For BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, and people of color) leaders who are healthcare professionals, ensuring the delivery of quality care is often made more difficult by the racial or ethnic bias they may encounter within their organizations. In this article, five BIPOC perioperative leaders share their experiences and offer advice for BIPOC nurses aspiring to leadership:
• Katie Boston-Leary, PhD, MBA, MHA, RN, NEA-BC, CCTP, speaker, consultant, certified executive coach, formerly chief nursing officer, University of Maryland Prince George’s Hospital Center, Cheverly, Maryland
• Brian Dawson, MSN, RN-BC, CNOR, CSSM, system VP of perioperative services, CommonSpirit Health, Chicago
• Santino Estrera, MBA, MHA, RN, CNOR, director of perioperative services, Mount Sinai Health System, New York City
• Cheryl Evans, MSM, RN, CNOR, administrative director, surgical services, Bon Secours Mercy Health, Cincinnati
• Marlow Levy, MBA, MSM, RN, FACHE, VP of operations, UPMC Hamot, Erie, Pennsylvania.
Boston-Leary: I’m able to think on my feet and process divergent pieces of information in enormous quantities to make key decisions. I feel it’s important to extend myself beyond the patient’s journey in the perioperative setting. It’s standard to call patients on the outpatient side, but I think it’s important to do that on the inpatient side, too. Do a round or give them a call to see how they’re doing.
In the OR, it’s quite easy to feel removed because interactions are limited for the circulator and surgical techs. The best thing for everyone in that room is to have a relationship with the patient on the table. I like to create standards for my team that encourage them to see the patient holistically, which helps elevate them beyond the body part they’re working on.
Dawson: My leadership philosophy is inspired by the eight tenets of Bushido, the code of conduct for Samurais: justice, courage, benevolence, politeness, truthfulness, honor, loyalty, and self-control.
Through the guidance of some great mentors and information gleaned from leadership courses, I built a great leadership toolkit. I used what I created when I was selected to be the CEO of the US Naval Hospital in Okinawa, Japan. As a leader, if everything is about you, you will eventually fail. If it’s about your people, then your people will carry you to success.
Estrera: My style has always been presenting a vision, identifying where we are currently as a team and organization, and where we need to be, and then figuring out a way to close the gap. I hold the people who report to me accountable by encouraging them to come up with solutions and help execute those goals. My role is to give them the resources, guidance, support, and coaching they need along the way.
Evans: I view myself as a team player, one of those leaders who believes in getting into scrubs to see what is happening with my team and my entire department. I make it a point to be visible so that they know in addition to being their leader, I am also knowledgeable about what they do.
Levy: My style is process improvement-focused, forward-leaning, innovative, fluid, and servant-oriented. I am a cultural disruptor. The COVID-19 crisis is blanketing the industry with uncertainty, and social/political unrest is exploding throughout the country. Our patients are navigating threats to their health, financial stability, and civil liberties. I’m putting every effort into maintaining surgical operations at full capacity with minimum disruption, and recovering our financial losses by bringing our patients back because community trust has been eroded in many areas.
Boston-Leary: A huge part of your success as a leader in perioperative services is for surgeons to respect you. You can be the best leader to your nurses and team, manage an excellent budget, and have great relationships with everyone else. But it’s potentially dire if there is tension between a nurse leader and the surgeon.
Dawson: The first barrier I experienced as a nurse was being male. The majority of nurses are women, and I didn’t get the same “seat at the table” as more male-dominated areas of medicine. Then add to that being a Black male.
In terms of race, I think a great deal of bias is unconscious. As humans, we all flock to what we’re accustomed to—our racial, cultural, and regional tribes. The media, TV, news, movies, and social media all shape our beliefs about other groups, as well. As a result of those factors, it’s difficult for people who are not BIPOC to understand how we feel in certain situations.
Certainly, at times it takes a while longer for me to be accepted or to prove myself than it would if I weren’t a Black male. I have learned to do this dance where, professionally, I must run faster, jump higher, and be 10 times better than my white peers to be accepted.
