April 17, 2015

Research projects potential cost savings with wider use of MIS

By: OR Manager
Share

Though minimally invasive surgery (MIS) is associated with lower postoperative complication rates, little is known about the cost savings resulting from the reduced rates.

Researchers led by Martin Makary, MD, professor of surgery at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, designed a study to calculate the projected cost savings that could be possible with increased use of MIS for colon or lung procedures and appendectomy.

Analyzing 80,000 surgical procedures in the 2010 National Inpatient Sample, the researchers found hugely divergent rates of MIS use and cost variation.

 

Lower costs, shorter LOS

Compared to open procedures, MIS resulted in lower costs for all procedures analyzed, with a mean savings of:

• $1,528 for appendectomy

• $7,507 for colectomy

• $6,290 for lobectomy.

Savings attributable to reduced complications alone in MIS procedures were:

• $688 for appendectomy—a 43.7% savings

• $5,097 for colectomy—a 67.9% savings

• $2,844 for lobectomy—a 46.8% savings.

MIS was tied to shorter length of stay for:

• appendectomy—1.4 fewer days

• colectomy—3.0 fewer days

• lobectomy—2.1 fewer days.

 

Increased use of MIS

If all hospitals nationwide used minimally invasive surgery as often as the top one-third of hospitals, the researchers estimated there would be:

• 4,306 fewer complications

• 169,819 fewer hospital stays

• $337 million in annual savings.

If hospitals increased their use of MIS by 50%, there would be:

• 3,578 fewer complications

• 144,853 fewer hospital stays

• $288 million in savings.

A more appropriate use of MIS for common procedures is an opportunity to improve outcomes and reduce complications and costs, the researchers say. Value-based purchasing and global payment initiatives are shifting the cost burden of complications from payers to hospitals, and hospitals need to be proactive. The researchers recommend that hospitals consider retraining surgeons in MIS and directing patients who require open surgery to surgeons skilled in open surgery and directing patients who are candidates for MIS to surgeons skilled in MIS. ✥

Reference

Xu T, Hutfless S M, Cooper M A, et al. Hospital cost implications of increased use of minimally invasive surgery (Research letter). JAMA Surg. Published online March 25, 2015.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat