In 2021, Patient Safety in Surgery published the article, “Incidence and OR team awareness of near-miss and retained surgical sharps: A national survey on United States operating rooms,” from a nationwide survey with over 400 surgeons, anesthesiologists, OR nurses and surgical technologists on the frequency of lost and retained sharps. The article further discusses the surprising discordance among the groups.
Here, we focus on the different perspectives and why the above groups view the issue differently. Like the story of the blind man and the elephant, people will claim to know the absolute truth based on their limited and subjective views. However, there is no room for shortsightedness in the OR, where ignoring other people’s experiences can compromise patient safety.
This article discusses the causes of different views in order to apply the same open-minded techniques in other situations where discordances could exist.
To understand the discordance among the groups, the views of surgeons were compared to those in a combined group of anesthesiologists, nurses, and technologists. Binomial logistic regression was performed to assess the likelihood of these events reported by surgeons:
➊ No surgical sharps were lost and a miscount of sharps happened in > 2% of surgeries in the last year.
➋ 100% of lost sharps were recovered before a surgery was completed in the last year.
➌ A portable X-ray was used 100% of the time to aid in the recovery of lost sharps.
A pairwise comparison was used to reveal statistically significant differences in media scores between:
• surgeon vs anesthesiologist groups
• surgeon vs nurse/technologist groups.
For the question, “In the last year, how often have you witnessed a miscount for a surgical sharp?”, significant dissonance was found between the surgeon and anesthesiologist groups on how often they believe miscounts “never” happen:
• Roughly 20% of surgeons believe they never had a miscounted sharp over the last year.
• Roughly 5.3% of anesthesiologists reported miscounted sharps never happened over the last year.
For the question, “What percentage of witnessed lost sharps were not recovered prior to completing a surgery in the last year?”, a statistically significant delta was found between the anesthesiologist vs. surgeon, and nurse/technologist vs. surgeon views:
• 54.3% of anesthesiologists vs 30.3% of surgeons
• 50.8% of nurses/technologists vs 30.3% of surgeons.
For the question, “Over the course of your career, how often is portable X-Ray used to aid in the recovery of lost sharps?,” more than half (56.8%) of surgeons reported using X-Ray 100% of the time to manage lost sharps. On the other hand, both anesthesiologists and nurses/technologists believe the percentage is closer to a third of the time.
Interestingly, despite the disagreement on how often X-Ray is used, all three groups agreed that X-Ray is only effective between 26–50% of the time in identifying lost sharps. More importantly, they all concurred that the use of X-Ray adds 31–40 minutes to the procedure, with an additional 21–30 minutes spent searching. The total equates to 50–70 minutes of OR time added per lost sharp event.
To dive deeper into the causes of the differing perspectives, we pulled data from the Patient Safety in Surgery article and interviewed both a surgeon and an OR manager:
• Sam Weprin, MD, identified as “surgeon” in the below Q&A, is one of the researchers and authors of the Patient Safety in Surgery article. His work is centered on patient safety.
• An OR specialty team manager from an academic hospital who prefers to remain anonymous, identified as “OR manager” below, was a circulating nurse for over 10 years before stepping into a leadership role. She has recent first-hand experience with the causes and prevention methods for better communication in the OR.
Surgeon: These events are caused by a constellation of factors, including time pressures, a distracting and often loud environment, a large number of instruments and needles, and OR staff shift changes.
OR manager: In addition, when there are multiple tables set up, that adds another level of confusion. If we walk into a case that we are not very familiar with but we are supporting, that adds another level of stress. From a staffing standpoint, having travel nurses who are not familiar with the hospital or the team could create unnecessary complexities along with multiple hand-offs. A very long case or an open case could also increase the chance of miscounts.
Surgeon: The surgeon plays the primary role in the OR and bears the bulk of the responsibility and any potential negative consequences. We assume that might lead them to have a bias towards recalling a more positive outcome.
To verify that, we obtained an odd ratio comparing surgeons to the rest of the surgical staff (anesthesiologists, nurses, and technologists) to see if there is a difference in the perception of the number of lost sharp events. Surgeons were found to be almost 3 times more likely to report zero lost events and 2.5 times more likely to say all lost sharps were recovered prior to the completion of a surgery.
I want to emphasize that this does not imply that surgeons are trying to hide something. It is more likely due to them not being directly involved in the instrument counting process.
OR manager: I agree. It is basically unawareness, which is why a survey like this creates a neutral platform for dialogue.
Here is how I think about perception in an OR: Imagine the patient lying on the table. The anesthesiologist sits next to the patient by the airway. Therefore, he or she is completely aware of what is happening in that area. The surgeons, on the other hand, are operating over the patient. They are concentrating on the inside of the body. The nurses and technologists care for the operation of the OR, from the use of instruments and equipment, to movement around the room, to the patient’s vital signs, and the overall environment. There is a clear division of labor, and that leads to different perceptions of events.
Surgeon: When I started researching on this, part of my intention was to use data to drive meaningful conversation. Many institutions now utilize an “end” time-out procedure to review what was done during the course of the operation and to review any key or important events. The more conversation and dialogue teams implement, confusion and ambiguity are less likely. OR leaders should strive for everyone to be on the same page before, during, and after each surgical procedure.
OR manager: I also suggest a few strategies that can help prevent miscounts:
➊ During both the initial count and final count, turn down the noise level and do not distract the person counting. Do not rush.
➋ Repeat back the initial count and final count to a second person.
➌ Articulate the motion of handing off the needles (such as ‘one-in, one-out’) verbally.
➍ Have a whiteboard inside the room when dealing with a large number of needles so the surgical technician can both hear and visualize the number of needles.
➎ And of course, the use of adjunct technologies in recent years has made things easier.
Recognizing that there are multiple perspectives in the OR is the first step to begin the conversation on patient safety. Only after the differing perspectives are considered, will the appropriate processes and protocols put in place to improve patient safety and increase OR efficiency be followed.
The more stressful the situation is, the more important the above is as well. When people are under stress, most will default to what is easier and more streamlined to resolve said stress, which might not include newly established protocols. Leaders should ensure that all patient safety protocols are “user friendly,” meaning all members from a surgical team are being represented. The adoption rate will increase when the effort is there to show all angles. A protocol is good only when it is properly adopted.
—Ivy Montgomery is a Go-To-Market executive who is passionate about improving patient outcomes, especially in the areas of diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of diseases.