March 15, 2019

Prioritizing patient safety unites and empowers OR team—Part 2

By: Iris Llewellyn
Share

Several never events at The Medical Center of Aurora (TMCA) in Aurora, Colorado, over a 1-year period prompted leaders there to launch patient safety first (PSF) initiatives. Part 1 of this series discussed how these initiatives were identified and implemented, and the importance of evidence-based communication tools (OR Manager, March 2019, 17-19). Part 2 explores the link between patient safety and a healthy nurse work environment, highlights the importance of accountability, and provides critical steps for sustaining PSF initiatives.

 

Vulnerability to culture

Kathy Bilys, MBA, CPHQ

The four fundamental characteristics of PSF initiatives are problem identification, strength of organizational competencies, vulnerability to culture, and commitment to change. A key benefit of PSF initiatives is that they allow healthcare leaders to manage vulnerability to the adverse effects of culture on patient outcomes. For TMCA, a critical shift in culture that occurred as part of its PSF initiative was recognizing and addressing the facility’s “sacred cows.”

Early on in TMCA’s PSF initiative, the notion of staff speaking up to a physician made some team members uncomfortable. “Like many organizations, ours had some traditional hierarchies and power differentials to overcome,” says Kathy Bilys, MBA, CPHQ, vice president of quality and performance improvement at TMCA. “Initially, it took some courage for team members to be able to speak up. Even though leadership said, ‘we have your back,’ that does not necessarily help when a team member is staring into the eyes of a surgeon who’s saying, ‘you want me to stop what?’ It took some time to build trust and for staff to see that there were not any repercussions to speaking up.”

The most challenging sacred cow, says Michelle Stierstorfer, MSN, RN, was “the mindset of ‘the physician is in charge and the physician knows best.’ That meant that if team members had a concern, they were often hesitant or too afraid to speak up.” Stierstorfer is director of surgical services: SDS, PACU, Pre-Admit Testing, Endoscopy at TMCA. “By facilitating consistency in surgeon awareness and use of the CUSS tool, we overcame this as an organization.” (CUSS is TMCA’s adoption of the TeamSTEPPS® CUS speak-up model shown in the sidebar at right.)

For positive culture change to occur, Beverly Kirchner, BSN, RN, CNOR, CASC, chief compliance officer at SurgeryDirect, LLC, Highland Village, Texas, stresses that executive and perioperative leaders must foster accountability by resolving issues with inappropriate behaviors or team dynamics. “To address sacred cows associated with speaking up, or what may be better described as a culture of intimidation, perioperative leaders must remember that this is not personal,” she says. “It is the responsibility of perioperative leaders to protect their team members and the patients who trust their facility to care for them.”

As trust in the use of the CUSS tool was building and sacred cows were being addressed, TMCA began to see significant improvements in process, culture, and outcomes, all of which were still being encouraged and supported by ongoing annual PSF meetings (sidebar below).

 

Importance of work environment

Linda H. Aiken, PhD, RN, FAAN, FRCN

Research by Linda H. Aiken, PhD, RN, FAAN, FRCN, and colleagues demonstrates the link between patient safety and work environment, and Aiken sees this as a critical factor in the success of TMCA’s PSF initiatives.

“The major finding from our research is that patient safety innovations like the one developed by the TMCA team are not likely to work as intended unless the hospital nurse work environment is good already or bolstered if needed,” says Aiken, the Claire M. Fagin Leadership Professor of Nursing, professor of sociology, director of the Center for Health Outcomes and Policy Research, and a senior fellow at the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia.

In a study of patient safety as an ongoing hospital concern, Aiken refers to findings that show more than a third of staff nurses in a large representative group of hospitals report the quality of the work environment in their hospital is only fair or poor, and that only 22% of hospitals improved their nurse work environments between 2005 and 2016 when there was a major focus on improving patient safety (sidebar below).

“Good results achieved from the innovation at TMCA may not have the same positive results if implemented at other hospitals without good work environments,” Aiken cautions. “It is critical to achieving real progress in patient safety that good nurse staffing and work environments are identified explicitly as patient safety interventions along with the clinical processes and tools now being used by TMCA and other institutions.”

 

 

Commitment to change

Victoria Steelman, PhD, RN, CNOR, FAAN

Sustaining meaningful change achieved through PSF initiatives requires deep and lasting commitment. According to Victoria Steelman, PhD, RN, CNOR, FAAN, associate professor at the University of Iowa in Iowa City and a former AORN president, these are the critical steps to take to sustain change:

• Engage staff and physicians.

• Educate staff and physicians about the change. Remember that education alone is never enough to implement a sustainable change.

• –Dedicate the resources to the first weeks of implementation of the change, and audit adherence. This will save time and resources later. Post daily rates of adherence. This not only serves as a reminder, but also acknowledges improvements right away.

• Continue to audit adherence to the change through the established quality reporting channels; provide feedback to staff and physicians about adherence.

• Six months after the change has been implemented, reinfuse the change with an activity that engages staff and physicians.

At TMCA, this level of commitment translated into refined messaging, periodic and anticipatory PSF meetings, alignment of onboarding practices with PSF practices, and pride in patient safety metrics.

“As culture and process have improved over the past few years, the TMCA leadership has had to circle back with the staff to make clear that, although our facility has had a long run without a never event, that was not luck—it was because our hospital implemented new measures to keep our patients safe,” says Bilys. “We continue to reiterate that there is a reason why we do briefings and debriefings, why we do a checklist, and why we encourage staff to speak up.”

 

Michelle Stierstorfer, MSN, RN

As a direct result of the PSF initiative, TMCA staff established, and continue to maintain, heightened awareness around patient safety through consistency in collaboration across departments. “Our weekly audits on our safety checks have proven that the strategies and tools that we have employed really have become a part of our culture, and that our team processes are stronger than any one individual because, ultimately, this initiative was driven by culture change,” says Stierstorfer.

Both Bilys and Stierstorfer credit current TMCA leaders, several of whom are either relatively new employees or were not at TMCA when the PSF initiative first launched, for maintaining the momentum of the initiative and for keeping patient safety a top priority for staff and leadership alike.

 

Anticipatory, energizing PSF meetings

TMCA continues to host anticipatory, energizing PSF meetings that are mandatory for all procedure areas. Patient safety goals are established, and educational activities, staff recognition, patient safety updates, and stories shared by team members form the foundation for TMCA to continue to evolve as an organization and to make its practices better.

At the 2018 PSF meeting, which featured a “TMCA airline” theme, Ryan Simpson, chief executive officer at TMCA, asked team members to tell the person sitting next to them, “I’ve got your back!” Staff members who stepped up, whether it was through use of CUSS or through patient advocacy, were acknowledged, and their names were listed in first class of the TMCA airliner presentation materials.

 

Alignment of onboarding practices with PSF initiatives

Linda Ortiz, MSN, RN

TMCA has learned that a commitment to patient safety requires onboarding new employees to the “TMCA way” of practicing. According to Linda Ortiz, MSN, RN, director of surgical services, this entails a direct conversation about CUSS and how to speak up.

“Most of the onboarding of new team members is handled by our preceptors, who make it a priority to explain that, at TMCA, we speak up and we do not hold back,” she says. “By having those crucial conversations, expectations are clearly set from the get-go about the culture we have created and wish to sustain, and what TMCA expects from every one of its team members.”

Since the launch of the first PSF meeting in August 2014, TMCA has been tracking the number of days it has gone without a never event. The number of days is routinely shared with staff at PSF meetings and in emailed PSF newsletters.

The results are powerful. As of December 31, 2018, TMCA had gone 1,187 days without a never event, which amounts to 19,454 error-free procedures. ✥

 

 Iris Llewellyn is a freelance healthcare writer based in Denver.

References

Aiken L H, Sloane D M, Barnes H, et al. Nurses’ and patients’ appraisals show patient safety in hospitals remains a concern. Health Aff (Millwood). 2018;37(11):1744-1751.

Ortiz L, Wolfmeier N, Stierstorfer M. Patient Safety First. Poster. OR Manager Conference. September 2018. Nashville, Tennessee.

Pocket Guide: TeamSTEPPS: Team Strategies & Tools to Enhance Performance and Patient Safety: CUS; SBAR. Agency for Healthcare and Research Quality. https://www.ahrq.gov/teamstepps/instructor/essentials/pocketguide.html#cus.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat