How can OR managers better prepare staff to handle crisis situations? How can they encourage teamwork? Increasingly, OR leaders are turning to simulation to answer those questions.
OR leaders who think they can’t afford a high-fidelity manikin (one that talks and exhibits physiologic changes) and state-of-the-art simulation lab might want to consider what Suzan Kardong-Edgren, PhD, RN, ANEF, CHSE, FAAN, director of the Regional Research and Innovation in Simulation Education Center at Robert Morris University in Pittsburgh, has to say: “People think simulation is about the equipment, but it’s not. It’s about communication and teamwork. You could run a really good simulation with a bag of potatoes. It’s a way to communicate and a way to work together.”
Kardong-Edgren, editor in chief of Clinical Simulation in Nursing and vice president of research for the International Nursing Association of Clinical Simulation and Learning, adds that although people tend to think higher costs equal higher quality, “It’s really almost a detriment because it’s more complicated. You spend more time nursing the manikin than having an effective learning experience. It’s a gift not to have a lot of money.”
Here’s why OR leaders should consider simulation and how they can build a simulation program.
Kardong-Edgren says ORs at children’s hospitals were among the early adopters of simulation, which was used to prepare staff for complicated procedures such as separation of conjoined twins. Running team simulations helped ensure each person knew what needed to be done.
“By the time they got to the real patient, they had cut down surgical and anesthesia time, and they had better outcomes,” she says. Ultimately, these early experiences evolved into the inclusion of virtual surgery and 3-D modeling of the patient so surgeons could more realistically practice the entire procedure.
Using simulation to prepare for procedures continues today. Franco Piscitani, BS, simulations operations manager with the Advanced Surgical Technology and Education Center at Inova Health System in Falls Church, Virginia, cites the example of a physician planning to perform deep brain stimulation.
“The physician hadn’t done one of these procedures recently, so he pulled the entire team into the center,” he says. “We found that the Mayfield headrest was going to collide with the CT scanner. If we hadn’t known that ahead of time, the headrest would have already been screwed in, and they would have had to cancel the case.”
In addition to preparing for surgical cases, simulation helps improve responses to emergency situations. A 2013 article in Simulation in Healthcare, which reviewed 18 articles on simulation and OR multidisciplinary team training, reported that most participants found the simulations to be of “high education value.” However, the range of outcomes measures meant that it was difficult to assess the transfer of learning to the clinical environment.
In 2015, one of the authors of that report, Jennifer Weller, MD, MBBS, MClinEd, FANZCA, FRCA, an associate professor and head of the Centre for Medical and Health Sciences Education at the University of Auckland in New Zealand and an anesthesiologist at Auckland City Hospital, coauthored an article on her and her colleagues’ experience with simulation training for 20 OR teams.
Participants were evaluated using the Behavioral Marker Risk Index (BRMI), which helps identify team effectiveness by using a scale of 0 to 1. A BMRI of zero reflects good team behavior, and 1 reflects poor team behavior. (For more information about BRMI, see Mazzocco in the reference list.) Results were positive for learning and team performance.
(In a related article on p 13, OR leaders share their successes in simulation and OR teamwork.)
Weller sees simulation as a game changer in patient safety. “Many adverse events are attributed to failures in teamwork and communication,” she says. “Enormous gains can be made in patient outcomes by improving sharing of information between members of multidisciplinary healthcare teams—doing what we already know how to do right, the first time, and every time.”
Kardong-Edgren adds that simulation also is valuable anytime it’s important to test something before the first experience, such as a new piece of complicated equipment. “If you run a simulation, you really know that’s the way it’s going to work,” she says. “You can identify issues such as whether the location of the plugs in the room works.”
The benefits of simulation are likely to grow as research continues in this area. “The science is still being developed,” Kardong-Edgren says. “It’s still in its infancy, so it’s like we’re building the airplane as we’re flying it.”
When asked who should lead efforts to establish a simulation center and then run it, Kardong-Edgren is blunt: “Whoever has the most pull and can get the most funding.” For most hospitals, that will be a physician; she knows of only one nurse in the US who is director of a simulation center at a major medical school.
Kardong-Edgren cautions that the director of the center might not be the best person to run the daily operations, which requires someone who can participate in training programs.
Financial considerations will drive the content of the simulation center, but again, Kardong-Edgren emphasizes, “It’s not about the fidelity of the manikin or the level of technology in the simulation lab; it’s about having a realistic scenario.”
She notes that it’s possible to create a realistic scenario without high technology. “Humans are the best for realism, but since we can’t get them to code on command, we have to look at other ways.” For example, a scenario that includes the need to coordinate the number of people in the OR might have staff members create havoc to stage a scene of chaos that participants must react to.
Most importantly, Kardong-Edgren says, OR leaders should keep in mind that the most effective simulations are multidisciplinary. “Have people [from different disciplines] write the scenario together, run it together, and debrief together,” she says. “It’s most effective when done as a team.”
Weller also emphasizes the importance of a multidisciplinary focus, noting, “Healthcare is delivered by teams, and simulation should reflect that.” She says that in her 2015 study, not all of the OR teams regularly worked together, which reflects clinical practice.
“Sometimes in real life teams won’t know each other, so simulation training can address ways to get to know each other at the beginning of the day,” she says. “I refer to it as ‘speed dating.’”
On the other hand, Weller says, “We found simulation helps to develop collaborative relationships between colleagues who work together but who don’t necessarily know much about each other; it helps develop positive relations at work.”
When writing the scenario, Kardong-Edgren recommends focusing on the goal—what people should know after the simulation is complete. This is another area where lack of funds can be an asset. “If you don’t have money for the bells and whistles, you have to concentrate on the pedagogy,” she says. “Learning happens during the debriefing, not the actual simulation.” In fact, Kardong-Edgren recommends that those interested in simulation first learn high-level debriefing skills (sidebar).
OR leaders should be prepared to encounter staff resistance when first implementing simulation. “A lot of us are very sure of our skills as long as no one can see what we’re doing,” she says. “Some people don’t want to be watched.”
That may change as nursing schools incorporate simulation into their programs. In 2014, results from the National Council of Boards of Nursing National Simulation Study provided evidence for replacing up to half of clinical hours with simulation.
Of course, how the simulation is run affects staff reaction. “We maintain a learning environment,” Piscitani says. “We’re here to help them train, not to assess competencies.”
Kardong-Edgren says many resources exist for those who want to implement simulation, including these websites:
• International Nursing Association for Clinical Simulation and Learning: www.inacsl.org
• Society for Simulation in Healthcare (SSIH): http://www.ssih.org/
She also encourages OR leaders to contact those involved in simulation. “People who do simulation share shamelessly and help each other out,” she says. This mindset is in reaction to many years when others thought simulation wouldn’t succeed long term because it was too expensive.
Piscitani has the advantage of working in a center with two high-fidelity ORs that accurately reflect the “real” OR setting (sidebar, p 10), but he says smaller hospitals without those types of resources have other options such as using an OR that is closed or not being used on a weekend. “A lot of places make low-cost vinyl curtains that show what an OR looks like,” he adds.
Like Kardong-Edgren, Piscitani recommends reaching out to others, including centers at larger hospitals or in universities. “We are very open to working with community hospitals,” he says. Fees vary, but typically average about $2,250 for the day.
To sum up, Weller says it takes three factors to have a successful simulation program:
• it needs to be integrated and ongoing
• it needs to be multidisciplinary
• it needs to have clearly articulated objectives, and the outcome measure should be aligned with the objectives.
Kardong-Edgren says simulation is here to stay. “Many people thought simulation was a flash in the pan, but it’s changing healthcare,” she says. ✥
Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.
Centers for Medical Simulation. Debriefing Assessment for Simulation in Healthcare® (DASH®). https://harvardmedsim.org/debriefing-assesment-simulation-healthcare.php.
Cumin D, Boyd M J, Webster C S, et al. A systematic review of simulation for multidisciplinary team training in operating rooms. Sim Healthc. 2013;8(3):171-179.
Dreifuerst K T. Getting started with debriefing for meaningful learning. Clin Sim Nurs. 2015;11(5):268-275.
Eppich W, Cheng A. Promoting excellence and reflective learning in simulation (PEARLS): Development and rationale for a blended approach to health care simulation debriefing. Simul Healthc. 2015;10(2):106-115.
Hayden J K, Smiley R A, Alexander M, et al. The NCSBN National Simulation Study: A longitudinal, randomized, controlled study replacing clinical hours with simulation in prelicense nursing education. J Nurs Reg. 2014;5(2)suppl:S1-S64.
Mazzocco K, Petitti D B, Fong K T, et al. Surgical team behaviors and patient outcomes. Am J Surg. 2009;197:678-685.
Rudolph J W, Simon R, Rivard P, et al. Debriefing with good judgment: Combining rigorous feedback with genuine inquiry. Anesthesiol Clin. 2007;25(2):361-376.
Weller J, Cumin D, Torrie J, et al. Multidisciplinary operating room simulation-based team training to reduce treatment errors: A feasibility study in New Zealand hospitals. N Z Med J. 2015;128(1418):40-51.
Here’s a closer look at a larger simulation center, based on a conversation with Franco Piscitani, BS, simulations operations manager with the Advanced Surgical Technology and Education Center (ASTEC) at Inova Health System in Falls Church, Virginia (photo).
Size: 7,000 square feet, which Piscitani says is on the larger end of the spectrum for surgical simulation labs.
Usage: Examples include the following:
• training nurses who are new to the OR, including managing emergencies such as a massive hemorrhage or fire in the OR
• training and testing residents on laparoscopic surgery
• training in robotic surgery, for example, workflow and how to drape the robot.
Utilization: Averages between 85% and 95%.
Operations: Staff members with clinical experience who work at the center run the simulation.
Financial support: About half of the center’s operating budget comes from outside vendors who want to hold education programs related to a new product or procedure. For example, one company had surgeons from across the US attend a simulation program on a new spinal fusion treatment. The hospital funds the other half for education purposes and because the center can help improve outcomes.
Outcomes: Training on urinary catheter insertion helped to significantly reduce catheter-related urinary tract infections. The plan is to develop a similar program for central line insertion.
The Advanced Surgical Technology and Education Center (ASTEC) at Inova Health System in Falls Church, Virginia, provides a realistic setting for simulation scenarios. Source: Inova Health System. Used with permission.
Suzan Kardong-Edgren, PhD, RN, ANEF, CHSE, FAAN, director of the Regional Research and Innovation in Simulation Education Center at Robert Morris University in Pittsburgh, says that it’s best to use higher-level debriefing techniques for simulations rather than the lower-level three-question model: What went well? What didn’t go well? How could we improve?
“It’s the debriefing that matters most in the simulation experience,” she says. “It’s talking about it and having participants self-reflect on their behavior and communication skills.”
An example of high-level debriefing is the Promoting Excellence and Reflective Learning in Simulation (PEARLS), developed by Eppich and Cheng. PEARLS integrates learner self-assessment, facilitating focused discussion, and providing information in the form of directive feedback and/or teaching. It includes scripted language to guide four phases of debriefing: reactions, description, analysis, and summary.
Other examples include Debriefing with Good Judgment and Debriefing for Meaningful Learning.
Those in charge of the debriefing should encourage discussion with thoughtful questions such as:
• Tell me what you were thinking when you did this?
• How did you decide to take this action?
• What would you do differently?
Kardong-Edgren says that, ideally, if significant difficulties occurred during the simulation, it should be run again after the debriefing. “If you do a good debriefing and then run it again so people can do better, they can leave feeling like they’ve learned something.”