Lynn Webb, PhD, assistant dean of the Vanderbilt School of Medicine, Nashville, Tennessee, shared an anecdote about unprofessional behavior with attendees of the recent OR Business Management Conference in San Antonio, Texas.
A nurse reported that a surgeon was performing a transverse colon resection, and at the appropriate point, they told him: “You need to regown and glove per our bundle.” The surgeon replied: “I don’t really agree with that element of the bundle, and I’m not stopping now to change gown and gloves,” and continued with the procedure.
After recounting the incident, Webb asked the attendees to take out their phones and respond to a live poll. Did the attendees believe the doctor’s refusal was a threat to patient safety? And would their staff be likely to report the doctor’s unprofessional behavior?
The results were telling. Although the majority of attendees reported they felt the doctor’s actions compromised the patient’s safety, they also indicated there was less than a 50% chance that an employee who witnessed that behavior would speak up in the moment or report the event in the organization’s occurrence reporting system.
It is very common, said Webb during the presentation, for OR team members to look the other way when it comes to a surgeon’s unprofessional behavior. This can include rude and disrespectful language, refusal to adhere to guidelines, poor handoffs, ignoring timeouts and agreed-upon protocols, and failure to respond when needed.
Staff supporting the surgeon might be afraid to speak up out of fear of retaliation or a sense of loyalty. Unless the organization shows that such feedback is actively encouraged, they may believe that this behavior is implicitly supported by the organization because of the surgeon’s status and experience.
If the OR team is afraid to speak up, said Webb, there is a high likelihood that they do not actually feel safe or supported in their organization. And those are the very same nurses, technicians, and physician assistants who are more likely to leave to seek employment elsewhere—this is just one of the ways that a surgeon’s unprofessional conduct leads to big financial losses.
“At a safe organization, what do people have to fear?” Webb asked during the presentation. “It’s important that we have a culture where our colleagues feel safe to speak up in the moment, if they observe or witness something that’s inconsistent with [an organization’s] values.” He added: “Employees trust that if they do speak up or report something, that we have their backs and will address the issue.”
At the Vanderbilt Center for Patient and Professional Advocacy (CPPA), Webb and his team oversee a national database called Patient Advocacy Reporting System, or PARS® (sidebar, p15). According to Webb, hospitals want to understand why patients are unhappy and have a chance to fix it. “We know from research that for every patient who tells us something and gives us the chance for service recovery, there may be somewhere between 20 and 40 who just leave,” he said.
Through data collected by PARS®, CPPA has made a number of striking observations related to physician complaint and malpractice risk. PARS® receives about 6,000 patient complaints per year, and 35–50% of doctors never get a single patient complaint in a 4-year period and are the subject of very few malpractice claims, Webb said. About 5% of physicians account for a third of patient complaints and are associated with as many as 50% of malpractice claims, he added.
Those same doctors who receive high numbers of patient complaints are also more likely to have poor surgical outcomes, according to a 2017 study led by Vanderbilt researchers that appeared in JAMA Surgery. The study involved reports from 32,125 patients in the National Surgical Quality Improvement Program from seven health systems along with data on unprofessional behaviors related to each of these patients from Vanderbilt’s CPPA.
A follow-up study in 2019 in JAMA Surgery looked at data on 13,653 patients treated by 202 surgeons at two academic medical centers from 2012 to 2016. The researchers came to similar conclusions associated with co-worker reports of unprofessional behavior, including reports collected via CPPA’s Co-Worker Observation Reporting System (sidebar, below). Unprofessional conduct cited included doctors wiping equipment on the bedsheets before use on patients, doctors trivializing safety procedures, and outright
bullying and rudeness by surgeons directed at hospital staff. When the researchers looked at patient outcomes in the months following their surgeries, they found that for those patients who had surgeons who had been reported at least four times, 14.1% had medical or surgical complications, including infections and lung/kidney complications, compared to 10.7% of patients whose surgeons had no negative reports.
“Patients whose surgeons had more co-worker concerns describing unprofessional behavior were significantly more likely to have a complication than patients whose surgeons had very few concerns,” says William Cooper, MD, MPH, vice president for Patient and Professional Advocacy at Vanderbilt University Medical Center and co-author of the study. “Improving safety and outcomes for our patients will require us to continue to focus on encouraging respectful and effective communication with other team members.”
PARS® provides national, discipline-specific, peer-comparative benchmarks of unsolicited patient complaints about professionals for effective peer-delivered interventions. PARS® was established by Vanderbilt’s Center for Patient and Professional Advocacy (CPPA). More than 200 hospitals and medical groups have partnered with CPPA to implement PARS® tools and processes.
• 5% of professionals are associated with 35% of unsolicited complaints and 50% of claims dollars.
• 35-50% of professionals are associated with no unsolicited complaints and 4% of claims dollars.
CORSsm is an effective tool and process to identify and intervene with professionals at risk for suboptimal outcomes of care associated with co-worker reports of unprofessional behavior. PARS® and CORS have a database of approximately 93,000 physicians and advanced practice professionals.
• 3% of professionals are associated with 44% of reports of unprofessional behavior.
• 85–90% of professionals are associated with no reports.
PARS® partnerships: https://www.vumc.org/patient-professional-advocacy/pars-process-infographic
PARS® findings: https://www.vumc.org/patient-professional-advocacy/pars-program
CORSsm: https://www.vumc.org/patient-professional-advocacy/cors-program
A climate in which hospital staff feel unable to share their concerns and flag unprofessional behavior also has serious financial consequences for institutions.
“Unsolicited patient complaints are an excellent predictor for future malpractice risk,” said Webb during his presentation, noting that they have been working with patient complaints to reduce malpractice risk for about 25 years at Vanderbilt. Across the country, the cost of medical malpractice is $55.6 billion a year, which includes “defensive medicine” costs, or the costs of tests or treatments given to patients solely to avoid lawsuits.
A 2019 study in Annals of Surgery looked at 264 cardiac, thoracic, vascular, plastic, orthopedic, and general surgeons at four academic medical centers. Measuring the ratings for surgeons on qualities such as education style, humility, respectfulness, and teamwork against malpractice claims, the study found that eight of 14 positive behaviors were significantly associated with not having malpractice claims, while four of nine negative behaviors were associated with having malpractice claims. These negative behaviors included snapping at others when frustrated, talking down to others, not considering suggestions, and not paying attention.
“The findings suggest that everyday negative conduct by surgeons toward their colleagues can have real implications for care, even when surgeons are highly skilled technically,” says lead author Janaka Lagoo, MD, MPH. And although there were ratings from peers, staff, and supervisors, it was the peer ratings, the study found, that had the highest correlation with malpractice claims.
“We believe that peers are uniquely positioned to observe and analyze the behavior and performance of their colleagues, as they have undergone similar training, understand the unique daily challenges of their profession, interact with similar healthcare staff, and likely have patients with similar health needs,” wrote the study authors.
In addition to malpractice suits, hospitals contending with staff turnover bear a major financial cost. Nurse turnover is particularly a major concern and one directly tied to workplace culture. Across the country, the turnover rate for bedside nurses is 17.2%, and 43% of new nurses leave their positions within 3 years. For each nurse who leaves, a hospital loses between $36,000 and $57,000—representing millions of dollars each year.
According to one study, said Webb, “of those individuals who leave with exit interviews, 40% say they left because of the culture and exposure to unprofessional behavior.”
Webb noted in his presentation that not only are peers essential in reporting unprofessional behavior, but they can be the most effective allies in correcting it as well. At Vanderbilt, they have engaged trained peer messengers who can step in at times when surgeons are not adhering to conduct and help them to course correct. “That’s the approach we have taken at Vanderbilt for many years,” said Webb. “We have supported many other hospitals and medical groups across the country to implement this same approach. We call it the professionalism pyramid, and it starts with a single concern.”
But while the data may seem grim, Webb said he sees hope for organizations that heed a culture of safety and respect. “The good news is the majority of healthcare professionals can self-regulate,” said Webb during his presentation. “If you give them meaningful feedback through stories and data, they will more than likely reflect on that feedback and change their behavior.”
—Brita Belli is an award-winning writer and PR professional with published stories in the New York Times, National Geographic, MSN.com, and Alternet.
Strafford F. Nurse turnover rate–infographic. Streamline Verify. March 16, 2016.