With hospitals under ever greater economic pressure, perioperative managers are expected to hew closely to staffing productivity targets, meaning they must match staffing as closely as possible to the hours of surgery actually performed. They’re also expected to grow surgical volume. Hospitals’ revenue depends on it.
To grow volume, ORs need to attract surgeons who will bring cases with positive margins. And to do that, they need open time in the schedule—time that is staffed and available to be booked.
“Every OR has to be growing volume, or their hospital is going to be out of business. As costs are escalating, and reimbursement is declining, if you’re not growing volume, you’re losing money compared to last year,” says Randy Heiser, MA, president and CEO of Sullivan Healthcare Consulting, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
“You cannot run an operating room that is 100% full and hope to grow your volume.”
That’s a tough spot for perioperative managers—grow your volume but meet your staffing target, goals that are mutually exclusive. Failure to meet staffing targets can lead to a negative performance review.
This relentless focus on productivity standards, in Heiser’s view, is diverting managers from focusing on the OR’s primary customers—patients and surgeons.
It also hurts morale, he says, because when OR time is unfilled, staff are often sent home early, depriving them of a full paycheck. Some ORs opt to use part-timers, but that entails more handoffs, which is a patient safety hazard, and requires more resources for orientation and education.
The problem, he says, is that finance departments apply the same types of productivity standards to ORs that they do to nursing units, which doesn’t work.
In one example, a tertiary hospital in a competitive market had 4 rivals within a short distance of each other. About 80% of the surgeons worked at more than one hospital, and about 30% worked at all 4, so it was easy for a hospital to lose market share quickly.
The hospital had made a deliberate decision to run the OR at about 65% prime-time utilization in an effort to capture more volume from surgeons.
But the finance department saw that the OR’s productivity was at 6.05 worked hours per hour of surgery for direct-care staff, including RNs, surgical technologists, and RN first assistants. That compared to the target of 3.79 worked hours per hour of surgery.
The finance department told the surgical services administrator the department was overstaffed. But the administrator responded that to meet the target, she would have to cut the number of rooms running almost in half, which was inconsistent with the objective of attracting surgeons.
The final staffing standard, at 6.53 worked hours per hour of surgery for all intraoperative staff, incorporated the strategic goals of the perioperative program and provided staffing for a targeted utilization of 60%.
Addressing this dilemma takes a strategic approach by perioperative leaders and senior executives that is based on an OR coverage plan, Heiser suggests. The coverage plan includes open time and guides the staffing. The plan is developed by the surgical services governing body, which should include leaders from nursing, surgery, and anesthesia as well as a member from the senior administration such as the CEO or COO. The governing body sets the OR’s strategic direction and develops and enforces policies. (For more on OR governance, see the June 2010 OR Manager.)
Here’s an example of what a coverage plan might include:
• 10 ORs will be staffed for 8 hours from 7:30 am to 3:30 pm Monday through Friday.
• The target utilization will be 85%, with 75% of the capacity for surgeon elective blocks, allowing for open, nonblocked OR time.
• The productivity standard for direct-care staff will be based on the target utilization. That might mean, for example, increasing the productivity target by 25% to 30% or even 100%, depending on much competition there is for surgeons in the local market.
• On the day of surgery, the person running the schedule will make the decision to fill any remaining open time by slotting in add-on cases and/or allowing some surgeons to “flip” rooms. In flipping, a second room is set up before a surgeon finishes the previous case, allowing the surgeon to move directly to the next case.
Many ORs use flipping as a way of improving customer service to surgeons. Though flipping requires more staff and thus can cause the OR to fall short of the productivity target, it can pay off if it attracts enough additional well-paying cases. Flipping should be a business decision guided by clear, consistent policies and viewed as a tactic that is in line with the hospital’s business objectives and strategic plan. (For more, see December 2010 OR Manager.)
If some time is unfilled, the staff isn’t automatically sent home unless nothing can be done to fill the time.
Having an executive from the C-suite on the OR’s governing body is a major asset, Heiser says. The executive serves as a liaison with the senior administration and the finance department. That can help to reconcile the objectives of meeting staffing benchmarks and having open time to recruit surgeons.
The executive, for example, could go to finance, explain the OR’s coverage plan, and say: “We need to suspend the productivity standards for the OR. Or we need to modify them so they are consistent with our growth goals.”
Raising the standard doesn’t mean loosening up on management of the daily schedule or hiring new staff, he points out. He says it can even reduce some case times because the staff is not as inclined to slow their pace so they can stay and be paid for a full 8 hours.
“This actually improves morale because people who are full time are actually working full time.” ❖
Patterson P. Flipping ORs: Does this common practice make business sense? OR Manager. 2010; 26(12):1, 6-8.
Patterson P. Is your OR leadership team up to health care reform challenges? OR Manager. 2010; 26(6):1, 6-7.