Estrera: There are cliques of a sort along the lines of race, culture, religion, and ethnicity. I’ve seen surgeons wanting to work with males on bigger cases. And it’s not a situation where they want familiarity or more experience, it’s just gender. As a leader, I discourage that. So, I want to see more inclusion and diversification with certain clinical roles because there is a tendency to profile certain job types or roles in the hospital.
Evans: When I was in the military, if an incident occurred, it was rectified quickly. Rank had privileges and respect, and you didn’t have to constantly prove yourself.
When I entered the civilian sector, it was a different world. At some facilities, when I reported an incident, it was handled quickly. But at many other organizations, my concerns were completely brushed aside. I think it made me stronger as a leader in the end because I became more aware of my surroundings and learned when to speak up and say when something was right or wrong.
Levy: At the professional level, most incidents of discrimination or racial bias are not explicit. They are indirect in expression and implicit in execution. No one is going to say, “I didn’t hire you because you don’t look like me.” But you hear dog whistles like, “not a good fit” or “you’re overqualified,” or you’re accused of being angry and aggressive.
When I played football in high school, during practice we would hit the blocking dummies and the coach would yell: “Keep your feet moving and push forward,” or “Grab their jersey and spin around them.” He was training us to drive through the defender or go around them. I’ve adopted that type of psychological maneuvering to overcome racial barriers and bigotry. I move forward toward my goals or go around them.
Boston-Leary: You need to be confident and build on that constantly. Never feel like you’ve “made it.” Sometimes when you show up as a BIPOC woman in a leadership role, you must jump higher and go faster. It’s hard, but it also gives you staying power.
Understand the culture of the organization you’re in. Find out where the landmines are—the history of relationships between surgeons and staff. Make yourself accessible, and build trust. Know what is happening around you so that you’re not hearing about a problem from the CEO after the fact.
As a career coach, one of my goals is to help people understand that if you’re not careful, work can become your entire world. I had a support system with my family that helped me raise my son, who is a successful dentist now. But I shudder to think of where he would be today as a Black male if not for that support.
Dawson: Find a mentor and listen to their advice, become nationally certified in your clinical specialty, obtain advanced degrees, and learn the rules of the game—especially unwritten rules that are not obvious. Make connections with and network with other BIPOC leaders.
When I got in the door, I put my foot in to hold the door open, so that both BIPOCs and women could get opportunities to become healthcare leaders, too. Others may not have had the money or the guidance to go straight to college from high school as I did, so I didn’t pass up any opportunities to help someone else climb the ladder into positions of leadership. As nurse leaders, we need to do the same and mentor our young staff nurses.
Estrera: Be adaptable to change. I am mentoring a lot of millennial staff, and they are sometimes very eager to jump into a leadership role.
A staffer who graduated from a master’s program asked me how to become a manager. My advice would be to get your credentials, but also get the actual experience. Become an informal leader within your team or unit, and shadow leaders so you can see what a leadership role entails. Having an MSN doesn’t mean you can automatically become a leader. Be patient, find mentors, understand what you really want to do in your career, continue to grow, and research.
Evans: Surround yourself with leaders who see your true value and performance, and who want to promote you. I have worked at places where I knew I was not appreciated. The greatness of perioperative leadership is that there are many positions out there for you. Find a mentor. They don’t have to be BIPOC; I have been mentored and supported by people who were not BIPOC. They need to be someone with whom you feel comfortable enough to have open and honest conversations.
Levy: Set clear goals for your career by being specific and developing timelines and measurable milestones. When you hit a barrier, drive in or go around, but always keep moving forward. Find mentors to support you and sponsors to help you, and protect your brand. Commit to a long game, and be loyal to your ambitions. ✥
–Carisa Brewster is a writer and media relations representative for Whitman Partners in Portland, Oregon.
National Black Nurses Association, https://www.nbna.org.
National Diversity Council, www.nationaldiversitycouncil.org.
The Society for Diversity, https://www.societyfordiversity.org.