Certain words and phrases are used frequently in nursing—sometimes so frequently that their true meaning is lost. For some, the term “shared governance” is one of those.
What is shared governance?
“A dynamic staff-leader partnership that promotes collaboration, shared decision making, and accountability for improving quality of care, safety, and enhancing work life” is how shared governance is defined at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, Tennessee.
“I like this definition a lot because it talks about quality, safety, and patients before it talks about the holiday schedule or the call schedule,” says David A. Wyatt, MPH, BSN, RN, CNOR, associate operating officer, perioperative services, and associate nursing officer, surgery patient care center at Vanderbilt.
Vanderbilt has 53 onsite ORs in seven locations, including 15 ORs in three free-standing ambulatory surgery centers. It is the only Level 1 trauma center in middle Tennessee, and it is a Magnet-designated facility, with more than 350 surgeons, fellows, and residents; 300 anesthesiologists; and 800 nurses, scrub technicians, clinical technicians, and anesthesia technicians.
Vanderbilt nursing was among the pioneers implementing the shared governance model 30 years ago. But about 2 years ago, the structures set up for shared governance began to lose their effectiveness.
“For the past 2 years we have been on a journey to reinvigorate our shared governance structure,” says Wyatt. “You are never done with shared governance,” he says. “It is a process. You have to keep at it.”
Shared governance has been shown to increase staff nurse satisfaction through shared accountability—not only in their practice but in their ownership of the decisions around their work environment (sidebar, below).
Shared governance aligns with the Magnet goal of structural empowerment. “If you are a Magnet institution, it is important that you show how the staff are engaged and has a voice in the decisions that are made,” says Wyatt.
Wyatt says he also believes shared governance positively impacts patient care. “Some say it is a little ‘fluffy’ to say it impacts patient care,” says Wyatt. “But what I have seen is that when staff are empowered, particularly over ownership of their practice, they begin to have a confidence in the day-to-day care they provide patients and the way they engage their physician colleagues and other staff members.”
Vanderbilt’s perioperative department has multiple shared governance unit boards that are based on service lines.
The unit boards are the point-of-service decision-making, problem-solving forums through which staff, managers, and other key stakeholders consider issues such as:
• local concerns of the unit
• staff and patient education
• quality of care
• patient and staff safety.
Unit boards include all staff and are chaired and facilitated by a team that includes an elected chair and cochair as well as the manager of the unit.
Each unit board chair also sits on the perioperative services executive unit board, with representatives from the presurgery evaluation team along with the pre-, intra-, and postoperative areas.
“Our main goal for the executive unit board is to use this team for decision making related to practice and policy development, such as a policy for counts, across the surgery enterprise,” says Beki Kazanofski, BSN, RN, CNOR, Vanderbilt’s OR patient care manager.
Governance principles Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, Tennessee, has used are from The Source: Twelve Principles of Governance That Power Exceptional Boards, a book that talks about actual boards of organizations and the principles that power them and make them exceptional. David Wyatt, MPH, MA, RN, CNOR, interim associate hospital director and associate chief nursing officer, perioperative services and the surgery patient care center at Vanderbilt, gave the following examples.
• Constructive partnership. Board members understand they are in this together, and that they are working toward their goals.
• Mission driven. Board members understand that they have a mission and are driven to that.
• Strategic thinking. Board members are thinking more broadly. This is very important for a board of an organization, but it’s different for managers of unit boards. Getting them to think more broadly about where they want to be in 1 year or in 3 years, and where they imagine their staff will be, is not as easy.
• Culture of inquiry. Board members have to solicit opinions. When everyone in a meeting is agreeing, it is important to stop and ask: “Is there anyone who doesn’t agree with this? Can someone give the other side to this?” It is important to do this because there can are unintended consequences that don’t come up until something is implemented. Just one person saying, there is a possibility that if this is done, X or Y would happen, helps the board anticipate unintended consequences.
• Independent mindedness. Board members do not participate in group think. They understand their role, particularly in the executive unit board. Those individuals are responsible for representing their areas at the larger level, and they need to know they can’t just go along with group think. They have to own who they are representing.
• Ethos of transparency. Board members make sure that what’s talked about is not a secret. Executive unit board members are responsible for telling everyone what they talk about in their meetings.
• Compliance with integrity. Board members understand they have to maintain and protect their integrity.
• Sustaining resources. Board members have to sustain the resources they have been given.
• Results oriented. Board members understand what they are doing and how they are producing results.
• Intentional board practices. Board members get back to some of the formal structures and formal resources around them.
• Continuous learning. Board members think about how to continuously develop their board and members, and help them grow.
• Revitalization. Board members don’t want to have a structure that remains the same, such as the same unit board chair for 12 years. Having the same unit board chair for 3 or 4 years is too long, and someone new is needed. That can be hard sometimes because staff will say that person is the best person to do it. Though that may be true, it can quickly start to feel like a club, and then that person won’t be able to represent the entire staff.
—The Source: Twelve principles of governance that power exceptional boards. Washington, DC: BoardSource, 2005.
Shared governance variables play a big role in the structures an institution will put in place.
• Size of staff/organization. Vanderbilt has a large inpatient OR with 39 rooms that used to have one large, ineffective unit board, says Wyatt. Because of the number of people and interests associated with that unit board, it was too hard to get consensus.
That board was divided up into three smaller boards, and in the past 2 years, these three have been divided up along service lines.
“After we redesigned our service lines into 10 PODs [point of delivery], we decided it might be more meaningful to have unit boards based on this same structure,” says Kazanofski (sidebar, below).
Key: MCE, Medical Center East OR; OOOPs, oto, oral, ophthalmology, and plastic surgery; FEL, free electron laser building; HGTV, hepato, general, trauma and vascular team in the main OR; EGS, emergency general surgery team; VPEC,Vanderbilt pre-evaluation clinic. Source: Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, Tennessee. Used with permission.
This made it so staff had a voice on a smaller scale, she says. “When you are in a meeting with a hundred of your closest friends, you may not feel like you can use your voice, but in a smaller group of 10 or 20, you are more willing to speak up.”
• Differentiation of practice. Organizations with unique specialty teams may not want to combine them all into one large unit board. They may all have different needs that will get lost in the larger unit board structure. However, Wyatt says, if orthopedic procedures, for example, are done in all operating rooms, one large unit board may work.
• Locus of control. It is important to have the locus of control as local as meaningfully possible. Wyatt says when they broke their larger groups into smaller groups, they also found that some large and small groups should stay together. For example, certain members of the cardiothoracic team also assist with bronchoscopies. Though it was a different practice, it was one room, so it didn’t make sense to break off bronchoscopy, he says. “You get to a place where it’s not meaningful anymore, so we kept bronchoscopy as a part of the cardiothoracic team.”
• Purpose or goals. Think about what the purpose or goals of a unit board are for certain specialty groups, and let that be the guide on how they are structured. For example, the orthopedic trauma team may believe their unit board’s purpose should be centered around inpatient case flow and how to improve efficiencies, while the ambulatory surgery team may think their purpose should be staff empowerment and how to reorganize their staff training process, says Kazanofski.
• Shared governance competency. The competency of a group has to be considered. Sometimes staff and managers aren’t ready or competent to do shared governance. The leader has to get them ready if the unit board is going to be effective and successful, says Wyatt.
Wyatt gave three components for an effective shared governance model.
A shared partnership for decision making and accountability between the manager and staff. Staff and managers have to take ownership of what they intend to accomplish through the unit board and reinforce that. “It is a difficult message sometimes for the staff involved because they are not used to owning things,” says Wyatt.
Shared governance has to be a partnership, notes Kazanofski. It has to be the nurse manager and the staff working together and using principles of partnership and accountability. “It can’t always be the staff coming to the nurse manager and saying ‘this is what’s wrong today and we need to fix it,’” she says.
The way a unit board functions depends on collaboration, says Wyatt. “It can’t be forced or led by a great manager, nor can it happen with a great staff. It has to happen with the cooperation of both, and that’s what makes it difficult to do,” he says. “Sometimes you have a dynamic nurse manager who wants shared governance, but he or she wants shared governance more than the staff does. So you have to help them grow into that.”
Mentoring. Because staff aren’t used to taking ownership, it helps to mentor them on the front end to understand how to own things, how to run the meetings, and how to manage the agenda.
Staff empowerment—having a voice. A big component of staff satisfaction surveys is how staff rate whether or not they have a voice in their organization. An effective shared governance model gives the staff a voice, says Wyatt.
Empowerment is a staff nurse satisfier, says Kazanofski. “I can’t make all the decisions about my staff’s practices. I tell them they are the experts in what’s going on in their rooms, and they should have a say in their practice. If there is a better way to do something, let’s bring it to the attention of others. And they like that,” she says.
When Vanderbilt began restructuring its shared governance model, Wyatt says he had to change how he gained staff input and feedback because his approach was not systematic. For example, if he was updating the policy for surgical counts, he would seek help from a couple of nurses he knew were interested in counts. “They would feel good about it, I would feel good about it, and I would check it off in my head that I had included staff in this process,” he says.
The problem was that there were about 500 RNs in the OR, and only two of them knew that he had included staff in the policy update. The other 498 assumed he had done it all himself without any staff input.
Using the formal structure of the unit board meetings to present policy changes and projects instead of one-on-one conversations is hard for managers who want to act on things quickly, says Wyatt, and it takes discipline to tell yourself, “I can’t do that, I need to work through the unit board.”
The benefit in the long term is that those projects are part of the minutes of the unit board meetings, he says. “There were no minutes of my discussions with those nurses about whether they wanted to be involved with the surgical count policy. There was no real proof that I was engaging staff in that decision making.”
Vanderbilt takes a very formal approach to the structural elements of shared governance.
Charter. Have a charter that includes the outlines and the boundaries of decision making. “It is really important to do that,” says Wyatt, “because there are things that are off limits for unit boards.”
They can’t make decisions about pay, and, in general, they can’t make decisions about the hours people work. They can have input on how shifts are distributed, but some human resources issues are not in their boundaries.
Collaboration. Unit board meetings need to be a collaboration between the staff, cochairs, and the nurse manager. That can be challenging both ways, says Wyatt. “You go to a unit board meeting and the manager is not there. That’s not shared governance. That’s a staff-only meeting. Other times you go to a meeting and the manager is there, but he or she is the only one talking. So it is really not shared.”
Managers have to learn how to work with a unit board, he says. That can be particularly frustrating for new managers because they tend to evaluate their performance on things they get done and the fact that they can do it. “We are asking them to not do some things and work through a unit board, and that can be challenging,” he says.
Meetings. It is important to have regular meetings with a formal means of communication to staff. That means letting all the staff know what the agendas are and what happened in the meetings so they can understand the decisions that were made.
Agendas. Mutually planned agendas by cochairs and managers should be distributed before the meetings. The cochairs and the managers have to meet ahead of the unit board meeting and decide what will be discussed at the meeting, what issues need to be resolved, and what projects they are working on.
Ground rules. Ground rules are needed on how to work together. Most staff have not had any experience in leading, so they won’t know how to interact at meetings or how to lead a meeting, says Wyatt. Vanderbilt provides in-services through its shared governance resources on how to do this.
In hospitals without such resources, it is up to the manager and the cochairs to discuss how they are going to keep the meetings from becoming “gripe sessions,” says Wyatt. “If you don’t do this, your shared governance model will fall apart,” he says. “You can’t allow one or two people to continually sabotage the agenda for their own motives.”
Consensus. “We believe strongly in consensus decision making,” says Wyatt. That means discussing something until a consensus is reached, which can be painfully long sometimes. Some things cannot wait for consensus decision making, but consensus is the preferred way in the shared governance model because it is the way to garner the most engagement from the staff.
Wyatt says it’s important to have a backup for when the group has to make a decision, and consensus decision making may not work. Before discussion starts, the group should agree to vote if consensus can’t be reached. Deciding to take a vote in the middle of a meeting when the room is full of people with strong feelings one way or another can be a problem, says Wyatt. “It is better to have the vote agreement before you have the problem.”
The biggest barrier to shared governance is having dedicated time for meetings and for work on projects, says Wyatt.
As an academic medical center, Vanderbilt has time available early in the morning on Wednesdays and Fridays. Those are the days in-services are done, from 6:45 am to 7:30 am, and the schedule starts at 8 am. Unit boards have the option of setting meetings during one or two of those eight meeting times a month.
Team members also have to be given dedicated time to work on projects, and that time can’t happen during unit board meetings. “That’s hard because all of our managers and directors have a guy like me who says, ‘we don’t say no to cases, we need to do all the volume we can do, and we will get it all done.’ This gives them conflicting messages about how to manage this. But it is something that they intentionally have to think about.”
Leadership skill sets pose another barrier. “Because many managers have a hard time learning how to work in a shared governance structure, you have to intentionally talk with them about how they are working with the unit board,” says Wyatt. “Once they get to the place where they understand it’s a partnership that will help them, and it’s not their enemy, it’s liberating for them,” he says.
A commitment to educating both staff and managers on how to work in a shared governance structure is essential for success, says Wyatt. Similarly, ensuring transparency about the process, particularly what the agendas are, is important. “Just plain old availability of information about what’s happening—that’s what’s needed for success,” says Wyatt. ✥
—Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN
BoardSource. The Source: Twelve principles of governance that power exceptional boards. Washington, DC: BoardSource, 2005.
Clavelle J T, Porter O’Grady T, Drenkard K. Structural empowerment and the nursing practice environment in Magnet organizations. JONA. 2013;43(11):566-573.
Vanderbilt University Medical Center. Shared Governance. http://www.mc.vanderbilt.edu/root/vumc.php?site=Shared%20Governance
Wyatt D, Kazanofski B. Innovations in shared governance: Transforming governance structures for maximum staff engagement. Presented at OR Manager Conference, 2014.
David Wyatt will be a presenter at the annual OR Manager Conference, October 7-9, in Nashville. Visit www.ormanagerconference.com.