999.

Staff incentives. More than a fourth of OR managers and directors (26%) say their facility has a plan for giving its staff financial rewards for performance improvements or cost reductions. Community hospitals are more likely to have these plans than teaching hospitals (27% vs 20%). Surprisingly, organizations with 1 to 4 ORs are more likely to offer financial rewards (33%) compared to larger organizations (16% for 5-9 ORs and 28% for 10+ ORs).

About you

The vast majority of OR managers and directors are women (86%) who are RNs (96%).

Age and retirement. The aging management workforce continues to be a concern, with an average age of 52.3 years. That’s 5 years older than the 47.1 reported in 1998 and 2 years older than in 2003. Only 12% are 44 years old or younger.

What’s your OR’s greatest achievement?

OR managers and directors have a lot to be proud of. Upgraded facilities and equipment led the list of achievements for survey respondents, followed closely by safety and quality improvements, better operational effectiveness, and efforts to develop the staff. Here is a sampling of comments.

Hospital OR managers and directors

What are you most proud of in your OR?

  1. Upgraded facilities and equipment
    • $27.9 million OR redesign with electronic communication, improvement of throughput, increased patient and MD satisfaction.
    • Renovation/new construction of 5 digital state-of-the-art ORs.
    • Improved instrument tracking and turnaround by replacing 3 sterilizers and deploying tracking system.
    • Implemented a new computer system that includes all surgical areas: Preop, PACU, GI, etc.
  2. Improved patient safety and quality
    • Surgical site infection rate is 0.9%. 100% compliance of surgical site marking by only physicians. 100% timeout compliance and documentation. Crew resource management for some specialties.
    • Going to 100% on SCIP compliance from 50%.
    • Introduction of highly reliable surgical teams, briefings/debriefings.
    • Two mechanisms to improve communication: (1) with PACU families of endoscopy patients and (2) morning report in OR.
  3. Better-functioning ORs
    • Improved block scheduling, which has increased surgeon satisfaction and allowed for arrival and OR time for 5 new surgeons.
    • First-case on-time starts from 20% to 80%+.
    • Decreased turnover times by 45%; increased physician satisfaction.
  4. People power
    • No use of travelers. OR training program for new grads and RNs without OR experience has brought staffing to zero vacancies.
    • Recruitment/creative scheduling to reduce call requirements.
    • Developed specialty teams. Improved room turnover time from 47 to 28 minutes.

… and what do you hope to achieve this year?

  1. Expand, upgrade facilities and equipment
    • Add additional capacity through addition of new advanced endoscopy and neurosurgical ORs.
    • Renovation, growing volumes. Become MIS (minimally invasive surgery) center of excellence.
    • Successful planning for renovation of 14 current ORs and addition of 11 more, with 11 “shelled in.”
    • Add robotic surgery.
  2. Develop people
    • Staff incentive program for meeting growth, efficiency, decrease material costs.
    • Achieve magnet designation; develop staff to look more into evidence-based practice and AORN standards to change their practice.
    • I’m retiring but wish my successor well since I’ve trained him for 3 years and laid the foundation.
    • Cross-train team within the department and with 2 other departments.
  3. Meet strategic goals
    • Want to add more surgeons to the staff, especially general.
    • Regain market to improve volume by 15% over last year.
    • Continue to build volume. Continue to develop new product lines.
  4. Better-functioning ORs
    • Working to see that senior management sees the significance surgical care plays in the hospital’s bottom line.
    • Implement "fast tracking" to decrease turnover time between back-to-back cases.
    • Improve efficiency in OR to increase volume and decrease turnover time.

The average year planned for retirement is 2018, a mere decade away. In all, 44% of the respondents will retire between 2010 and 2019.

Leaders who retire will take along years of experience. Managers and directors have been in their current positions an average of 7.3 years.

Education. Managers and directors are most likely to have a bachelor’s degree as their highest level of education, while administrators and administrative directors typically have a master’s degree.

Graduate education has risen over the past years. In all, 40% of respondents report their highest degree as a master’s, compared with 37% in 2003 and 31% in 1998. The most common master’s degree is the MS/MSN (22%), followed by an MBA (6%) and other master’s (22%). Just 1% of respondents have a doctorate in nursing.

Most common degree required by position
Administrator/administrative director:
 Master’s 63%
Director:
 Bachelor’s 71%
Nurse manager:
 Bachelor’s 85%

More than three-fourths (77%) of managers and directors say a specific degree is required for their position. The most common degree required is the bachelor’s (61%), but the requirement varies by type of facility. While a bachelor’s degree is the most common requirement for community hospitals (67%) teaching hospitals are most likely to specify a master’s degree (53%).

—Cynthia Saver, RN, MS

Cynthia Saver is a freelance writer in Columbia, Maryland.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat