Three new studies on reducing urinary tract infections (UTIs) were reported at the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP) conference in July.
Researchers identified several process changes that, once implemented, brought down infection rates. Each study and its findings are described below.
When the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston joined NSQIP around 2010, their UTI rate was an outlier. MD Anderson performs a large number of complex malignancy cases each year, many of which require plastic reconstructions. Need for renal monitoring and multiday bed rest are legitimate factors for Foley catheters, and a large number of epidural catheters also are used.
A multidisciplinary team assessed the NSQIP UTI occurrence data and found a 2.4% rate of UTIs (60 cases out of 2,500), including a combination of inpatient and postdischarge diagnoses.
Initial assessment determined that patients who developed UTIs had their catheters in for a median of 6.3 days, says Dr Thomas Aloia, MD, FACS, associate professor, department of surgical oncology at MD Anderson. Not all 2,500 had their catheters in for 6.3 days, but those with UTIs did.
In addition, some had a recent preoperative documented UTI, but they had no immediate preoperative urinalysis.
To lower their UTI rates, the team developed a quality improvement (QI) initiative they termed “S.T.O.P. UTI,” which consists of four parts: S terile insertion, T ime to removal, O ptimal position, and P roper sampling.
Sterile insertion. If sterile technique is lacking and catheters aren’t put in properly, UTI rates will go up, says Dr Aloia.
The quality and outcomes team found that OR nurses already had a rigorous process in place for catheter insertion. Every 6 months, nurses were watched by peers while inserting a Foley and signed off on proper technique. Although trainees did not have such a process, they were less likely to place catheters. “If you are unwilling to have a didactic and simulation training with certification for your residents, you should not allow them to put in Foleys,” says Dr Aloia.
Time to removal. The QI team held an unannounced 1-day “Foley Roundup” to gather data from patients. They went floor to floor in the surgical tower, asking patients four questions:
• Were you a surgical patient?
• When were you admitted or when did you have surgery?
• Do you have an epidural?
• Do you have a Foley?
They also noted the location of the Foley bag in the rooms.
This audit determined that indwelling Foley use was, in many cases, appropriate. Surprisingly, prolonged Foley use associated with epidural catheters was less prevalent than expected. However, the team found areas for improvement, including overall Foley duration and proper position of the urinary collection bag.
It was clear that in the majority of UTI cases, the Foley was a likely contributor, and many UTIs occurred because of long Foley duration.
In the beginning of the QI initiative, there was a push for a blanket order requiring removal of the Foley on day 2 unless the attending surgeon wrote an order to keep it in. The problem was that there were too many patients with legitimate needs for Foleys to have an automatic removal order. Also, not all patients succeed after Foley removal, and if too many patients had to have Foleys put back in, this put unnecessary stress on both the patients and the nurses.
“I would submit that those who advocate for a blanket Foley removal order have never had one put in while awake,” Dr Aloia noted.
Optimal position. During the Foley Roundup, 29% of the Foley collection bags were found to be improperly positioned.
When the nurses were asked why some Foley bags were placed below the bedframe or on the floor, they said that at night hanging the bag onto the bedframe causes a dependent loop in the tubing, which creates a sensation of pressure in the bladder. All night long the patients complained about pressure, so the nurses put the bags on the floor to relieve it.
Through collaborative discussions, it was suggested that nurses place the Foley bags inside clean emesis basins on the floor. This practice was recommended by the urology nurses, who typically drop the urine collection bag into an emesis basin filled with ice when they collect 24-hour urine samples.
Proper sampling. For proper urine sampling, it is important to use the designated port to aspirate fresh urine captured in a loop of tubing. Urine is never taken from the drain bag for testing.
“Since instituting the QI process, UTI rates have dropped from 2.4% to 0.8%. That means 450 fewer patients got a UTI, which saved the hospital about $1 million,” says Dr Aloia. “Overall, the S.T.O.P. program gave us a framework to identify the unique features of our practice that may have been contributing to UTIs. Collaboration between surgery and nursing, rather than mandates and policies, led to a dramatic improvement in outcomes.”
In 2010, UTI rates were a statistically high outlier in NSQIP outcomes at Sheikh Khalifa Medical City, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. Abdelrahman A. Nimeri, MD, FACS, FASMBS, chief of general, thoracic, and vascular surgery, gave the “Top 10” processes surgical services used to lower their UTI rates:
Assemble a team and pick a surgeon champion. Assemble a multidisciplinary team that represents the services that have UTI problems, and then pick a champion from that group. A general surgeon was chosen as the champion.
Perform a chart review. Residents, nurses, and others performed chart reviews to understand the reasons for the high rate of UTIs.
Three services—general surgery, orthopedics, and neurosurgery—were responsible for nearly 90% of the UTIs, and insertion of Foley catheters was the cause of almost 60% of UTIs.
Compare cases to best practice guidelines. The team compared the UTI cases to NSQIP best practices and put the data on a spreadsheet. They determined that catheter-associated urinary tract infections (CAUTIs) were the problem they had to focus on.
Looking at the definitions of UTI and CAUTI, they found a huge documentation issue. Almost 44% of UTI patients were not picked up because none of the staff wrote in the charts that the patients had fever and dysuria. This meant the UTI problem was worse than the data showed.
Start with the easiest problems to fix. Focus on the easiest process to implement first, and follow the results to see if it works. The team analyzed the spreadsheet and decided which problems would be easiest to fix.
“We didn’t want to ‘rebuild the world,’ we just wanted to focus on the simple things that we knew we could deal with,” says Dr Nimeri.
Empower the nurses and house staff. It is important to empower the nursing staff and house staff to implement the changes the team decides to make.
Decrease catheter insertions. Decreasing unnecessary catheter insertions was the first process the team focused on.
Education days termed “UTI Fighter Days” were instituted for the nurses, and an order set was added to the electronic medical record, which asks the surgeon or resident the reason for ordering a Foley catheter.
Standardize who places the catheter. When the team evaluated the competency of staff inserting the catheters, they found that insertion was sometimes done by residents and sometimes by nurses.
They determined that nurses were the most competent, so the process was changed to have only the nurses catheterize patients in the OR. Nurses’ competency is regularly assessed.
Automate the process of catheter removal. It is important to automate the process of catheter removal so the nursing and house staff don’t have to wait for an order from the attending physician. On the patient care units, patients with a Foley have an “F” sign on their beds. The sign serves as a reminder to those on daily rounds to ask if the catheter can be removed.
An automated daily reminder in each patient’s electronic medical record also reminds nurses to ask about catheter removal.
Follow UTI and CAUTI rates on a monthly basis. Determine a metric to follow monthly, and don’t wait for semiannual reports. The team decided to use the number of UTIs and CAUTIs per 1,000 Foley days for the metric.
Don’t be in denial about the results. The most important thing is to follow the results and not be in denial about the UTI and CAUTI rates.
“Once we actually looked at our CAUTIs closely, we were able to improve our UTI rates because we found the problem was actually catheter associated,” notes Dr Nimeri.
UTI rates in 2010 were 11/661, Odds Ratio 1.74 (CI 1.00-3.05), high outlier. The current rates are 7/1413 Odds Ratio 0.95 (CI 0.54-1.67).
Comparisons made using NSQIP outcomes data showed that the rate of CAUTIs was higher at Northwestern Memorial Hospital, Chicago, than at other similar hospitals—consistently ranking in the bottom 20%.
A multidisciplinary surgical process improvement team, led by Anthony D. Yang, MD, FACS, assistant professor of surgical oncology in the Surgical Outcomes and Quality Improvement Center, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, developed consensus criteria for the placement of catheters.
• For procedures that are performed in 3 hours or less, a catheter would not be inserted unless there was specific indication for it, and it would be removed in the OR or the postanesthesia care unit immediately after the procedure.
• For all catheterized patients, attending surgeons would decide in the OR whether there was an appropriate indication for keeping the catheter in place postoperatively.
• A two-person team would be responsible for ensuring that the placement of catheters adhered to sterile technique.
The process improvement program reduced the number of CAUTIs related to catheters placed in the OR to 0.4 per month over a 5-month period. In three of those months, there were zero infections.
The program also lowered the number of catheterizations. In the year before the study, 67% of all catheters in surgical patients were used in patients who may not have needed them.
In the 5 months after the study, there was a 12% decrease in the rate of catheter insertions, and a 6% increase in the number of catheters that were removed within minutes of the end of the procedure.
“Our thought was to look at what happens in the OR and how we can get surgeons as well as surgical residents and nurses to think critically about using catheters,” says Dr Yang. ✥