January 20, 2016

Preparation, policy compliance key to positive survey outcome

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN
Share

Preparation for a visit from the Joint Commission or the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services is key to a positive survey outcome. “There is nothing mysterious about Joint Commission or CMS compliance,” says John Rosing, MHA, FACHE, vice president and principal, Patton Healthcare Consulting, Naperville, Illinois. Ensuring compliance involves setting up in advance policies, practices, procedures, and tools, and then educating staff and validating their competency on those policies and practices.

Often managers educate staff on a topic and give a post-test to validate competency, but they don’t go back to see if best practices are consistently being followed, says Rosing.

Left to their own devices, staff are prone to make up their own methods—a little workaround that they think is quicker, easier, and safer—and they end up with a variation.

Surveyors are looking for standardization, not variation, says Rosing.

“That’s what they’re all about, and that’s what usually trips hospitals up. There may be variation right under your nose that you don’t pick up on, but the surveyor will see it right away.”

 

Where to focus

There are 1,800 scorable elements of performance in the Joint Commission manual, but it seems 90% of the findings are on only about 25 of those elements.

One strategy to get ready for a survey is to focus on the priority issues, such as:

• top scored issues (sidebar, p 8)

• National Patient Safety Goals

• new standards or frequently asked questions

• previously scored issues

• issues that are CMS condition-level risks.

“If you previously scored on an issue, that’s an indication it might be an issue that’s hard to perfect or master in your organization. You want to make sure that you do everything you can to eliminate that potential,” says Rosing.

Issues related to infection prevention that get CMS condition-level findings are serious findings in the eyes of both CMS and the Joint Commission and result in follow-up surveys. “You have to make sure those issues are taken care of as well,” he says.

There are also “low-hanging fruit” issues that fall into the surveyor’s lap—things that are easily detected and irrefutable, notes Rosing. For example, a manager and a surveyor both see a stretcher or cart that was left in front of the medical gas valve shutoff box, and the surveyor writes it down as a finding. Another example is an oxygen tank that’s not properly secured.

“Focus on these issues, and fix them long before the survey,” Rosing advises.

 

Complete and accurate medical record

John Rosing, MHA, FACHE

John Rosing, MHA, FACHE

The focus of this top issue is whether entries into the chart are signed, dated, and timed. “This is decreasing as a finding because more documentation is electronic and automatically dated and timed, but it is still an issue,” says Rosing.

One problem with an electronic medical record (EMR) is that it dates and times every entry at the moment the entry happens, and this trips people up if the entries are out of the proper sequence, he says.

For example, surveyors will check to see if the time entry for starting an IV in the preoperative holding area comes after the time entry for the order to start the IV. If the order isn’t recorded first, that is considered starting an IV without an order.

Because there is some element of anticipation that nothing will go wrong during a routine procedure, surgeons, anesthesiologists, and nurses may be inclined to document their postoperative evaluations and write postoperative orders preoperatively. If the surveyors find this, they can go to an accreditation participation requirement and cite for fraudulent or fabricated documentation, which is a serious finding. Likewise, postoperative orders must be based on the patient’s condition postoperatively.

“It is acceptable to start a postoperative note before the case, adding elements such as demographic or preoperative diagnostic information, but make sure the final completed note has a final time documented electronically by the author that falls after the time the case is completed,” says Rosing.

Another problem with the EMR is the copy-and-paste or cloning of records. This has become an unintended and potentially dangerous consequence of the EMR whereby totally erroneous or no longer valid information can be carried forward as a current assessment.

“In addition to creating a potentially dangerous patient safety risk, the practice is fraught with fraud and abuse potential because CMS is going to look at this and say, ‘If you’ve cloned an H&P, and then charged Medicare for a new H&P, you’ve committed fraud.’ Hearing this will likely grab the attention of your physicians,” says Rosing.

The history and physical also remains a problem. It can’t be older than 30 days, and if done prior to the day of the procedure it needs to be updated on the day of the procedure so that any changes in the patient’s condition can be identified by the surgeon and taken into account to decide whether to continue with the procedure or change the procedure.

This update requirement has caused much of the concern with H&Ps, says Rosing. Games are played to get around it, such as sending the H&P over at 4 pm the night before a surgery that is scheduled for 10 am the next morning.

Surgeons do this because they believe, erroneously, that if the H&P is filed within 24 hours of the surgery, no update is required, he says.

“The problem is, there is no such thing about ‘less than 24 hours’ in the regulation,” Rosing explains. The regulation says when a patient is admitted to the hospital, the admitting physician has 24 hours to complete the H&P for the admission. “This is not about surgery or a procedure, it’s just about being admitted to the hospital; the physician has 24 hours to do the H&P or update an H&P after the patient is admitted,” he says.

If a patient is coming in for a surgical procedure, the H&P has to be done no more than 30 days before admission. If the H&P is done anytime in the 30 days before admission, the physician must update it within 24 hours of admission, or prior to an invasive procedure on the day of the procedure, whichever comes first.

“As long as there is wording in the chart that the physician reviewed the H&P and examined the patient and there are no changes, or if there are changes, what the changes are, you won’t get cited,” says Rosing.

 

Medication storage

This issue has been on the top 10 list for years, says Rosing. It includes medication management such as the temperature at which the medication is maintained, whether it is a medication that requires refrigeration, or whether it is a medication of any type that is not properly secured in the hospital. This also includes fluid warmers.

Refrigerators and warmers need to have a thermometer in them that is monitored on a daily basis. There needs to be a recording of the temperature and documentation that action was taken if the temperature was outside of the desired range.

The action could be as simple as rechecking the temperature in 30 minutes as the first step or perhaps a second step of calling the pharmacy to determine whether the medication in the refrigerator remains safe to use.

“More and more, medication refrigerators are tied into an ADM (eg, Pyxis or an AccuDose) dispensing machine, and the temperature is automatically recorded and monitored remotely by the pharmacy, but it’s still an issue,” says Rosing.

Problems with warmers include maximum temperature and beyond-use date duration. Manufacturer instructions for irrigation fluids have different desired temperature maximums and length of time they can be in the warmer. Warmers should be set no higher than 104ºF, and if they are not electronically monitored for temperature, there should be a manual method in use. The beyond-use date should be put on the bottle or overpouch if the fluid is in bags.

The blanket warming portion of the warmer should be at 130ºF, according to AORN and the ECRI Institute. However, these warmers can go up to 160ºF, and some hospitals use this higher temperature for blankets.

Because there is not a clear-cut standard for this, Rosing suggests creating a risk assessment showing the pros and cons of warming blankets to a range from 130 to 160ºF and concluding at the end of the risk assessment that the temperature may reach 160ºF without adverse consequences.

“The surveyors are taught that if they encounter a well-created, well-contemplated risk assessment, they should accept the decision of the hospital and not impose their own expectations,” says Rosing.

Improper labeling of medication, including no beyond-use date and expired or damaged medications that are not promptly removed from the area, is another problem. Some anesthesia carts, such as difficult airway carts that aren’t often used, may be vulnerable to this expired medication finding.

Any medication that is not discarded after opening has to be dated with a new beyond-use date. Injectable medications have a 28-day lifespan once the vial is opened. Non-injectables are not held to the 28-day rule, and generally are good until the manufacturer’s expiration date after opening.

Outbreaks of bloodborne pathogen transmission have been traced to the insertion of a used needle back into a vial to draw more medication and storage of that vial in a drawer or cabinet for use on another patient. Therefore, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says multidose vials should not be allowed for use in patient care areas, which include ORs, exam rooms, and procedure rooms.

“You can use a multidose vial in those settings, but you have to treat them as if they were single-dose vials. In other words, you throw them out even if there’s medication remaining in the vial,” says Rosing.

Other medication findings include spiking IV bags or bottles within 1 hour of use.

“It is a common practice to spike 20 IVs at the beginning of the day, if there are 20 patients coming into the preop holding area,” notes Rosing.

The problem comes with the simple practice of spiking an IV bag or bottle because under USP 797 guidelines this is considered low-risk compounding outside of the pharmacy, and the fluid then has only a 1-hour shelf life from the time it is spiked (ie, 1 hour to begin infusing the fluid). By spiking 20 IV bags or bottles at the beginning of the day, the first couple of patients might have their IVs infusing within the hour, but by the third or fourth bag, the hour has run out.

Similarly, drawing medication into a syringe is considered compounding, and the clinician also must begin using it within an hour.

 

Verbal, standing orders

The Joint Commission says when required by law or regulation, verbal or telephone orders are authenticated within a specified time frame (ie, 48 hours), and the authentication is timed.

The CMS language says the verbal order is authenticated “promptly.” When asked to define “promptly,” CMS has said they mean the next time the physician who gave the order is writing in or making an entry into that record. However, “we’ve not yet seen CMS or state surveyors cite to this level of conformance,” says Rosing.

For standing medication orders, CMS has adopted a position that the medical executive committee, chief nurse executive, and chief pharmacist can oversee these orders.

“The purpose of the three roofs is to keep the process of creating standing orders honest,” notes Rosing.

CMS uses the term “standing order” to describe those limited circumstances, where in order to provide timely and necessary care to a patient, the nurse can administer medication per this order without having first talked to a physician.

This is in contrast to a preprinted postoperative order set, which the nurse can’t implement without having first talked to the physician and gotten an order to execute the order set. When permission is given by the physician, the order then becomes a verbal order.

 

Infection prevention

Infections develop in about 1 to 3 out of every 100 patients who have surgery, and an estimated 40% to 60% of those infections are preventable, says Rosing.

An infection prevention finding often generates a CMS condition-level deficiency, which triggers a follow-up survey within 45 days. “You always want to avoid a condition-level finding, and infection prevention is one of the areas where they come up,” he says. It is very important to have an infection prevention program that includes:

• a designated infection control officer with qualifications

• practices and policies based on nationally recognized guidelines and standards

• infection control risk assessments related to any construction going on

• air exchange rates for airborne isolation

• policies governing an antibiotic stewardship program.

CMS has published three worksheets, one of which is on infection control. These were sent to all state surveyors, and they are referring to this document during surveys, going through it point by point, says Rosing.

The Joint Commission has said they are not going to do that because they think their standards already include what is in the worksheets. However, says Rosing, the infection control worksheet is a great tool to use for self-assessment (https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Provider-Enrollment-and-Certification/Survey-CertificationGenInfo/Downloads/Survey-and-Cert-Letter-15-12-Attachment-1.pdf). It will help hospital staff identify when and where there are compliance issues. ✥

 

Reference

Rosing J R. Friend or foe? Preparing for your Joint Commission survey. Workshop. OR Manager Conference 2015.


Top 10 scored standards for 2014

• Complete/accurate medical record (RC.01.01.01—66%)

• Maintain egress (LS.02.01.20—56%)

• Fire protection features maintained (LS.02.01.10—52%)

• Fire protection features maintained to protect patients (LS.02.01.30—45%)

• Maintain fire safety equipment (EC.02.03.05—40%)

• Medical equipment infection risk (IC.02.02.01—36%)

• Assess and reassess per time frames (PC.01.02.03—34%)

• Medication storage (MM.03.01.01—33%)

• Verbal orders (RC.02.03.07—32%)

• Maintain system for extinguishing fire (LS.03.01.35—31%)

—Joint Commission. Top standards compliance issues for 2014. Joint Commission Perspectives. 2015;35(4):1-8.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat