January 13, 2020

Recycling program evolves to sustain gains in waste reduction

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN
Share

Approximately 5.9 million tons of waste annually comes from the healthcare industry, and one-third of that waste comes directly from the OR.

Each year, an increasing number of disposable products are used in the OR. To address this dilemma, an OR recycling performance improvement committee was formed at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) in Boston.

The multidisciplinary committee members collaborated in evaluating processes to reduce waste transport to landfills, increase waste transport to recycling and reprocessing, and reduce waste at the point of care. Over time, they had many successes and gained support from the perioperative staff, materials management, waste management, environmental services, and other areas in the hospital, says Patrice M. Osgood, DNP, RN, CNOR, NE-BC, associate chief nurse, MGH perioperative and GI endoscopy services.

Despite recent challenges related to changes in international recycling policies, staff members continue to work toward implementing the changes that are needed for a sustainable system and waste reduction.

Forming the committee and its charter

Committee members included the perioperative director, perioperative staff specialist, surgical service clinical practice nurses, MGH sustainability director, Partners HealthCare sustainability director, MGH environment of care manager, and the anesthesia technology team leader. (Partners HealthCare is a Boston-based network that includes MGH and Brigham and Women’s Hospital. Partners announced a name change in November 2019; it is now known as Mass General Brigham.)

As the committee developed, the center for perioperative care (CPC) and postanesthesia care unit (PACU) clinical operations managers and nurses also contributed as members.

The MGH sustainability director oversees recycling throughout MGH facilities, while the Partners sustainability director provides a more global perspective for recycling options and organizational contracts.

The committee developed a charter to provide a mission statement, guide the committee’s work as the initiative evolved, and establish objectives for sustainability.

The objectives were to:

• further reduce the carbon footprint of the OR by increasing recycling, reusing, and reducing waste from the OR

• understand the waste stream outside the OR

• collaborate with colleagues and peers to understand what works and what does not work

• start with small steps for success

• implement practices that would decrease waste going to landfills

• promote awareness

• ensure there is clarity in the communication of practice changes.

 

Preparation and planning

The committee, which was nursing staff driven, created a quantitative audit through the use of a staff survey to evaluate what the staff observed as barriers to recycling in the OR (sidebar at right).

“When the survey answers came back, we were able to quantify where the barriers were that we could address immediately. From that perspective, we developed a number of standardized practices,” Barbara Belanger, MSN, RN, CNOR, perioperative clinical practice nurse at MGH, told OR Manager.

Issues identified for improvement from the survey included a need for:

• clarity in what could or could not be recycled

• standardized processes for recycling

• convenience and limited space.

In addition, there was a lack of awareness of waste generated at the point of care, such as opening and not using items on the sterile field and the waste stream process, says Belanger, who assumed the committee chair position.

Committee members toured and observed the waste stream at MGH and affiliated regional recycling facilities.

“We collaborated with the vendor where the recycling waste was transported, and we got an accurate perception of what we could recycle and what we couldn’t,” says Belanger.

“We also clarified the type of paper and plastic recycling with the vendor because that had changed,” she says.

The staff were surveyed again at 1 year. There were improvements, but additional issues were identified (sidebar above).

 

Process for implementing changes

The committee’s findings and preliminary practice changes were presented at perioperative services staff meetings, educational in-services, and in a weekly online OR communication newsletter. OR staff were given electronic access to information in an OR recycling folder in the nursing administration file.

Improvements included:

• green bags placed into triangular-shaped bins for plastic recycling

• blue bins available for paper recycling

• recycling signs placed near the bins to guide effective recycling

• bins placed in all ORs, locker rooms, lounge areas, and storage areas

• a process for recycling coffee cups and cardboard lunch trays.

Belanger says a pilot study was conducted before they put a coffee-cup recycling process in place, and they saw a huge improvement in just that one area. “We also collaborated with the vendor to improve our practice for reprocessing single-use-only surgical items, and we improved the reprocessing of compression boots and tourniquet cuffs for the OR, PACU, and preop areas,” says Belanger. “Stryker, our vendor, keeps track of the number of times items have been reprocessed,” she says.

In addition, a nurse-driven pilot audit was conducted to collect data on the number of items opened onto the sterile field and not used.

“Results from these surveys, studies, and audits have increased awareness at the clinical site in terms of recycling, reducing waste, and reprocessing, which led to improved outcomes,” says Belanger.

 

International policy changes ‘throw a wrench into the works’

Items that can be recycled have changed in response to China’s “National Sword” policy adopted in 2017. This initiative banned the importing of 24 grades of plastics and mixed paper (mixed paper accounts for 40% of single-stream recycling).

In addition, the contamination rate acceptable for recyclables shipped to international countries was changed to 0.05%—down from the previous industry specification of 2%.

This major shift has significantly impacted the value of commodities—reducing overall value by 65%—and left many cities and businesses across the US challenged by a new economics for recycling.

In 2016, China imported 760 million tons of plastic recyclable waste. That number has fallen by 95% since international regulatory changes were implemented. MGH is working with national and international recycling manufacturing companies to determine what plastic waste can be recycled from healthcare facilities.

“Our options have changed dramatically in the past year,” says Belanger. “The MGH sustainability director is working with a leader in the recycling industry to develop other options, but we are not quite there yet.”

The single-stream recycling approach was a limiting factor in healthcare recycling. The waste systems vendor who worked with MGH to create the previous process is now having to respond to the international regulatory changes, notes Belanger.

“We haven’t lost hope,” she says. “We have a significant opportunity to capture even more recyclables than they we have in the past, but it will have to occur through an alternate collection and processing system, which will take time to set up. The biggest thing for us to focus on is creating true long-term sustainability in our programs and our efforts.”

 

Other processes ‘in the works’

The committee is working on other processes that include:

• using compostable bags instead of plastic bags for patients to put their clothes and other items in when they are admitted

• selling bags in the gift shop with the hospital logo on them made from the blue wrap after sterile items are removed (http://www.circularblu.com/)

• recycling blue wrap through Halyard Health, Alpharetta, Georgia.

“We are discussing new options for recycling blue wrap and plastic medical waste with companies through our vendors who are aware of our problem” notes Michael Farrell, MS, RN, CNOR, MGH nursing director for the OR.

The big issue now is sorting through the middlemen of transportation and storage.

“We need the ability to store the blue wrap somewhere for it to be bundled, packaged, and then transported to the facility,” says Farrell. “It’s a similar issue with medical grade plastic. Any waste items that are identifiable as coming from a health organization are a challenge—not for the end recycler, but for the transportation to the end recycler and how to separate it from the mainstream waste,” he says.

A big challenge for MGH is its capacity to store and separate materials, notes Osgood.

“We are extremely space-constrained in Boston. We don’t have a large area where we can store different items for one truck at a time to come for specific items. This might be different for a facility in the Midwest, for example, with a lot of space,” she says.

 

Potential solutions to additional challenges

Osgood adds that before the international policy changes, waste was placed in a green recycling bin in every OR, and the staff knew that all noncontaminated items went into that green bag. “It was single stream, and we just had to take that bag out at the end of the case,” she says.

However, since China tightened restrictions, no plastic items from the OR are accepted in single stream, even if it is taken out before the patient enters the room.

US companies are working to determine approaches to operationalize transportation challenges.

“From what we’ve been told, there are vendors who want medical plastic for recycling, says Farrell. “Uncontaminated medical plastics have value, but the trick is in collecting, consolidating, and marketing those materials,” he says.

The waste systems vendor that works with MGH is confident that outlets and processes for transportation for the plastics can be found, says Farrell. It is just a matter of revamping the program so waste can be collected and processed efficiently.

 

Ever-changing list of recyclable materials

The list of recyclables is ever-changing. “We are working with our vendor and our sustainability teams at MGH and Partners for a viable, working list of recyclables that can be presented to the staff. The perioperative staff really want to recycle and are engaged with the process for recycling,” says Farrell.

The staff also have focused on reducing waste on their own. For example, they no longer automatically open extra packages of supplies, such as sponges or sutures that could end up in a landfill.

In addition, if they need to cover the patient or create padding or rolls, they will take a couple of bath blankets out of the warmer rather than eight to ten blankets that will not be used and placed into the laundry, which adds to the carbon footprint.

After Belanger did a presentation for Nurses Week in May 2018, other MGH nurses contacted her to see what they could do in their departments to help reduce waste and improve recycling.

“If I stood up as a nurse manager and said, ‘you will do this and recycle this,’ the initiative would not have been successful,” says Osgood. “Getting people who are passionate about recycling as champions and letting staff take the lead is what made the initiative successful.” ✥

 

References

AORN. AORN Position Statement on Environmental Responsibility. 2014. https://aornjournal.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1016/j.aorn.2013.10.011.

 

Belanger B, Bouyer-Ferullo S, Osgood P. Perioperative nursing performance improvement recycling initiative. Poster. AORN Global Surgical Conference & Expo. 2019.

 

Ivanova I. American cities confront a “slow-moving recycling crisis.” CBS News. March 20, 2019. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/recycling-after-chinas-plastic-ban-american-cities-face-recycling-crisis/.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat