An estimated 126.6 million Americans are dealing with the impact of a musculoskeletal (MSK) condition, according to a US Bone and Joint Initiative report. That means, one in two adults in the US have gone or will be going through a wide range of hip, knee, shoulder, and/or spine procedures.
With the growing prevalence of MSK conditions in the US, healthcare providers might not be prepared to deal with the magnitude of the problem. As healthcare undergoes a digital transformation, digital health tools and collaborations between providers and payers will play a significant role in streamlining data processes. At some level, healthcare providers record patient vital information, functional improvement, and any surgical complications. Proper data reporting can prepare healthcare workers for the future, enabling better systems and processes.
“Surgeons, OR staff, and management often rely on imprecise and incomplete data to make important decisions,” says Vijay Yanamadala, MD, MBA, FAANS, chief medical officer at digital physical therapy firm Sword Health. “When we make decisions based on incomplete data, we do not know the impact of those decisions fully.”
Detailed data reporting for MSK procedures directly impacts patients and ensures they receive evidence-based care. Physicians depend on this information to make well-informed decisions, evaluate surgical methods, and offer the best possible solutions. Hospitals also utilize data for benchmarking, resource allocation, and maintaining care excellence.
Additionally, the research community depends on it for studies and medical advancements. Insurance companies utilize surgical data to determine coverage policies and set premiums. Medical device manufacturers need accurate data to innovate and improve their products. Regulatory bodies need it to set health standards and drive policy. Detailed data prevent errors, enhance the improvement of surgical methods and rehabilitation approaches, and lets providers assess their performance against established standards—guaranteeing the incorporation of optimal practices.
Electronic medical records (EMR) or electronic health records (EHR) software is used to record, collect, and report patient data. While most healthcare providers use the standard EHR systems to record and report data, more sophisticated software have emerged over the last couple of years. Hospitals may not need to replace any of their existing systems to acquire certain software, such as ThoroughCare and Spruce, as they are built to integrate into an existing EHR. While adopting such tools is not a necessity, it can contribute to surgical preparedness and improve patient care.
The long-term nature of many MSK outcomes requires extended follow-up, sometimes for a year or more, which can contribute to inconsistent data reporting. However, data collection comes with its own set of challenges and limitations, including low patient engagement, lack of educational capabilities, bad infrastructure, and the risk of human error.
“The absence of standardized metrics can hinder comparisons across institutions,” says Shriya Das MS, MSc, clinical project manager at Compass Pathways. “While ensuring patient data privacy is crucial, it can sometimes restrict data sharing.” Another challenge, she says, is the cost of data management. Implementing advanced systems that employ data analytics and machine learning technology can be hefty on the pocket. With restrictive budgets, hospitals may forgo the use of such systems.
Lack of familiarity—and subsequent hesitance—with newer technology among older generations of providers is another impediment. Legacy systems are widespread, and replacing systems that are relied on can be scary for providers. A team at Palo Alto Networks discovered that 83% of medical devices are run on outdated operating systems.
Discrepancies and gaps in the time period for which the data is collected can also pose challenges in care. According to data scientist Ben J. Clarke, founder and managing director of data management firm Cyan Q, with poor data quality, clinicians would be forced to either fill in the gaps or make decisions with incomplete information.
Sword Health collects data on Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services mandated complications, such as readmissions, cardiac complications, surgical site infections, and reoperations within the global period of 90 days. “However, very little data is systematically collected beyond this time point. We have very limited information on long-term safety and complications,” says Dr Yanamadala.
He also asserts that a lack of proper data reporting can get in the way of assessing the appropriateness of a candidate for surgery. According to a report from Forbes, based on a Harvard Business Review study, 50% of spine surgical procedures and 30% of joint procedures done today may be unnecessary. In the first year of the pandemic alone, 30,000 unnecessary spine procedures were performed. Ryan Grant, MD, a neurosurgeon and co-founder and CEO of Vori Health, says that very few people actually need surgery for back and knee pain.
Quality data allows for specialized care and empowers surgeons to perform tailored procedures and even prevent unnecessary ones. Dr Yanamadala believes that patients can undergo more appropriate procedures based on objective criteria formulated as a result of the collected data. When patients are better educated with more comprehensive data, they can advocate for themselves on whether a recommended procedure is necessary or not.
The incorporation of patient-reported outcomes (PROs) into care assessment is also substantial because it highlights how patients actually feel in the care equation. “Patients can increasingly feel confident that their providers are subject to certain standards when it comes to care quality,” says Bronwyn Spira, founder and CEO of Force Therapeutics, a digital care management platform. The company is rapidly moving towards a patient-centered healthcare landscape that is aimed at providing monitoring of patients’ rehabilitation and recovery.
Force Therapeutics’s recent report on the company’s virtual care management and remote engagement platform showed significant improvements in PROs. The report gathered data from 55,000 MSK patients in 25 facilities and over 200 providers.
The results emphasized the importance of surgical preparedness and patient engagement in producing positive outcomes. Of the patients who used the Force Therapeutics remote engagement platform, 95% said they were “very prepared” for their procedures. A large number of patients (85%) also logged their pain regularly, and 95% understood their postoperative pain management plans “very clearly” or “clearly.”
Force Therapeutics utilized its platform and patients’ data to improve customer satisfaction and communication. This speaks volumes on the potential of proper data collection in improving patient care. Similar to Force Therapeutics, companies such as AthenaHealth, Total Joint Specialists, Thoroughcare, and Mend provide streamlined processes for record keeping and integrated care coordination.
Eziah Syed, CEO of Mend, a science-based clinical nutrition formula company, shares how the company is creating practical outcomes through data. “Data collected in biopsy studies shows that the muscle is damaged in procedures such as total knee arthroplasty” (TKA), he says. “But muscle damage can be reversed using preoperative nutrition focused on essential amino acid supplementation.”
Patients experience varying degrees of improvement in functionality and pain relief postoperatively. The subjective nature of pain and functional outcomes in MSK procedures can make standardization difficult. Kenneth J. Kress, MD, chief of outpatient surgery, hip and knee replacement specialist, and orthopedic surgeon at Total Joint Specialists, suggests looking at data in the context of each patient.
For example, some patients may report high levels of pain, but their functional outcomes could be great, while others may never report high pain but also will not show much progress. At Total Joint Specialists, surgeons get a 360-degree holistic view of a patient’s pain, activity, range of motion, and functional scores. “Thanks to our digital infrastructure, I can get all of this information digitally without needing to see my patients in the office,” says Dr Kress.
At Aurora Health Care, a large part of patient care involves the use of physical therapy. When possible, the doctors would start with less invasive methods of treatment such as massage therapy, Feldenkrais, or occupational therapy before opting for MSK surgery.
“Overall, accurate MSK data are crucial across the healthcare spectrum, as data influence decisions, policies, and patient care outcomes,” says Das.
At Total Joint Specialists, Dr Kress shares various ways the staff optimize the surgical process from start to finish. First, the team ensures their patients are well-educated and prepared throughout the cycle of the surgical procedure (the procedure itself as well as the discharge plan). As a result, the clinic gets very few close-to-the-date or same-day cancellations.
“This keeps our operation very efficient and allows us to serve more patients,” says Dr Kress. “With more data at our disposal and strong direct communication tools between providers and patients, we know when to delay or reschedule a surgery ahead of time and save our staff time in educating and re-educating patients on their preop instructions.” He also iterates the importance of revisiting data and making adjustments to continuously improve care and the patient experience.
Force Therapeutics’s Spira considers data to be part of a large-scale ongoing shift in the healthcare system. “Providers have had to adapt workflows and implement solutions to support better data collection, and this has allowed them to gain greater insight into their own care quality,” she says. Spira also emphasizes the impact of digital health tools in enabling more care journeys to take place outside of the hospital.
According to Das, creating solutions such as standardizing reporting guidelines and fostering collaboration between providers and payers can also help streamline processes. The US Bone and Joint Initiative report advises clinicians to address data limitations in screening, diagnosing, and treating patient conditions. Understanding the impact of sex and gender in MSK conditions and treatment responses, as well as monitoring pediatric patients, can help assess the impact of MSK diseases early on.
According to Clarke, the whole design around reporting also needs to be reconsidered. A kitchen sink mentality, where more data is seen as better, is actualy counterproductive. “The data has to be created by busy clinicians who are rightfully more interested in their patients than they are in providing data for administrative purposes,” says Clarke. Consideration of clinicians’ time constraints and pressures can make them more engaged and open to constructive feedback. As a result, reporting will become more effective and intelligent.
Getting PROs more frequently is also an important consideration. Syed suggests capturing data that has never been captured before. For example, how much load is the patient putting on their knee postoperatively, or what are the reasons for visiting their primary care physician immediately following surgery? This type of information can help unlock new insights into patient care. “Remote monitoring platforms such as Upgraid that enable real-time bidirectional conversation with patients and monitor key biomarkers will be a major win for data collection,” says Syed.
Starting in 2025, any hospital under the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (IQR) program will be required to collect and report PROs. This includes PRO-related variables for at least 50% of eligible total hip/knee patients. Failing to report the data will result in a reduction in the percentage increase on annual payments. By reporting this data, healthcare providers should also see an improvement in patient engagement, leading to successful outcomes.
With millions of Americans affected by MSK conditions, the need for accurate and comprehensive data has never been more critical for better quality and tailored care. Proper data reporting not only prepares healthcare providers for the challenges posed by these conditions, but also empowers patients to make informed decisions about their care.
In the future, as the requirement to collect and report PROs becomes standard practice in hospitals, patient engagement and successful outcomes are expected to improve. Data reporting is not just a means to an end; it is a transformative trend that is shaping the future of patient care, research, and healthcare policy and should be driving continuous improvement in caring for complex cases such as MSK conditions.
—David Cotriss is a healthcare freelance writer based in California.
EHS Today Staff. Half of all Americans have MSK pain. EHS Today. May 18, 2022.
US Bone and Joint Initiative. One in two Americans have a musculoskeletal condition: